This is actually one of my favorites, but it only gets four (or 4.5?) stars for a few reasons. One of them is the recurring gendered nature of styles of foolishness. I am referring to Ann Soforth choosing to conscript the men of Oogaboo into an army and conquer the world, much the same way Jellia Jamb conscripted an army of girls to conquer the Emerald City back in The Land of Oz, their motivations being they are tired of housework. Which could be a feminist kind of thing, except it's not. They're both presented as foolishly stepping out of their places - they should be happy at home. Ann's army is not a serious threat to anyone, and we all know that it's ludicrous of the Nome King to take them seriously even for a second. (This is because women belong at home, not conquering the world.) When men (like the Nome King) lead armies in the Oz books, they are threatening.
And it's a weird thing, because for the most part, Baum is pretty good at having active female characters - Dorothy, Betsy, Ozma-who-was-Tip, Scraps, Eureka and the Glass Cat - with agency and unique personalities. Although so far in the series the human and fairy girls are all super pretty. Like, that's all we hear about, is how Ozma is so pretty, and Glinda is so pretty, and the Rose Princess is so pretty, and Polychrome is even prettier, and Dorothy is also fairly pretty, and together they're the prettiest girls ever, and they wear the prettiest clothes, they're so pretty. Because prettiness is a requirement for benevolently powerful women - if they're ugly, they're bad witches, like the Wicked Witch of the West and (in the next book, which I've read already because I'm behind on my reviews) old Blinkie. Also Eureka and the Glass Cat are vain, but Toto and the Woozy are affable. The Sawhorse is vain, but it's about his abilities rather than his looks.
I guess that's also partly an old-fashioned thing and partly a writing-for-children thing, but it still bothers me.
Anyway, now to what I liked, because I liked a lot. And honestly, he's better on gender than many contemporary authors.
I like that the fiercest guy in Oogaboo is a reader who grows book trees. Although also he's kind of a tool - "when we return to Oogaboo, I'll take all the marbles away from the children and melt them up and make, a marble statue of myself for all to look upon and admire." But of course he does refuse to attack the helpless ladies, so, uh, that's good.
I really enjoy the Rak, and also the bit that essentially his punch line.
Let's count the ways people have gotten to Oz:
1. tornado
2. (everyone is already there)
3. deliberately, via magic carpet - after being washed overboard in a storm
4. deliberately, via magic belt - after falling into the ground in an earthquake
5. deliberately, via sand boat - after getting lost on the road to Butterfield
6. deliberately, via magic belt
7. (everyone is already there)
8. deliberately, via magic belt - after being washed overboard in a storm
That was fun. Baum is leaning toward the washed overboard in a storm trend; he's used it twice in 8 books. That is 25% of the time! I'll keep you updated as I proceed through the series.
P.S. I can't believe he blew up Betsy's whole freaking ship and sank it. That is a lot of people dying! But of course this is not dwelled on.
Here's another thing Baum likes: picking plant person rulers when they have deliberately been left on the bush by their people. It happens in Dorothy and the Wizard with the Mangaboos and now in Tik-Tok with the Rose People. Maybe he thought he didn't explore the concept fully the first time.
This is the book where Roquat is renamed Ruggedo. Baum explains that he forgot his name after drinking the Waters of Oblivion, but I'm pretty sure Baum just didn't like the name and wanted a chance to pick a new one. Also, question: I thought the Nome King could do no magic without the magic belt. But suddenly in this book he can do spells! Did he go learn from somebody? Or what?
I love the part where Tik-Tok negotiates his salary. I love that when they're talking to the Private Citizen, everyone is like, "oh! you're Ti-ti-ti Hoo-choo! Of course!" because obviously they've all heard of him? I have always loved the maidens of light - I mean, as a kid I thought this was the most wonderful thing. I like the three-course nuts! I want them to grow in my garden! They are like the lunch and dinner pails from Ozma of Oz, it seems to be - yet a third concept he revisits a second time in this book! I don't understand why sometimes Ozma can wish people around with the magic belt and sometimes she has to rely on the Wizard to do a spell or ask Glinda to do stuff for her. There seems to be no logic to the system, except for Baum sometimes realizing that the magic belt is too easy. I really like that Baum has thought of the wireless telephone already in like 1910. I love the surprise about Toto!
As I said, this is one of my favorites.
P.S. Shaggy is still kind of obnoxious, especially in his behavior to Poly.