I picked up this book last summer, at a local bookstore, with the virtuous idea of deepening my appreciation for my native place. And though the book did indeed quicken my enjoyment of home, it wasn’t exactly what I was hoping for. I wanted either one of two things: a narrative history of the valley, or a travel guide with interesting places to visit.
This book is neither. Rather, it is a collection of short articles, originally published in The Hudson Valley Magazine, and then compiled here in roughly chronological order. This makes it rather easy reading, since each chapter is only two or three pages, but it doesn’t weave the many historical threads into a tapestry.
Added to that, Levine clearly wrote these on a tight deadline. Thus, for research he often resorts to contacting local experts and reporting what they said. The inevitable result is light history. And the hokey, jokey style appropriate for a weekly column of local history became grating over the course of a book.
But I can’t knock the book too much, since I’m responsible for buying it without giving it proper inspection. And it should be said that Levine casts an admirably wide net, writing about geology, the Revolutionary War, the UFO sightings of the 1980s, among much else. It may not be the definitive book on the Hudson Valley, but it’s a good place to start.