In a world all too familiar with environmental disasters, Horst Kornberger argues that the bee crisis is a more significant problem than deforestation, pollution and global warming put together, as it points to the causes behind all these. Global Hive is a rallying cry for a new understanding of world ecology. More than a study of bees, this book offers both an entirely new way of thinking about the bee crisis and its causes, and a way to use the crisis to explore wider social and ecological issues. Kornberger challenges the dominant scientific worldview that reduces everything to minute detail and fails to see the larger holistic picture. He argues that we urgently need to start thinking about ecology in a different way – by developing a new science which draws on empathy and imagination – if we want to mend our relationship with the natural world. From this perspective, the worldwide threat of the bee crisis becomes a starting point for global change. Global Hive is a thought-provoking treatise on what colony collapse teaches us about our society, our choices and how we can build a more sustainable world.
2.5 rounded up. I really liked the basic premise of this book - we need to have a more compassionate and empathetic relationship with ecology. This is something I can completely get behind and I think the author does a good job of explaining its necessity and how our current views are creating the climate crisis. I also really liked the notion that we are too often stuck in these exploitative patterns due to a lack of collective imagination.
However, once Kornberger starts to break down his arguments it all falls apart for me. The first issue I have is that his starting argument is that colony collapse is a result of abusing queen bees and the synthetic nature of modern day bee keeping hives. However, he never actually proves this. This pattern seemed to continue throughout the book as Kornberger made claim after claim to support his larger argument but never backed any of them up.
Two chapters I especially took issue with were Global Hive and Imaginal Literacy. In Global Hive, Kornberger acknowledges the inherent exploitative nature of our current economic system but his solution is to be better capitalist and buy things with green labels? Presenting better buying choices as a solution to climate collapse totally ignores the wild amounts of money that goes into hiding the environmental impact of what is being marketed to us and the fact that much of the world isn’t in a position to make these kinds of choices. The solution to over consumerism isn’t consumption. When it comes to Imaginal Literacy, anytime a book is like “this is just like Harry Potter!” It’s an immediate red flag.
Overall, great concept but the execution could’ve been much more convincing.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.