The most recent addition to my collection of World War II historical fiction, The Long Path Home audiobook was honestly a really fun and interesting experience, mostly because the audiobook narrator did such a great job with old-timey accents (as well as European ones), and the plot moved so fast it was like a soap opera for my ears. But far and away the best thing about this book is its protagonist. Vi is simultaneously so fresh, clever, and relatable without ever losing her unique edge. Her backstory is heartbreaking, and yes, a bit Bollywood-y; but Vi's emotions feel so real that empathizing with her is truly effortless. I was so attached to her by the end. All I wanted was her happiness. She's probably the best-written protagonist I have read in a very long time.
There are some small things that add up to hold this book back from being 5 stars. While I think Lindseth actually did an amazing job capturing the atmosphere and lingo of the 40s, the plot and the characters are often a little too extreme to be believable. This can work in some books, but since Vi is so realistic and multi-dimensional she kind of makes all the other characters look dull and fake by comparison. A great example of this is her eventual love interest, Sergeant Ansel Danger, a name that is way too silly to ever take seriously. He is, for the most part, an incredibly flat stoic soldier archetype that is played completely straight, which makes him an absolutely terrible match for Vi. I only started warming up to him by Chapter 31, because he dropped some real truth bombs in that chapter and brought the important theme of self-forgiveness up for Vi's character development, not because I liked anything about him, really.
Sergeant Danger became a persistent problem for me because Vi's story could never be fulfilled by a love interest. Mostly the tension that needed to be resolved was between her and her family, especially her older sister and her young son. This is where the story started and it is also where it ended. So seducing Ansel is a side quest, at best. But the amount of time spent on it is a bit egregious, especially considering that Vi's friendship with Marcie, which is far more integral to the plot, is completely sidelined for the romance. I never truly believed that Vi was close to Marcie because Sergeant Danger is constantly getting in the way and the reader never gets to spend any time with her.
Now I understand this all sounds very harsh for a 4-star review, so I do want to clarify that while the plot is melodramatic, it's also compelling. And though Sergeant Danger is boring, he is also very benign. Nothing is done badly. It can just be done better. Lindseth's potential is huge, so I hope she keeps writing, because I want more.