What do you think?
Rate this book
Tsongkhapa: A Buddha in the Land of Snows
The new standard work and definitive biography of Tsongkhapa, one of the principle founders of the Gelug school of Tibetan Buddhism--the school of the Dalai Lamas.
In this groundbreaking addition to the Lives of the Masters series, Thupten Jinpa, a scholar-practitioner and long-time translator for His Holiness the Dalai Lama, offers the most comprehensive portrait available of Jé Tsongkhapa (1357–1419), one of the greatest Buddhist teachers in history. A devout monastic, Tsongkhapa took on the difficult task of locating and studying all of the Indian Buddhist classics available in Tibet in his day. He went on to synthesize this knowledge into a holistic approach to the path of awakening. In an achievement of incredible magnitude, he integrated the pivotal yet disparate Mahayana teachings on emptiness while retaining the important role of critical reason and avoiding the extreme of negating the reality of the everyday world.
Included in this volume is a discussion of Tsongkhapa’s early life and training; his emergence as a precociously intelligent Buddhist mind; the composition of his Great Treatise on the Stages of the Path to Enlightenment , Great Exposition of Tantra , and many other important works; and his founding of the Lhasa Prayer Festival and Ganden Monastery. This is a necessary resource for anyone interested in Tsongkhapa’s transformative effect on the understanding and practice of Buddhism in Tibet in his time and his continued influence today.
In this groundbreaking addition to the Lives of the Masters series, Thupten Jinpa, a scholar-practitioner and long-time translator for His Holiness the Dalai Lama, offers the most comprehensive portrait available of Jé Tsongkhapa (1357–1419), one of the greatest Buddhist teachers in history. A devout monastic, Tsongkhapa took on the difficult task of locating and studying all of the Indian Buddhist classics available in Tibet in his day. He went on to synthesize this knowledge into a holistic approach to the path of awakening. In an achievement of incredible magnitude, he integrated the pivotal yet disparate Mahayana teachings on emptiness while retaining the important role of critical reason and avoiding the extreme of negating the reality of the everyday world.
Included in this volume is a discussion of Tsongkhapa’s early life and training; his emergence as a precociously intelligent Buddhist mind; the composition of his Great Treatise on the Stages of the Path to Enlightenment , Great Exposition of Tantra , and many other important works; and his founding of the Lhasa Prayer Festival and Ganden Monastery. This is a necessary resource for anyone interested in Tsongkhapa’s transformative effect on the understanding and practice of Buddhism in Tibet in his time and his continued influence today.
480 pages, Paperback
Published November 20, 2019
50 people are currently reading
108 people want to read
About the author
Thupten Jinpa
80 books110 followersGeshe Thupten Jinpa Langri, Ph.D., is the senior translator for His Holiness the Dalai Lama and Pesident of the Institute of Tibetan Classics. His works include the translation of twelve books by the Dalai Lama.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
June 30, 2025
My first experience with Thupten Jinpa was many years ago when I went to the Indian hill-station of Dharamsala which is now home to the government-in-exile of the Dalai Lama of Tibet. The occasion was the Mönlam Chenmo, or Great Prayer Festival, a tradition initiated by Tsong Khapa, founder of the Gelukpa order of Tibetan Buddhism, the politically-dominant sect which had ruled the country from the time it was unified in its pre-modern form by the Fifth Dalai Lama until the Chinese invasion of 1949.
The Dalai Lama regularly gives long public teachings during the Mönlam Chenmo, and the year I was in attendance he taught for eleven days for several hours a day. The text he focused on was Tsong Khapa’s lam rim ‘bring, or The Middle-Length Exposition of the Stages of the Path, and Thupten Jinpa was the Dalai Lama’s English translator.
For many hours a day I say on the ground in a large stone square surrounded by hundreds of monks and thousands of Tibetan laypeople while the Dalai Lama lectured in his strong, melodious voice. I especially remember that every day very large vultures circled around the square for hours, giving me the vivid impression that they were some kind of guardian spirits.
Thupten Jinpa is uniquely qualified to render Gelukpa material into English. Not only was he a Lharampa geshe, with the highest academic training credentials available to a monastic scholar in the Geluk tradition, but he went on to earn a PhD at Cambridge, having written his dissertation on the life and thought of Tsong Khapa.
Tsong Khapa is one of the great religious geniuses of Tibet. A prodigious scholar and yogi, he wrote numerous groundbreaking treatises that set the pattern and agenda for subsequent scholarship in his horizon, not just within his own tradition, but to a large degree in the other schools as well. In particular, he catapulted the study of Indian Madhyamaka into the center stage of Buddhist soteriology and gave it a prominence that was highly unusual in his day, combining his close reading of the deconstructive, apophatic phenomenology of Nagarjuna, Buddhapalita, and Chandrakirti with the logico-epistemological tradition of Dignaga and Dharmakirti to form a highly-original synthesis that insisted in the ultimate inadequacy of all concepts and representations, on the one hand, and the absolute need for ascertaining that inadequacy through concepts, on the other.
In the Middle-Length Exposition, Tsong Khapa goes so far as to argue that an experience of nonconceptual equipoise that can arise in certain meditation practices designed to still conceptual thought only act as an actual perception of emptiness if the yogi understands that that’s what they are doing. If they don’t understand the madhyamaka reasoning set forth by Nagarjuna and his followers, then the experience itself is not liberative in the same way.
This very striking argument reminds me a bit of a story Miles Davis told in an interview. He said early on he was playing with a band and had a really great solo, and after the show one of the other horn players in the band came up to him and said “That sounded really fantastic - what did you do?” Miles replied “I don’t know,” and the fellow responded “Oh, then you didn’t do nothing.” That made a big impression on Davis, and he launched into an intensive study of music theory until he knew exactly what he had done in that solo.
There’s something of the same logic in Tsong Khapa’s argument, that all kinds of extraordinary experiences become available to yogis and religious devotees in a variety of ways, but the effect those experiences have on the experiencer depend not just on the experience itself, but on how they are valued, received, and understood by the mind in question.
There is a great deal to be said for and against this position. I love Tsong Khapa, and there are very few people who have exerted as profound an influence in my thinking and worldview as this master. I also love many critics of Tsong Khapa, and personally I love to critique his profound insight almost as much as I love to celebrate it. Figures like Gendun Choephell, Mipham Rimpoche, Gorampa, and Daktsang have raised countless compelling challenges to his approach, and I think we do have to ask just how much we can and should ultimately trust concepts, given the fundamentally-antinomian or apophatic character of Nagarjua’s message. I am not sure we can have it both ways.
On the other hand, in Tsong Khapa I see another form of an argument that I find so persuasive in Hegel, who also insists on the necessity of the concept, and warns us that if we try to relinquish positing conceptual distinctions, we end up with a inchoate absolute like that of Schelling, which, as I said in my review of Phenomenology of Spirit, contains everything but explains nothing
We can set aside some of the more sophisticated philosophical ruminations, though, and return to what to me is Tsong Khapa’s cardinal insight with respect to understanding Nagarjuna’s middle way - the harmony of dependent-arising and emptiness. As Jinpa makes clear in this biography, this insight was integral to Tsong Khapa’s personal breakthrough realization of emptiness, which he celebrated with his short Essence of Eloquence, titled “In Praise to the Conqueror for Teaching the Harmony of Dependent-Arising and Emptiness. This short, important text has been excellently translated with a commentary by Lobsang Gyatso, a former teacher at the Tibetan Institute of Dialectics, by the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives.
The idea here is that emptiness, properly understood, is dependent-arising. The fact that conventional appearances are able to function lawfully in accordance with their appearance is not in spite of their being empty of inherent existence, it is only possible because of their emptiness. The reason that phenomena are causally efficacious and have extension in space and time while conventionally retaining their identity is only possible because ultimately, our sense of them as conventionally discrete and autonomous objects is inaccurate. If things really existed as the autonomous beings that they appear to be, then they could not affect other things. This is the very point of Nagarjuna's many reasonings.
In this intellectual and spiritual biography, Jinpa goes through the main events of Tsong Khapa’s life based on his close reading of numerous traditional Tibetan sources. He traces out the main outline of the evolution of Tsong Khapa’s thought, and provides a brief secondary analysis and commentary on some of its main movements.
Of course, from our own historical perspective, we know this is highly problematic, because the Indian Buddhism that Tsong Khapa putatively reconstructs is entirely a Tibetan invention, one in which, for example, Chandrakirti and Bhavaviveka are towering figures who represented two competing paths of interpreting Nagarjuna’s thought. This is, of course, entirely anachronistic, and as I recall there has been no Buddhist in any time or place who referred to themselves as a Svatantrika-Madhyamaka.
I am not entirely certain who this book is ideally for - I believe both experts and novices will have problems with it. The novice is certain to be somewhat bewildered by the plethora of Indian and Tibetan names and terms, and the expert is likely to be somewhat impatient of the introductory way in which the core philosophical problems Tsong Khapa dealt with are introduced and glossed. I myself would have rather preferred a scholarly biography that assumes knowledge of Tibetan religious culture and history.
Jinpa attempts to thread the needle between traditional and rational-objective presentation of Tsong Khapa’s life, and he does often but not always stop short of attributing miraculous powers to his subject. But this text follows traditional patterns that I found somewhat distracting by the end. Jinpa’s Tsong Khapa lives in a world without money, patronage, political struggle or influence, violence, or women. He almost never raises the question of how Tsong Khapa paid for anything, or seems to acknowledge that some of the primary forces that shaped the evolution of Tibetan religious culture were not simply well-intentioned bodhisattvas in debate. This is a world without history, or a world in which history is somehow external to or incidental to the real core of events, which is apparently the unfolding spiritual drama of liberation.
Did you know that when the Fifth Dalai Lama died, his regent kept his death a secret for 20 years? He would tell everyone that the Fifth was in a prolonged retreat, but here are his orders. In order to maintain the illusion, he would periodically trot out an imposter who looked a bit like the Fifth for ceremonies or festivals, but when he caught wind that the imposter felt deeply uneasy about maintaining this deception, the regent had him strangled.
Anyone with a real acquaintance of the actual history of Tibet knows this kind of thing went on constantly throughout its long history. Monks waged wars, sects were suppressed, monasteries converted by force, games of intrigue and power were played by the all-important clans, and a savage realpolitik of patronage and violence was carried out with the Chinese and the Mongols.
You get none of this in Jinpa’s book, which projects a religious narrative of a pristine Tibet that I have come to find really oppressive. The effect of the book is essentially devotional, and it is my firm belief that Tibetan culture will remain a prisoner of its past until it can come to terms with the limits of its traditional horizons, and come to understand that history matters.
The Dalai Lama regularly gives long public teachings during the Mönlam Chenmo, and the year I was in attendance he taught for eleven days for several hours a day. The text he focused on was Tsong Khapa’s lam rim ‘bring, or The Middle-Length Exposition of the Stages of the Path, and Thupten Jinpa was the Dalai Lama’s English translator.
For many hours a day I say on the ground in a large stone square surrounded by hundreds of monks and thousands of Tibetan laypeople while the Dalai Lama lectured in his strong, melodious voice. I especially remember that every day very large vultures circled around the square for hours, giving me the vivid impression that they were some kind of guardian spirits.
Thupten Jinpa is uniquely qualified to render Gelukpa material into English. Not only was he a Lharampa geshe, with the highest academic training credentials available to a monastic scholar in the Geluk tradition, but he went on to earn a PhD at Cambridge, having written his dissertation on the life and thought of Tsong Khapa.
Tsong Khapa is one of the great religious geniuses of Tibet. A prodigious scholar and yogi, he wrote numerous groundbreaking treatises that set the pattern and agenda for subsequent scholarship in his horizon, not just within his own tradition, but to a large degree in the other schools as well. In particular, he catapulted the study of Indian Madhyamaka into the center stage of Buddhist soteriology and gave it a prominence that was highly unusual in his day, combining his close reading of the deconstructive, apophatic phenomenology of Nagarjuna, Buddhapalita, and Chandrakirti with the logico-epistemological tradition of Dignaga and Dharmakirti to form a highly-original synthesis that insisted in the ultimate inadequacy of all concepts and representations, on the one hand, and the absolute need for ascertaining that inadequacy through concepts, on the other.
In the Middle-Length Exposition, Tsong Khapa goes so far as to argue that an experience of nonconceptual equipoise that can arise in certain meditation practices designed to still conceptual thought only act as an actual perception of emptiness if the yogi understands that that’s what they are doing. If they don’t understand the madhyamaka reasoning set forth by Nagarjuna and his followers, then the experience itself is not liberative in the same way.
This very striking argument reminds me a bit of a story Miles Davis told in an interview. He said early on he was playing with a band and had a really great solo, and after the show one of the other horn players in the band came up to him and said “That sounded really fantastic - what did you do?” Miles replied “I don’t know,” and the fellow responded “Oh, then you didn’t do nothing.” That made a big impression on Davis, and he launched into an intensive study of music theory until he knew exactly what he had done in that solo.
There’s something of the same logic in Tsong Khapa’s argument, that all kinds of extraordinary experiences become available to yogis and religious devotees in a variety of ways, but the effect those experiences have on the experiencer depend not just on the experience itself, but on how they are valued, received, and understood by the mind in question.
There is a great deal to be said for and against this position. I love Tsong Khapa, and there are very few people who have exerted as profound an influence in my thinking and worldview as this master. I also love many critics of Tsong Khapa, and personally I love to critique his profound insight almost as much as I love to celebrate it. Figures like Gendun Choephell, Mipham Rimpoche, Gorampa, and Daktsang have raised countless compelling challenges to his approach, and I think we do have to ask just how much we can and should ultimately trust concepts, given the fundamentally-antinomian or apophatic character of Nagarjua’s message. I am not sure we can have it both ways.
On the other hand, in Tsong Khapa I see another form of an argument that I find so persuasive in Hegel, who also insists on the necessity of the concept, and warns us that if we try to relinquish positing conceptual distinctions, we end up with a inchoate absolute like that of Schelling, which, as I said in my review of Phenomenology of Spirit, contains everything but explains nothing
We can set aside some of the more sophisticated philosophical ruminations, though, and return to what to me is Tsong Khapa’s cardinal insight with respect to understanding Nagarjuna’s middle way - the harmony of dependent-arising and emptiness. As Jinpa makes clear in this biography, this insight was integral to Tsong Khapa’s personal breakthrough realization of emptiness, which he celebrated with his short Essence of Eloquence, titled “In Praise to the Conqueror for Teaching the Harmony of Dependent-Arising and Emptiness. This short, important text has been excellently translated with a commentary by Lobsang Gyatso, a former teacher at the Tibetan Institute of Dialectics, by the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives.
The idea here is that emptiness, properly understood, is dependent-arising. The fact that conventional appearances are able to function lawfully in accordance with their appearance is not in spite of their being empty of inherent existence, it is only possible because of their emptiness. The reason that phenomena are causally efficacious and have extension in space and time while conventionally retaining their identity is only possible because ultimately, our sense of them as conventionally discrete and autonomous objects is inaccurate. If things really existed as the autonomous beings that they appear to be, then they could not affect other things. This is the very point of Nagarjuna's many reasonings.
In this intellectual and spiritual biography, Jinpa goes through the main events of Tsong Khapa’s life based on his close reading of numerous traditional Tibetan sources. He traces out the main outline of the evolution of Tsong Khapa’s thought, and provides a brief secondary analysis and commentary on some of its main movements.
Of course, from our own historical perspective, we know this is highly problematic, because the Indian Buddhism that Tsong Khapa putatively reconstructs is entirely a Tibetan invention, one in which, for example, Chandrakirti and Bhavaviveka are towering figures who represented two competing paths of interpreting Nagarjuna’s thought. This is, of course, entirely anachronistic, and as I recall there has been no Buddhist in any time or place who referred to themselves as a Svatantrika-Madhyamaka.
I am not entirely certain who this book is ideally for - I believe both experts and novices will have problems with it. The novice is certain to be somewhat bewildered by the plethora of Indian and Tibetan names and terms, and the expert is likely to be somewhat impatient of the introductory way in which the core philosophical problems Tsong Khapa dealt with are introduced and glossed. I myself would have rather preferred a scholarly biography that assumes knowledge of Tibetan religious culture and history.
Jinpa attempts to thread the needle between traditional and rational-objective presentation of Tsong Khapa’s life, and he does often but not always stop short of attributing miraculous powers to his subject. But this text follows traditional patterns that I found somewhat distracting by the end. Jinpa’s Tsong Khapa lives in a world without money, patronage, political struggle or influence, violence, or women. He almost never raises the question of how Tsong Khapa paid for anything, or seems to acknowledge that some of the primary forces that shaped the evolution of Tibetan religious culture were not simply well-intentioned bodhisattvas in debate. This is a world without history, or a world in which history is somehow external to or incidental to the real core of events, which is apparently the unfolding spiritual drama of liberation.
Did you know that when the Fifth Dalai Lama died, his regent kept his death a secret for 20 years? He would tell everyone that the Fifth was in a prolonged retreat, but here are his orders. In order to maintain the illusion, he would periodically trot out an imposter who looked a bit like the Fifth for ceremonies or festivals, but when he caught wind that the imposter felt deeply uneasy about maintaining this deception, the regent had him strangled.
Anyone with a real acquaintance of the actual history of Tibet knows this kind of thing went on constantly throughout its long history. Monks waged wars, sects were suppressed, monasteries converted by force, games of intrigue and power were played by the all-important clans, and a savage realpolitik of patronage and violence was carried out with the Chinese and the Mongols.
You get none of this in Jinpa’s book, which projects a religious narrative of a pristine Tibet that I have come to find really oppressive. The effect of the book is essentially devotional, and it is my firm belief that Tibetan culture will remain a prisoner of its past until it can come to terms with the limits of its traditional horizons, and come to understand that history matters.
February 22, 2021
Given the centrality and importance of Tsonkhapa to Tibetan Buddhist thought, practice, and history, it’s quite surprising that there has not been a comprehensive biography on him until this. But even if there was, it’s hard to imagine it could’ve been anywhere near as good as this. Jinpa is so well suited for this - a scholar at ease with the material, a practitioner, and he writes very, very well. This is a great accomplishment and very satisfying.
Note: I am associated with Shambhala Publications, but this is an objective review!
Note: I am associated with Shambhala Publications, but this is an objective review!
January 3, 2024
It is so fortunate that we are able to read this glorious book on of the most important teachers of the era ❤️🙏
January 30, 2023
I have grown increasingly attached to reading and enjoying the genre of biography - especially of the great thinkers, philosophers, mystics and so on of the past- a genre I hadn't really found much love for until recently. I have read a few notable biographies- the ones on Einstein and Da Vinci and Feynman and Newton and Dirac and Kepler and Nietzsche and a few others- and I have always come out of such a book inspired and romanticised by the ideal of intellectual pursuits.
And with this book, 'Tsongkhapa: A Buddha in the Land of Snows", I have yet again turned my eyes back to my heritage. The gravitas of 'Tsongkhapa' in the Tibetan intellectual and societal culture is something one can't miss growing up as a Tibetan in a Tibetan community. But sadly, though we feel his brightness, his figure remains distant from most of us, maybe in an altar, maybe in a temple, but not near us, not in our minds. But this book aims, and in my humble opinion does achieve, to bring the Heavenly Tsongkhapa down to Earth, extract the human Tsongkhapa so to say, bring him and his struggles, and his pursuits and his wishes near to us, and still manage to preserve the divine figure he has carved on the Tibetan psyche.
Dr Thupten Jinpa, the principle English translator of HH the 14th Dalai Lama and an intellectual in his own right, lucidly weaves a truly appealing life story of the Great Master, philosopher, mystic, and the teacher that is Je Tsongkhapa. At times magical and mystical, and at times so close to my modern 'heart,' Tsongkhapa's ( Or Lobsang Drakpa's) story truly resonates in remarkable ways with the intellectual ideal.
There is a certain refrain of thought and ideal ever present throughout Tsongkhapa's life that speaks to me and inspires me. It's a mode of living, one might say, and that is the verse from his autobiographical poem.
"First I sought wide and extensive learning,
Second I perceived all teachings as personal instructions,
Finally, I engaged in meditative practice day and night;
All these I dedicated to the flourishing of the Buddha’s teaching."
This poem, the tibetan version of it, has lived rent free in my mind ever since I read it. I find it to be incredibly profound and inspirational. And in this story of Tsongkhapa, one truly gets the breadth and depth of the studies that Tsongkhapa does and embarks on to achieve the understanding he desires. It is truly marvellous. It is truly marvellous how Tsongkhapa in the 14th-15th century rural Tibet can endeavour so much for his studies when I just lay around my home in this comfortable world I live in. It makes me ashamed, but it also inspires me. This book alone has made me want to read the works written by Tsongkhapa and study more of his specific Philosophy and proceed in my life with a trained focus and determination like Tsongkhapa had!
One doesn't need to be a Buddhist to enjoy this book and appreciate Tsongkhapa's story and what he was doing- I am not a buddhist myself and I enjoyed it a great deal- as one doesn't need to be a Christian to appreciate Kierkegaard's Life stories and his writings or a Muslim to enjoy Rumi.
As Tsongkhapa said, one must seek "wide and extensive learning."
And with this book, 'Tsongkhapa: A Buddha in the Land of Snows", I have yet again turned my eyes back to my heritage. The gravitas of 'Tsongkhapa' in the Tibetan intellectual and societal culture is something one can't miss growing up as a Tibetan in a Tibetan community. But sadly, though we feel his brightness, his figure remains distant from most of us, maybe in an altar, maybe in a temple, but not near us, not in our minds. But this book aims, and in my humble opinion does achieve, to bring the Heavenly Tsongkhapa down to Earth, extract the human Tsongkhapa so to say, bring him and his struggles, and his pursuits and his wishes near to us, and still manage to preserve the divine figure he has carved on the Tibetan psyche.
Dr Thupten Jinpa, the principle English translator of HH the 14th Dalai Lama and an intellectual in his own right, lucidly weaves a truly appealing life story of the Great Master, philosopher, mystic, and the teacher that is Je Tsongkhapa. At times magical and mystical, and at times so close to my modern 'heart,' Tsongkhapa's ( Or Lobsang Drakpa's) story truly resonates in remarkable ways with the intellectual ideal.
There is a certain refrain of thought and ideal ever present throughout Tsongkhapa's life that speaks to me and inspires me. It's a mode of living, one might say, and that is the verse from his autobiographical poem.
"First I sought wide and extensive learning,
Second I perceived all teachings as personal instructions,
Finally, I engaged in meditative practice day and night;
All these I dedicated to the flourishing of the Buddha’s teaching."
This poem, the tibetan version of it, has lived rent free in my mind ever since I read it. I find it to be incredibly profound and inspirational. And in this story of Tsongkhapa, one truly gets the breadth and depth of the studies that Tsongkhapa does and embarks on to achieve the understanding he desires. It is truly marvellous. It is truly marvellous how Tsongkhapa in the 14th-15th century rural Tibet can endeavour so much for his studies when I just lay around my home in this comfortable world I live in. It makes me ashamed, but it also inspires me. This book alone has made me want to read the works written by Tsongkhapa and study more of his specific Philosophy and proceed in my life with a trained focus and determination like Tsongkhapa had!
One doesn't need to be a Buddhist to enjoy this book and appreciate Tsongkhapa's story and what he was doing- I am not a buddhist myself and I enjoyed it a great deal- as one doesn't need to be a Christian to appreciate Kierkegaard's Life stories and his writings or a Muslim to enjoy Rumi.
As Tsongkhapa said, one must seek "wide and extensive learning."
January 7, 2022
This book by Thupten Jinpa is one of the best buddhist books I have ever read. I am amazed at the amount of detail and lucidity contained within it. Anyone seriously interested in reading about heroes such as Tsongkhapa needs to have this one on their personal bookshelves. I have read it several times now and each time something new comes from it. Tsongkhapa's personal link with Buddha Manjushri is fascinating and gives us all hope in progressing in Buddhism. What a shame that Tibetans have had to put up with Chinese suppression for so long.
March 30, 2023
Amazing look to learn about Je Tsongkhapa and his legacy from Modern spectrum.
April 24, 2024
Sprawling in scale, great detailed development and history of Tsongkhapa's philosophy. Superb read.
Read
June 8, 2025I honestly didn’t think anyone would ever write a book like this about Tsongkhapa. It’s something to celebrate. Jingpa really did the impossible
January 16, 2021
Formidable portrait of the Great Lobsang Drakpa, stemming from a thorough research that Geshe Thubten Jinpa has clearly done on the life of the master, His character traits, His inconceivable virtuous activities in service of the BuddhaDharma and His undying legacy.
One of the most inspiring books I've come across in my life so far.
One of the most inspiring books I've come across in my life so far.
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews