Kindle Freebie at time of download
This anthology of Christmas, pet or culinary themed Christmas cozies contains a little something for everyone.
MURDER BY PLUM PUDDING by Less Strauss-- 4 stars is the whole reason I downloaded this set. I love the Ginger Gold series and this is no exception. Ginger is excited to celebrate Christmas with her new family and show Scout the magic of the season. However, she's a bit wistful missing her stepmother and sister back in Boston. When Sally and Louisa show up, Ginger is excited to see them, until they announce they're staying with her! Ginger is planning a dinner party with an American business associate of her father and his wife, the Reed family and friends. Another guest is invited for dinner so the young ladies will have a single gentleman to fight over! The American, Mr. Doyle, may be rude and crass but surely no one would wish him dead? That seems to be the case when the man dies after eating a bite of Christmas pudding. Basil and Dr. Gupta are certain the death was not due to natural causes. Can Ginger and Basil solve the crime before Christmas is over?
This story is longer than the Lady Gold Investigates series and shorter than a full-length novel. It's a very satisfactory length but a bit too long to read in one sitting. I love how confident Ginger and Basil are now in their relationship with each other and how easy they share sleuthing duties. His respect for her is admirable. Scout usually provides some comic relief but he isn't in the story much. Boss, my very favorite character, does have a big role to play in this story. Louisa is back and as annoying as ever and we get to finally meet Sally. I can see why Louisa is a pill. I don't understand what Ginger's father saw in Sally. Sally is acting more than snippy, she acts suspicious. There's NO WAY Ginger's stepmother could be a killer, right? Readers of Ginger's Journal may be disappointed that one entry is repeated here but still it was good to meet Sally in the present and see what she is like now her husband is dead.
Newcomers include Mr. and Mrs. Doyle from America. He's a loud, crude man- the sort the English hate. He manages to insult Ginger and her guests while his wife is forced to put up with his behavior and apologize. Her brother, Mr. Lester, is also at the dinner party. He's quiet and a bit aloof. Mr. Lester doesn't really respond to Louisa and Felicia's flirtations. Mr. and Mrs. Davenport, friends of the Reeds, seem lonely and sad. They have secrets that could lead to the killer. Mrs. Davenport seems to be elderly, frail and possibly afflicted with dementia. They're a rather sad reminder that the book is set post-WWI.
I figured out which person was the killer right away and the murder weapon is equally obvious. Still, this is a fun mystery and fans of the series will enjoy it. Newcomers could start here if they wanted but I wouldn't recommend it.
SLAY BELLS RING by Karen MacInerney -- 2 stars
At Dewberry Farm in Texas, Christmas means mistletoe bunches, cedar swags and homemade goat's milk soap for the Buttercup Christmas Market. When Lucy Resnick and her friend Quinn hear shots coming from the ranch next door they are a bit worried for the livestock. Then the shots move closer into Lucy's peach orchard and the ladies become frightened and move indoors. The shooting turns fatal when a person crumples dead in the orchard and another person takes off running. The police think it was a random accident with the city folks staying at Lemmon Ranch but when Lucy has an opportunity to meet her wealthy neighbor and his guests, something doesn't feel right. Was this an accident or was it murder?
This series is new to me and I frankly didn't care at all about the characters or the setting. I'm not a farm girl and I'm not from Texas. I couldn't relate to Lucy or the other characters at all. Cyrus Lemmon seems nice enough but he and his guests do an awful lot of drinking before dinner. His wife, Lissa, is an alcoholic and an angry drunk. She's a nasty woman and I don't see their marriage lasting. The guests all meld together as faceless rich people. The way the mystery is solved is a bit too coincidental and quick. This is not my favorite story.
CHRISTMAS AT BAKER STREET by CeeCee James -- 3.5 stars
In this Baker Street spin-off, Cecelia is working hard to put grumpy Oscar in the Christmas spirit. When one of her guests ends up dead outside the B&B and the police threaten to take away her food license, Cecelia is deeply upset. It's up to Oscar to put his rusty FBI skills to the test and figure out what happened and help Cecelia.
I loved catching up with these characters even though I don't usually like elderly characters and elderly romances. That came as a shock to me. The last I saw Oscar, he was barely coming around and talking to Georgie. Now he's kissing Cecelia and they are obviously in love. It's sweet how her cheerful optimism can bring him out of his grief-stricken funk. Bear aka Peanut is hands-down my favorite character. She's so silly and cute. In this novella she has a very important part. I was happy to read that scene. Georgie is nowhere in sight and Frank only appears in police capacity.
There are several new guests at the B&B. Mike, the deceased, was a young man visiting the inn with his wheelchair-bound father, Steve. Mike seems like he was a slacker and Steve was tough on him. Steve is paralyzed from an accident and unable to manage without a caretaker. I feel very badly for him that his son and caretaker was killed. Steve is a bit tough and hard to like too and perhaps he was overly harsh to his son. Roy and Troy, businessmen visiting town, seem to have a lot of free time on their hands for people attending a conference. They don't even know when hey're supposed to be done. Maybe they're playing hooky or hiding something? Sarah, a college student, seems very kind and caring. Sarah is the only guest who is truly likable. Bobby and Brenda are newcomers after the murder. They can't seem to get their story straight and act kind of suspicious. They seem nice enough though and weren't around at the time of Mike's death. Perhaps they're just private?
This is a complicated mystery! I figured out one of the mysteries but not the whole picture. I enjoyed the puzzle of trying to fit the pieces together. One big mystery remains- what did Oscar do that his sons find unforgivable? A new spin-off series focusing on Oscar and his family will answer that question.
CAT'S PAWS AND CURSES by Nancy Warren I skipped this story. I don't do vampires.
MEOWY CHRISTMAS MAYHEM by Molly Fitz -- 3 stars
It's Christmas and clients for her P.I. business have been scarce but Angie and her sidekick Octo-Cat have still discovered their fair share of murderers thanks to Angie's ability to hear animals' thoughts and speak with them. Angie's Nan has a whole month of festive activities planned including pet pictures with Santa wearing outfits to match their owners'. Octo-Cat protests but Angie refuses to translate his grumpiness. Nan and her pup Paisley accompany Angie and Octo-Cat to the pet shop but Santa does not await. After a delay, Angie searches out Santa only to find him dead in the back storeroom. With the local police busy, it's up to Officer Bouchard, Angie, Angie's boyfriend Charles (a lawyer) and Octo-Cat to solve the crime.
The setting is charming. Even though I hate paranormal and find the whole reason for Angie's gift super cheesy, I enjoyed the concept. Angie is an eternal optimist with a sunny disposition. Normally I'd find her annoying but Octo-Cat's grouchiness makes up for it. I love his sarcasm. Sometimes he's a little too grouchy and mean. The author must be a cat lover because the dogs seem to be less intelligent or less developed than the cat. Paisley sounds like a little sweetheart but childlike compared to Octo-Cat's old man voice. Nan is irritating but she's fun and if she was my grandma, I'd be embarrassed but love her anyway.
Who could have killed Santa and why? The store manager, Shirley, claims the victim wasn't the man she hired and she has never seen this man before. Shirley is obviously defensive but doesn't seem upset that someone was murdered. She's the type who is more concerned about the store than the human. Andy Crawford, the real Santa-for-hire, is a crude sort of man. He's brash and kind of bullying. I found Andy to be a very unpleasant man. The victim, Marcus, wasn't a great guy but I feel sorry for him. Scott, Marcus's only friend, is also rude and unpleasant. He seems genuinely upset that Marcus was killed.
Which one killed Marcus? The solution isn't so easy to figure out and is rather complicated. I didn't expect the twist.
CHRISTMAS FUDGE FATALITY by Addison Moore -- 2.5 stars
Lottie Lemon is eager to enjoy the Christmas season with her cats and her two boyfriends. When she comes out to take a picture of Santa with her cats she unwillingly gets in the middle of a feud between her friend, Tamara Gray and Tamara's ex-husband's girlfriend Stacy. Lottie hopes the divorcing couple can settle things soon but when she sees the ghost of a French Bulldog, she fears the worst. Seeing dead pets usually means murder is imminent. In spite of extra police detail, Lottie finds Tamara's body lying at the bottom of a ravine. Everyone is certain Tamara's ex Scott is the killer but Noel, the French Bulldog is still hanging around. He wants justice done for his beloved friend and is eager to help dole it out. If only they can untangle the complicated knot woven around Tamara's life to find the killer.
I really hate ghost stories. I love animals so I kept reading this one. One dead pet didn't bother me too much because Noel seemed to really be alive. I did not enjoy the cameo by two dead humans and the references to ghost tours. It seemed fairly obvious who killed Tamara but there ended up being several suspects so I wasn't positive until the end. I wasn't surprised by the identity of the killer but the motive was really weak and implausible.
Lottie has two boyfriends and can't decide which one she likes better but the events of this story help start to push her away from one of her men. Everett, Lottie's good friend, is a better man. He's kind to her cats and supportive of Lottie. Even though he's a judge, he can't be unbiased towards Noah and some of that bias comes out a bit mean-spirited. Detective Noah Fox is kind of a jerk. He's a good detective but he lacks tact and sensitivity. I don't know why the cats like him better.
Tamara seems nice but what we hear about her after her death shows she is not as nice to everyone as she is to Lottie. Tamara is certainly vindictive towards her ex. Scott seems like a not-so-nice man from Tamara's point-of-view and even one of the other characters reveals hidden things about him. He has a nasty temper he can barely control and surely seems capable of murder in everyone else's opinion, yet when he's on page and accused of murder, he seems genuinely sincere in his innocence. Lottie thinks Scott's girlfriend Stacy is super nice but Stacy comes across as a bit mean-spirited. As the other woman she surely must be a villain but she does try to solve her differences with Tamara by speaking with her. Other suspects include employees and friends Bonnie Dupre and Joyce. Bonnie, an accountant, is not as good with money as she should be. She has a serious problem and a motive for murder. Joyce, a women's gym proprietor, is not the most pleasant person to deal with. She has a better motive for murder than Bonnie and she's tough enough to fight. Both women don't seem like killers but Lottie is convinced Tamara didn't just fall down the ravine.
Lottie has two sisters who apparently don't share her special gift. Lainey is a librarian of the modern sort. I found her a bit off-putting and not very warm. Their sister, Meg, is an ex-wrestler who apparently now teaches stripper dancing?! Meg is tough but more sisterly than Lainey. Their mother owns a haunted B&B and apparently makes a lot of money providing authentic ghost tours and pushing Lottie's baked goods associated with murder victims. ew. ugh. Mrs. Lemon also acts like a horny teenager. More ew. Lottie's best friend Keelie is crazy.
I didn't really like any of the new-to-me stories enough to want to read a series but I enjoyed this collection of novellas and was happy to catch up with series I have already read. I recommend this to cozy mystery lovers who read pet and/or baking themed stories and want some fun holiday infusion in their stories.