I decided to read this collection from beginning to end in the order the stories are printed. They are not strictly arranged chronologically but they are close enough to get a feeling of their development from the 1950s to 2008. In the earlier stories allowances have to be made for the background images of family life. Daddy goes out to work while Mummy stays home to do the housework, the cooking and caring for the children, with the Women's Institute for a diversion if she must have one. Thank heaven Mrs. Armitage finds a wishing-stone in the story Prelude and adds magic to everyone's life.
The early stories are full of sparky magic and witchery. The children, Harriet and Mark, experience delightful adventures, often a little bit scary but never too much so. The stories are very fairytale in quality. However, as time passes, a darker side creeps in with unexpected deaths, challenging endings, dangerous witches and magic that can turn against we poor mortals. While an 8 or 9 year old reader would lap up Doll's House to Let, The Frozen Cuckoo or Dragon Monday, some later stories such as Kitty Snickersnee, The Serial Garden or Don't Go Fishing on Witches' Day would be better in the hands of 11 or 12 year olds.
My own favourites were The Ghostly Governess, a near perfect little ghost story which is not meant to scare but to ensnare one in a web of masterful storytelling. The ghost, a governess from Victorian times, does not appear to the children due to tragedy or to seek revenge. She needs only one piece of good news to give her a peaceful rest. The Land of Trees and Heroes is closer to a mythological tale than a fairytale. Mark and Harriet intrude on otherworld controlled by Selene and it falls to Harriet to try and rescue her brother after he falls under the Silver Lady's spell. It is traditional storytelling but of a very high order.
Goblin Music and Don't Go Fishing on Witches' Day bring in more emotionally testing moments. Goblin Music is about the Niffel people, a goblin tribe desperately seeking a new home. All goes well until, one day, little Dwiney, a goblin child befriended by Harriet and Mark, runs out on to the road just as a group of motorbike riders is coming. The result is so abrupt it is quite shocking in a story for children. Don't Go Fishing on Witches' Day brings in every parent's great fear. Mark goes out early one morning to fish and doesn't come home at his usual time. What has happened is all magical of course, but there is a spell when Mr. and Mrs. Armitage have to face the possibility that the real world may have claimed their son. It expands a fairytale to a higher level.
One other story I have to mention is Harriet's Birthday Present. First published in 1953 it does have a dark side to it. The Brothers Grimm are heavily involved as Mark is tricked into the clutches of a witch who loves children - ideally roasted with herbs and served with redcurrant jelly after peeling. Mark's mission was to find a present for his sister. So, after all the adventures, what was that very important present? Well, we meet Joan Aiken at her most playful at the end.
An excellent collection for bedtime reading or for settling down in a comfy armchair on a cold, drizzly day, pulling your feet up, and allowing one of the great modern storytellers take over your imagination.