Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Knitting in the City #4.5, 6.5

Neanderthal Seeks Extra (Yarns)

Rate this book
From the New York Times Bestselling Author Penny Reid

A comprehensive collection of all short stories, deleted scenes, and special features from the Knitting in the City series.

Includes:
**Janie and Quinn**
-Deleted (love) Scene from 'Neanderthal Seeks Human' (new)
-Interview with Janie and Quinn (shared on a blog 2014)
-Short entitled, 'Neanderthal Seeks Honeymoon' (shared in 'Scenes from the City,' free or $.99 limited release 2015)
-Short entitled, 'Neanderthal Seeks Baby, part 1' (shared in newsletter 2016)
-Short entitled, 'Neanderthal Seeks Baby, part 2' (shared in newsletter 2017)

**Elizabeth and Nico**
-Deleted Scene from 'Friends Without Benefits,' Original Opening (new)
-Deleted Scene from 'Friends Without Benefits,' Not so nice Nico (new)
-Deleted Scene from 'Friends Without Benefits,' Hunting an Elk (new)
-Deleted Scene from 'Friends Without Benefits,' Original Confrontation (new)
-Short entitled, 'Most-Definitely-With Benefits' (shared in 'Scenes from the City,' free or $.99 limited release 2015)

**Sandra and Alex**
-Short entitled, 'Hacking the Hacker' (shared in 'Scenes from the City,' free or $.99 limited release 2015)
-Short entitled, 'The Junior Hackers Society' (new)

**Ashley and Drew**
-Deleted Scene from 'Beauty and the Mustache' Furry Purse (shared on a blog 2014)
-Deleted Scene from 'Beauty and the Mustache' Eavesdropping (shared on a blog 2014)
-Short entitled, 'A Winston Christmas' (shared in newsletter 2015)
-Short entitled, 'Beauty and the Beard' (shared in 'Scenes from the City,' free or $.99 limited release 2015)

**Fiona and Greg**
-Deleted Scene from 'Ninja at First Sight' Greg's Point of View (new)
-Extra feature, Greg's Valentine's letter to Fiona (shared on a blog 2016)

**Marie and Matt**
-Short entitled, 'Dirty Talk is for Parties' (shared on a blog 2017)

**Kat and Dan**
-Extra feature, Dan's Creative Curse Words (new)
-Novella entitled, 'Scenes from the Hallway' (shared 2018, free limited release)
-Extra feature, Dan's Valentines Letter to Kat (shared on a blog 2018)
-Deleted Scene from 'Marriage of Inconvenience' Crying Material (shared on a blog 2018)
-Deleted Scene from 'Marriage of Inconvenience' Astronaut Specialist (new)

238 pages, Kindle Edition

First published October 15, 2018

637 people are currently reading
4103 people want to read

About the author

Penny Reid

92 books22.4k followers
Sign up for the newsletter of awesome: www.pennyreid.ninja/newsletter

Penny Reid is the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and USA Today bestselling author of the Winston Brothers and Knitting in the City series. She used to spend her days writing federal grant proposals as a biomedical researcher, but now she writes kissing books. Penny is an obsessive knitter and manages the #OwnVoices-focused mentorship incubator / publishing imprint, Smartypants Romance. She lives in Seattle Washington with her husband, three kids, and dog named Hazel.

FOLLOW PENNY:
Facebook: www.facebook.com/pennyreidwriter
Twitter: www.twitter.com/reidromance
Instagram:www.instagram.com/reidromance

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,185 (37%)
4 stars
1,191 (37%)
3 stars
699 (21%)
2 stars
95 (2%)
1 star
21 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 241 reviews
Profile Image for Penny Reid.
Author 92 books22.4k followers
Want to read
August 10, 2020


Binge the entire Knitting in the City Series
Listen to the Knitting in the City Series on Audio

** EBOOK LINKS **
Amazon US*Amazon UK*Amazon AU*Amazon CA
Apple Books*Google Play*Kobo*B&N

Buy a Signed Paperback Copy from Penny's Store

Just as a reminder this is a comprehensive collection of short stories, deleted scenes, and bonus features! Includes all the short stories from Scenes from the City, Scenes from the Hallway, and a (comprehensive) collection of all my bonus features, stories, and deleted scenes from the series.
Profile Image for Kat.
Author 14 books604 followers
December 19, 2021
Yay!!! More Penny Reid!!! And all these extra deleted scenes from the Knitting couples I love and don’t have to say goodbye to JUST yet. Most of these are Janie/Quinn and Dan/Kathleen, deleted scenes from their books. My very favorites were the Sandra/Alex scenes. Squee! I am such an Alex fan and love my Sandra, and the extra bonus scene we got for them was such a great sendoff for this couple. I also loved the Ashley/Drew scenes. I liked how Penny provided a little explanation about why each scene wasn’t included in the actual book, and her reasoning on the Ashley/Drew scenes made sense, but still, it was nice to dive into the Winston family for those brief moments! Loved these!

Please excuse typos/name misspellings. Entered on screen reader.
Profile Image for alana ☁️.
1,156 reviews1,337 followers
August 22, 2021
LOVED THIS!! it's nice catching up with these awesome, wonderful, quirky couples i loved so much. definitely makes me want to re-read every single book again.
such a great addition to a series i will forever cherish. 💞
Profile Image for Eden.
1,677 reviews1 follower
October 16, 2018
I'm so sad this series is done. I love this group of women and men so much and hope they pop up in future novels somehow. Maybe their children? One can hope...
Profile Image for Antonella.
4,123 reviews621 followers
October 19, 2018


Extra....in Knitting in the City series....

Extra words....

Oh my.....




For all the fans of the great Penny Reid and this amazing series.....extra toppings...yeeeees




I always love to read about my fav characters...and I do love when Winston family are gathered also Greg, Dan & Quinn....swoon




Profile Image for Lauren Reads Romance.
448 reviews57 followers
June 15, 2021
If you’re thirsting for more Knitting in The City love, read all the extras in this city. So much good unpublished stuff! Quinn and Janie honeymoon, Elizabeth and Nico deleted scenes, Alex and Sandra 10 years in the future, Ashley and Drew luscious-ness and Winston Christmas, Marie and Matt’s dirty talk *tingles*, Greg’s love letter to Fiona, Dan and Kat’s Scenes from the Hallway.
Profile Image for Lady Heather .
1,312 reviews772 followers
October 17, 2018
My favorite parts of this ensemble of deleted scenes was Alex & Sandra and Dan & Kat's deleted epilogue role-playing scene.
The Best! <3
Profile Image for Kelly.
1,216 reviews15 followers
October 16, 2018
Loved!!

I really love reading all of these extra scenes from all of my favourite characters. Yes - I had already read the majority of them, but this was totally worth it just for the new content. I read the book from start to finish, enjoying scenes I had already read, and absolutely devouring all the new scenes. My favourites would have to be Extra Scene : The Junior Hackers Society for Sandra and Alex, and Dan's creative word list was hilarious.
Profile Image for Katerina.
799 reviews321 followers
December 1, 2018
I loved pretty much 3/4 of the random deleted scenes with all the couples.

EXCEPT THIS ONE AND GOD DAMN WHY DID IT GRACE MY EYES.


“Dan!”
At the sound of his name, Dan blinked, frowning like he was confused and glanced over his shoulder whilst I peered around him.
It was Tonya. Tonya from accounting on the seventeenth floor. (...) Tonya was also smiling at Dan like she knew him really well. Really, really well. Perchance even intimately. I quickly shooed away this unpleasant thought, but then my suspicion was confirmed when, upon reaching us, she lifted to her tiptoes and gave him a quick peck on the lips.


I’m sorry, the scene with Kat and Dan broke my heart so I now hate him. There’s another scene about ten years on where they’re married but STILL. She was PINING for him and she saw him kiss his girlfriend and no, I just can’t. Especially when she was just about to ask the guy out. I don’t like that shit in my romances. I HATE THAT. I DETEST that shit. He’s just a f*cking idiot. I genuinely thought that she’d just heard he was dating but she didn’t witness it. THAT I could live with. I’m sorry guys but if this was in the original book, I would have straight 1 starred it.

I would have been okay if she had a boyfriend and that’s how Dan and her cleared their misunderstanding. Like that’s how he found out that she can do monogamy and was jealous and confused. It’s just! It’s so annoying. I feel like a few of the guys in PR’s book have always been the mover oners or the person in a relationship when they meet their s/o and I’d prefer if the shoe was on the other foot. Mate it just pissed me off big time so I feel like I need to read something safe now because she liked him back big time and you know just as a human being I can’t relate to seeing the guy (I may prospectively date) have been with another girl. Not in my nature.
Profile Image for Jewlsbookblog.
2,209 reviews74 followers
October 19, 2018
**NOTE** If you’re late to the Knitting series like I was and missed a lot of these as freebies, I felt the price was worthwhile. If you were able to collect these through Penny’s newsletters and what not, then 🤷🏻‍♀️

I was lacking the Scenes from the City bits and decided to splurge on this ebook so I could finally read them. I loved the odds and ends that completed the Kintting series. I also appreciated how some scenes provided much-needed closure on some of my favorite characters and the what happens after questions I had swirling in my head.

After I finished the ebook, I immediately turned around to buy the print copy because 1) I enjoyed the shorts that much, 2) so I wouldn’t be scrambling to find a way to read the book like I did for Scenes in the City, and 3) I now have all the scenes and extras in one handy little place to turn to when I want to reread them.
Profile Image for Michelle Claypot_Reads.
2,511 reviews61 followers
October 30, 2018
LOVED everything about this. All the extra little bits from stories I already adore made me so very smiley. This was a great addition to a series I will forever cherish. Who would say no to more words from this group of characters. Not me that's for sure!
Profile Image for Izzie d.
4,298 reviews362 followers
October 21, 2018
This is a must read for Penny Reid fans.

I would recommend you read the original books first, this book contains extra scenes that were either deleted or not included in the original released copies, either due to length or distracting from the main thread.

Some of the work included has been previously available via newsletters and on blogs, plus the 'Scenes from the Hallway" book is included but there is also unseen, previously unreleased material.

Each piece of work titles with the couple it's about.

It is a delightful read, really funny, an excellent companion to the Knitting series books.



Includes:
**Janie and Quinn**
-Deleted (love) Scene from ‘Neanderthal Seeks Human’ (new)
-Interview with Janie and Quinn (shared on a blog 2014)
-Short entitled, ‘Neanderthal Seeks Honeymoon’ (shared in ‘Scenes from the City,’ free or $.99 limited release 2015)
-Short entitled, ‘Neanderthal Seeks Baby, part 1’ (shared in newsletter, 2016)
-Short entitled, ‘Neanderthal Seeks Baby, part 2’ (shared in newsletter, 2017)

**Elizabeth and Nico**
-Deleted Scene from ‘Friends Without Benefits,’ Original Opening (new)
-Deleted Scene from ‘Friends Without Benefits,’ Not so nice Nico (new)
-Deleted Scene from ‘Friends Without Benefits,’ Hunting an Elk (new)
-Deleted Scene from ‘Friends Without Benefits,’ Original Confrontation (new)
-Short entitled, ‘Most-Definitely-With Benefits’ (shared in ‘Scenes from the City,’ free or $.99 limited release 2015)

**Sandra and Alex**
-Short entitled, ‘Hacking the Hacker’ (shared in ‘Scenes from the City,’ free or $.99 limited release 2015)
-Short entitled, ‘The Junior Hackers Society’ (new)

**Ashley and Drew**
-Deleted Scene from ‘Beauty and the Mustache’ Furry Purse (shared on a blog 2014)
-Deleted Scene from ‘Beauty and the Mustache’ Eavesdropping (shared on a blog 2014)
-Short entitled, ‘A Winston Christmas’ (shared in newsletter 2015)
-Short entitled, ‘Beauty and the Beard’ (shared in ‘Scenes from the City,’ free or $.99 limited release 2015)

**Fiona and Greg**
-Deleted Scene from ‘Ninja at First Sight’ Greg’s Point of View (new)
-Extra feature, Greg’s Valentine’s letter to Fiona (shared on a blog 2016)

**Marie and Matt**
-Short entitled, ‘Dirty Talk is for Parties’ (shared on a blog 2017)

**Kat and Dan**
-Extra feature, Dan’s Creative Curse Words (new)
-Novella entitled, ‘Scenes from the Hallway’ (shared 2018, free limited release)
-Extra feature, Dan’s Valentines Letter to Kat (shared on a blog 2018)
-Deleted Scene from ‘Marriage of Inconvenience’ Crying Material (shared on a blog 2018)
-Deleted Scene from ‘Marriage of Inconvenience’ Astronaut Specialist (new)


NOTE/DISCLAIMER ABOUT THIS BOOK: This book will definitely contain content that you've either had a chance to acquire for free ('Scenes from the Hallway' and 'Scenes from the City' were both free), or 99cents (Scenes from the City was 99cents for 12 months to benefit charity), available in past editions of my newsletter, or available on blogs/around the internets. We've also included a few extra, never before seen deleted scenes and new shorts just for this volume.

If you opt to purchase this book, you will be buying something for $5.99 you could have purchased for $.99 to benefit charity (or read for free) over the past few years + 20% new content.
Profile Image for Cyndi.
2,450 reviews124 followers
January 28, 2019
I loved these stories so very much! As a huge fan (stalker) of Penny Reid’s I had already read most of these stories, but I still loved them! Makes me want to re-re-reread the series again and slip the stories into their slots. 💕
Profile Image for Charlotte Henderson.
58 reviews4 followers
October 17, 2018
So many things I loved. We got to revisit old friends, swoon again over what may happen in their futures, or just see things from different perspectives, or how they felt in situations we didn’t quite get in other books.

It was like the deleted scenes in a movie- and I read the header in Penny’s voice as the director commentary.

Best way to cap off a series.
Profile Image for Charity Chimni.
Author 2 books9 followers
October 16, 2018
Enjoyable! Loved seeing all my favorite couples for some bonus content.
Profile Image for Kat Cup of Tea Bookblog.
452 reviews6 followers
October 21, 2018
If you are a fan of Penny Reid's Knitting in the City series then this is a must read! It has all of the extras from blogs and other places in one book. Plus some fun new content! I loved catching up with all the ladies in the series. It made me want to do a re read!
Profile Image for Miriam Rivera.
509 reviews
October 17, 2018
Loved it!!

The author told us that this book was full of material we had already read. I love when an author post extras from their work in social media. This book allows us to keep it all in one place and it's easy to just open it up and read all the extra goodies. The new scenes are amazing. Love it All!!!!
Profile Image for Vicky.
2,144 reviews30 followers
August 26, 2019
So much love for all of them... Janie & Quinn, Alex & Sandra, Ashley & Drew, Matt & Marie, Greg & Fiona, Elizabeth & Nico and of course, Kat and Dan... although Quinn is the uberalpha, I have a deep and undying love for Dan. Sighs muchly. I also do love ALL of the Winston brothers... but not at the same time... that would be wrong on so so so many levels...

Happy happy sighs... and I would happily read more about these wondrous women... and their magnificent men.
Profile Image for sana.
385 reviews272 followers
March 14, 2022
“can you imagine going through life without ice cream and lobster? the worst.
maybe like . . . i guess . . . me going through life without you.”


dan's unsent letter to kat, greg's valentine's day letter to fiona, nico taking care of elizabeth and comforting her after her day at the ER, alex and sandra adoption and birthday scenes, janie and quinn honeymoon and pregnancy scenes, etc. these bonus scenes were so fun!
Profile Image for Mayedah.
374 reviews11 followers
October 18, 2018
I'll say it one more time... Needs me some more Quinn and Janie!! This was still not enough!
Profile Image for Patricia Noblet.
Author 7 books40 followers
October 20, 2018
I'll never have enough. This series is amazing, we became like a part of this big family, we know them, we love them... it was so hard to tell them goodbye at the end of Marriage of inconvenience. Neanderthal seeks EXTRA is the "more" we wanted. I especially like the part with Janie and Quinn and the one with Sandra and Alex . Thank you Penny Reid !
Profile Image for  tatiana ❀.
321 reviews67 followers
December 1, 2019
my babies :(

i'm only giving this 4.5 stars because because i wanted Marie and Matt (and Sandra and Alex, though there was more of that) content.
Profile Image for aniryllis.
953 reviews156 followers
September 9, 2019
After:

I left the best for last. Janie and Quinn's deleted love scene was everything I wanted. Wish it was in their book, sigh. They are still my favourite couple, so I had to re-read the other scenes. I missed them so much. I still hope Penny will give us Neanderthal and Human Seek Baby someday.

The couple I hate most, had the most new scenes. Figures. The only good thing about this being the ending, ending, is that I won't have to read about them ever again. As with Scenes from the City, I skipped their part. Thank you, but no, thanks.

Someone had too much and someone else had nothing. There wasn't any new scene for Ashley/Drew and Marie/Matt. WTF?
Marie and Matt had only one extra scene. Why did Sandra and Alex get a new one written for them and they didn't? WTF???
Marie and Matt deserved better. Much better.

Really loved to be back with Fiona and Greg, my second favourites. Grateful for the new scene, even though it was very short.

Definitely not worth the money, but oh, well...


Before:

I read almost all the extra yarns, in fact only 10-20% will be new content and it will cost A LOT ($6 for an ebook is always too much imo, more so if I've already read 80% of it...),
but,
BUT,

BUT!

One of the new scenes is the Janie and Quinn sex scene that was cut from Neanderthal Seeks Human !!!

FINALLY THE SEX SCENE WE ALL DESERVE

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Janie and Quinn definitely deserve it. I mean, I deserve it too, lol. I've been waiting for this moment since Penny Reid turned to the smut side.
There was no sex in that book. None. Not fair. Nope.

So excuse me, but

Image and video hosting by TinyPic
Profile Image for tai.
576 reviews86 followers
September 18, 2019
Instead of writing a review for this I will just share my ratings for each of the stories featured in this book!

I. Janie and Quinn
-Deleted Scene: 3 stars
- Interview: cute!
- Neanderthal Seeks Honeymoon: 3.5 stars
- Neanderthal and Human Seek Baby Part 1 and 2: 4 stars

II. Elizabeth and Nico
- Deleted Scene: Original Opening: 3.5 stars
- Deleted Scene: Nico wasn't...: 3.5 stars
- Deleted Scene: Hunting an Elk: 4 stars
- Deleted Scene: Nico calls Elizabeth...: 4 stars
- Friends Most-Definetely With Benefits: 5 STARS!!!!!!!! FAVORITE

III. Sandra and Alex
- Hacking the Hacker: 4 stars
- The Junior Hacking Society: 4,5 stars, so damn cute!!!

IV. Ashley and Drew
- BATM Deleted Scene 1: 3 stars
- BATM Deleted Scene 2: 3 stars
- A Winston Christmas: 5 stars!!!!! the winstons make it perfect, obviously <3
- Beauty and the Beard: 4 stars

V. Fiona and Greg
- Greg's POV: 3 stars
- Greg's Letter to Fiona: 4.5 stars

VI. Marie and Matt
- Dirty Talk is for Parties: 4.5 stars, i love Matt and Marie so muuuch

VII: Kat and Dan
- Dan's Creative Curse Words: So funny LOL
- Scenes from the Hallway 1, 2, 3 and 4: 5 stars
- Dan's Letter to Kat: 5 stars
- Cry Porn: 4 stars
- Astronaut Sex Times: 4 stars
Profile Image for Hijinx Abound .
4,921 reviews44 followers
August 23, 2020
I Love these characters!!! I keep trying to sort out which of these men I would steal for myself. It's been a tie between Greg and Dan. Don't get me wrong, I love Quinn and am entertained by Matt. Although I enjoy Alex and Nico, neither of them are my type. But I am almost completely positive that Dan is my man. And Kat could find someone else. After all, she is an heiress.
I loved these extra scenes because I am not ready for these stories to be done. This group of friends and their men have been so much fun. I love that these women are smart and capable and their relationships add to their lives not take away from it. They are all capable on their own as well. And their conversations feel like the ones I have with my friends.
Profile Image for Piper.
321 reviews89 followers
September 26, 2019
This was a nice way to finish up the series. I love that PR shared her extra and deleted scenes with her readers. More goodness to savor. 🥰
Displaying 1 - 30 of 241 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.