This is a good book for people who need to declutter, and I am amongst those who do.
However, keeping a journal? If I wanted to journal, I would journal. I find it absurd to do that. But, for those who don't, perhaps it helps to write about what they are throwing out, or giving away.
I do like her having the piles of things, and setting times to do this, and starting in one spot, and moving on to others. I also liked that she suggested doing it in bits, taking 30 minutes to an hour for each sorting.
I am currently going through my late mother's things, and discovering things I want to keep, and things I never knew about. It has to be sorted, and there are the easy things to throw away, as well as the hard ones that I want to keep, such as family albums.
Life is not stuff. And it is because my mother, and her mother, and her grandfather hung on to things, that we have some of the things we have today, historic things, things that have been forgotten about, such as an original Mark Twain manuscript.
So, no, although this book is good for the mundane, and the stuff the people fill their lives with, and is often good advice, there are certain things that this book doesn't cover, such as family heirlooms, that are going to be a bit harder to get through in the coming months.
On the positive side, the book is a good size, and has a whole bunch of helpful hints. It is not meant for writers who keep old journals and old writings, because I have no way to declutter that. :)
Thanks to Rockridge press for making this book available for an honest review.