This is one of my favorite cookbooks. So much so, that I don't even keep it in the book area with all my other books, I keep it in my room or near the kitchen, where I can reach for it easily.
So why not a full 5 stars?
Simply put, the organization of the content aggravates me a bit. When I first get a cookbook, I look through it a few times on the surface. The first time around, I skim and look at the pictures. The second, I read it for content. After that, I'm looking for something specific, usually while I'm cooking or wanting to try a new food experiment. Here's where I have a problem with how this book is organized.
If I'm cooking and suddenly want to look up the recipe for a cocktail, or some side dish, I won't be able to find it in snap, because the table of contents is organized by season not by type of food. So if I'm looking for a casserole, I have to actually sit down and read the TOC as opposed to skimming to the section that I need, opening it up and finding what I need.
Now, I understand, this book is based on the show, and it's not like any other cookbook- it reads a lot like the show, and is a cooking textbook of sorts. It reminds me of The Joy of Cooking in this sense. So I get it. But just because I get it doesn't mean it doesn't annoy me. Usually when I use recipes from a cookbook, I'm using it as a basic inspiration since I substitute a lot of ingredients. Sometimes I can't have something or sometimes, I simply don't have all the ingredients, and can't run to the market.
As far as content, this book is pretty excellent, and as I mentioned before; I was a big fan of the series. I watched it purely for the science and history information of cooking alone. Information is introduced in a manner that doesn't make me shut down and start daydreaming halfway through the page.
I've tried a few recipes, and they've worked out even with substitutions! So while this book really deserves a five; frustrating me while my hands were covered in food, and I needed to find something quickly, convinced me to demote a star.