THE ORIGINAL ‘RAISING A CHIMP LIKE A HUMAN CHILD’ EXPERIMENT
Winthrop N. Kellogg and Luella Agger Kellogg [a married couple] wrote in the Preface to this 1933 book, “It was in 1927 that the general plan for the investigation reported in these pages was first evolved. The idea was then entirely new to us. Although… studies of a similar type had previously been thought of but apparently never completed… At length, through the stimulation and encouragement of Professor J. Robert Kantor… we made tentative inquiries about the physical possibilities of a venture of this sort. Then at once the extreme difficulty of procuring an anthropoid ape sufficiently young to make the research feasible became apparent...”
They begin the first chapter, “Let us suppose that … a human infant, the child of civilized parents, were abandoned in the woods or jungle where it has as companions only wild animals. Suppose … [that it] grew up in these surroundings. What would be the nature of the resulting individual who had matured… without clothing, without human language, and without association of others of its kind?... about a dozen instances of ‘wild’ foundlings of this sort are known to history.” (Pg. 3)
They state, “Here… are two complete but entirely distinct methods of accounting for the same phenomena---the one according to the influence of inborn factors, and the other as a matter of environment… Probably most persons interested in this topic today would subscribe to … [the] compromise conception as … more likely to agree with the facts. To say, however, individuals grow because of the combined influences of heredity and environment is quite another thing from saying that one individual may DIFFER from a second individual because he has a different heredity or because he has a different environment.” (Pg. 9-10)
They report, “it would be both possible and practical, it occurred to us, to reverse these conditions. Instead of placing a child in a typical animal environment, why not place an animal in a typical human environment? Why not give one of the higher primates exactly the environmental advantages which a young child enjoys and then study the development of the resulting organism?... If such an experiment were to produce valid results, it would admit of no halfway measures … one would have to obtain an infant anthropoid ape, as young as possible, and rear it in every respect as a child is reared… the animal subject was to be fed upon a bottle, clothed, bathed, fondled, and given careful human treatment in every phase of its existence…. It would be induced at the proper time to walk upright… It would learn to eat with a spoon… its mistakes would be gently and persistently corrected as are the mistakes of a child. It would be made a thoroughly humanized member of the family of the experimenters, who would serve … in the capacities of adopted ‘father’ and ‘mother.’ … the animal would never be given the opportunity to learn any other ways of acting except the human ways.” (Pg. 11-12)
They recount, “On June 26, 1931, a young female chimpanzee [was] forcibly separated from her mother… This little animal, named Gua, had been born in captivity… She was turned over to the writers… [and] taken to their home, where her humanizing was begun. Her age at that time was 7½ months, or almost exactly 2½ months less than that of the writers’ only child, Donald, who had been born August 31, 1930… the close correspondence between the ages of the boy and the ape proved indeed to be a fortunate coincidence. These two individuals lived together as companions, playmates, and members of the same household until March 28, 1932. Their surroundings and treatment was as nearly alike as it was possible to make them… 9 months after the initiation of the research… the experiment was then discontinued and the ape was returned by a gradual habituating process to … the Experiment Station.” (Pg. 16)
Later, they note, “A question … at this point is whether Gua ever displayed anything in the nature of chimpanzee nest-building. When alone in the forest chimpanzees … break off and bend together the smaller branches of trees to make a basketlike nest for the night. Gua certainly had no experience in this behavior… Nevertheless, after she had been sleeping on a soft mattress for a few weeks, she began nightly to disarrange and disturb the bed clothing to so great an extent … that serious preventative measures were taken…. There was, as far as we could tell, no purpose or object to this behavior and certainly there was no observable pattern… in which she stirred the bedding.” (Pg. 52)
They recount, “We endeavor to compare the coordinated arm movements of the two subjects by placing upon their heads a small skull cap … at the age of 9 months [Gua] does nearly everything Donald has done by the time he is 18½ months old. She immediately removes the cap in less than 2 seconds after it is placed on her head.” (Pg. 65)
They acknowledge, “In order to encourage her to walk upright… a special walker… was furnished Gua… but the instant she began herself to move, it was always to scramble out of the device rather than to make it go by pushing with her feet… she never used this as it was supposed to be used until near the end of the nine months, when she had come to walk upright quite well without its assistance.” (Pg. 72)
They observe, “there was one aspect in which [Gua’s play] differed significantly from that of Donald. This concerns the EXPLORATION and MANIPULATION of new objects… or, if you will, with his curiosity over and tendency to examine things for their own sake… Although such behavior was not entirely lacking in Gua, its presence was by no means as common nor its development as advanced.” (Pg. 132-133)
They point out, “Probably the most convincing proof of the child’s superiority in imitation was his direct mimicry of the ape herself… the human subject picked up a great deal from her in this incidental manner… It was Gua… who was almost always the aggressor or leader in finding new toys to play with… while the human was inclined to take up the role of the imitator or follower.” (Pg. 141)
They state, “Our observations seemed to indicate that Gua not only sought social contacts, but that she was absolutely DEPENDENT upon them… a sort of psychological dependence, must surely have made life harder for Gua than it was for Donald. This consisted of an intense … impulse to remain within sight and call of some friend … or protector… she almost never roamed very far from someone she knew. To shut her up in a room by herself… proved… to be the most awful punishment that could possibly be inflicted.” (Pg. 157)
They note, “At mealtime, [Gua] would lower her head to the side… for us to tie her bib. She began assisting in this manner fully six months before the human was observed to make similar reactions. As might be suspected from this generally cooperative attitude, her responsiveness to vocal commands was likewise more immediate and more consistent that Donald’s. In one sense she could therefore be said to obey better than he did.” (Pg. 162-163)
They state, “In spite of the fact that … human children do not eat with a spoon … until around the eighteenth month, Gua had demonstrated considerable progress by the 13th month and was eating by herself quite well a few weeks later.” (Pg. 219)
When Donald was 12½ months old, “With regard to the number of NEW tests passed by one subject but not by the other, the human here takes a commanding lead… One of the child’s superior acts is… unwrapping a cube from a small bundle of paper… [and] inserting a round block in the circular hole …” (Pg. 260-261)
They admit, “Donald … proved before very long to be considerably retarded for his age… Indeed it can be safely said that neither subject really learned to talk during the interval of the research. No doubt the necessity of spending so much time with tests of various sorts was to some extent responsible for this retardation.” (Pg. 280-281)
They acknowledge, “We must confess at this point to a special training which was undertaken daily with Gua… to induce her to say the word ‘papa.’ … such [facial] movements as she made were never movements … such as one would make to produce the consonant ‘p’.” (Pg. 286-287) Later, they also admit, “by way of criticism… there is a strong tendency in an investigation of this type to commit the error of anthropomorphism, that is, to ascribe to the animal and to the young child adult- and man-like attributes which they do not actually possess.” (Pg. 325)
They summarize, “the child and the ape … acquire a great deal of new behavior which is the same… we can say: 1. That the heredities of the two are similar enough … to permit similar reactions to the same stimuli… 2. That the environment is the activating factor in bringing out the potentialities of the subjects for similar development.” (Pg. 309-310)
Later, they add, “another factor of great importance… consists of [the ape’s] FASTER RATE OF LEARNING… as far as Gua is concerned, an increased rate of maturation parallels … an increased rate of learning.” (Pg. 319)
For a similar and more extensive experiment in the 1970s, see the book, ‘Lucy: Growing Up Human’ by Maurice K. Temerlin.