“You have a great year, and you can run into a buzz saw,” said starting pitcher Stephen Strasburg after the Nats swept the Cardinals in the NLCS. “Maybe this year we’re the buzz saw.”
I had just moved to D.C. when four months later the Nats won the World Series. It immediately was followed by a 60-day pandemic-shortened season, and then management selling off most of its talent. So I only got a glimpse of the team at the height of its powers.
Fortunately, this book is the answer to all my questions since then — notably, who is Patrick Corbin and Stephen Strasberg, and why does the team shop keep selling their jerseys if they’re not active players: Answer — which is one of the driving themes of this book — they had phenomenal seasons in 2019, amd were major contributors to the WS team, never to touch that pinnacle of talent again.
In many ways, Buzz Saw is your typical sports story: It starts with an odd cast of characters (the oldest team in MLB) and focusing on the “little things” aka fundamentals to compete with other, sexier franchises. It has dips and turns, and a hole to climb out of when the Nats started 19-31 (who doesn’t love an underdog story?), mostly because the old team was marred by injury after injury and a terrible bullpen.
The guiding force, which suits the narrative, is the steady hand of manager Dave Martinez and the shrewd moves by GM Mike Rizzo who leaned on “quality on a budget, reliability, some moxie, and some experience.”
The book then takes us player by player, chapter by chapter through different parts of the team and necessary background on some of the most iconic players on this team: the veteran and injury-ridden Ryan Zimmerman, the slugger and media-shy Anthony Rendon, the cocky young bat Juan Soto, the first-draft pick flamethrower Stephen Strasburg, the underdog and small-sized Howie Kendrick, and Geraldo Parra, who injected the Baby Shark energy into the ballclub when they needed it most.
Then for its second half, the book unfolds the drama of the playoffs, of four elimination games, of a team comfortable with trailing, and of the improbable bouts with fate that all aligned to give the Nats the title. Dougherty walks us through each series, inning by inning, stopping a while for certain plate appearances or pitching matchups, and giving us that sports-movie energy that defined the season.
By relying on a healthy mix of new school analytics and the old school eye test and traditional scouting, the Nats created a team with just the right moxy for just the right time to make a legitimate title run. With some creative and innovative management, notably relying on only 6–7 pitchers in the playoffs, the Nats avoided their shaky bullpen and won the games they had to win and stayed in the games they were within striking distance.
“Take one block out and the whole thing falls down. But keep them together, weather a 19-31 start, let the weight wobble, just enough to steady itself, and you get… well, you get this.”