What do you think?
Rate this book


273 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 8, 2019
Spoilers ahead
Honestly, I didn't hate it, but I most certainly didn't love it, and I will probably never read a book from the Death in Paris Mystery series in the future - here's why.
I completely understand the concept of a "COZY" mystery having read the likes of Agatha Christie for years. Less overt violence, lack of over the top blood and gore, maybe some humor, I completely understand. But the fact that these two women are interfering in a murder investigation because they think they're better than the police and have the gaul to be upset and affronted when told to mind their business before they screw everything up is a little beyond "cozy", it's just stupid. Picking locks to get into suspects hotel rooms, going door to door looking for other suspects, lying their way into an apartment building and stealing evidence with no idea how to handle it is not funny, it's pathetic, and that's just a few examples. Then consulting their husband (no idea what he does for a living as it is never explained) and boyfriend (who just happens to be a lawyer) for advice on whether to hand over evidence, searching crime scenes with them, discussing the case over dinner, making phone calls ... how convenient and utterly ridiculous. I guess I just don't have the patience for that type of rule-breaker even in the world of cozy crime fiction.
The second problem with this book is in the relationships. Our heroines/amateur detectives extraordinaire Rachel and Magda have been friends for decades, yet they sulk and pout and fight like children over the details, the way forward, and each other's involvement in the ongoing investigation like a toy that OH BY THE WAY neither of them should have anything to do with. It's unnecessary tension and does nothing to move the story forward. Are we supposed to glean that conflict breeds cooperation or something? It became tiresome.
But like I said, I didn't hate it, because the interesting pieces about rare and ancient books appealed to my librarian sensibilities, as did the city and culture of Paris - one of the most beautiful and also scathing places I've ever visited. There was enough of that to keep me reading despite the lack of interest in who actually committed the crime. There was also an interesting array of possible suspects with stories and motives that were adequately described. If you like an occasional SAT word (e.g. insalubrious) and references to obscure poetry and authors to make you feel more academic, then this may be book for you, just not for me.
Thanks for reading!