This book was a very entertaining and nostalgic trip down memory lane. Raftery certainly provides a robust number of exceptional films that made 1999 a great year for movies, examining their importance through the cultural context of the time as well as their lingering influence on films to come in later years. Among others, this year brought along such classics as "Office Space," "The Sixth Sense," "Fight Club," The Matrix," and many more. It was a year in which some of today's most celebrated directors - such as David Fincher, Alexander Payne, Wes Anderson, and David O. Russell to name a few - started to gain traction (even if their work wasn't fully appreciated at the time).
As a whole, the book is very well-researched with some great quotes from various people involved in the making of the films cited. Raftery is clearly very invested in this subject, and his passion for cinema undeniable, which makes this a pretty fun read overall. Though I admit that I'm not a huge fan of all the movies referenced in here - I'm looking at you "Cruel Intentions" - I would say that even the chapters on subjects I was not initially as enthused about turned out to be at least fairly amusing and informative in all sorts of ways.
Most of my gripes with this book are not really gripes at all but just a desire for more. For instance, now I want a whole book on Mike Judge, or maybe a work on classics a la "Fight Club" that initially failed due to misleading marketing. Certainly, a logical next step for Raftery might be to write a book about the worst movie year ever. I'd definitely be interested to read what he might come up with for that.
Something else I wanted when I came to this book's conclusion was some more in-depth conversation on other years in film. While Raftery makes a strong case for 1999 being a very good year for film, he does not really bring up many other strong years as points for comparison - this might be one way he could have made an even stronger case for 1999. He leaves the ultimate decision up to those readers who are willing to investigate the matter further. When I finished this book, I felt that I was up to the task of poring through Wikipedia lists of films by year to see if 1999 was, in fact, the best year in film. My conclusion was that it very well might have been, but, for argument's sake, I just thought I'd offer up a few years to serve as possible counterpoints.
1984:
High Performers - Ghostbusters, The Karate Kid, Beverly Hills Cop (Eddie Murphy really takes off), Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, Gremlins (also a cult classic), Police Academy, Footloose (Kevin Bacon's breakout film), Romancing the Stone, and Splash (breakout role for Tom Hanks).
Other Noteworthy Films: Amadeus (won Academy Award), The Terminator (James Cameron's first big directorial feature), Repo Man (cult classic), Paris, Texas (one of my personal favorites), This is Spinal Tap (cult classic), Sixteen Candles (coming-of-age classic and first directorial effort by John Hughes), The Natural (classic sports film), Once Upon a Time in America (epic crime drama and Sergio Leone's last film), Top Secret! (cult classic), Bachelor Party (also one of the films that helped introduce Tom Hanks to the world), The NeverEnding Story, Revenge of the Nerds (cult classic), Purple Rain AND Stop Making Sense (two of the greatest music films of all time), A Nightmare on Elm Street (horror/cult classic; Johnny Depp's film debut), and Dune (cult classic), Blood Simple (directorial debut for Coen Brothers; feature film debut of Frances McDormand).
1994:
High Performers: The Lion King (is there a more famous Disney movie?), Forrest Gump, True Lies, The Mask (Jim Carrey breakout role), Speed (Sandra Bullock breakthrough role), Dumb and Dumber (another huge movie that helped introduce Jim Carrey), Four Weddings and a Funeral, Interview with the Vampire (Kirsten Dunst breakthrough role), Clear and Present Danger, Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (Jim Carrey AGAIN!?!).
Other Noteworthy Films: Pulp Fiction (widely hailed as one of the greatest film's of all time; helped further establish Quentin Tarantino's reputation as a great writer-director), The Shawshank Redemption (possibly the best Stephen King film adaptation?), Quiz Show, Ed Wood (cult classic), Reality Bites (cult classic), D2: The Mighty Ducks (maybe not as important as some of these other films though it holds a special place in my heart; if nothing else, it seemed to proliferate a short-lived street hockey craze), Maverick, Angels in the Outfield (another sentimental favorite perhaps), Natural Born Killers (cult classic; subject of some controversy), The Next Karate Kid (breakthrough role for multiple Academy Award-winner Hilary Swank), Leon: The Professional (cult classic; motion picture debut of Natalie Portman), The Santa Clause, Miracle on 34th Street, Hoop Dreams (one of the greatest documentaries of all time), Crumb (another great documentary).
2004:
High Performers: Shrek 2, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (best Harry Potter in my opinion), Spider-Man 2 (best Marvel superhero film in my opinion), The Incredibles (best Pixar film in my opinion; also one of the best superhero films in general), The Passion of the Christ (while I've never actually seen it, I recall this one making quite a splash at the time), The Day After Tomorrow (the film that finally brought us to our senses regarding global warming - Not!), Meet the Fockers, Troy.
Other Noteworthy Films: Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (one of my personal favorites), The Aviator, Ray, Sideways (maybe even a better Alexander Payne film than Election?), Million Dollar Baby, Hotel Rwanda, Collateral (a good year for Jamie Foxx), Closer, The Motorcycle Diaries, Maria Full of Grace, Super Size Me (big documentary), Miracle (classic sports flick), Hellboy (another pretty good pre-MCU comic book film), Kill Bill: Volume 2, Mean Girls (cult classic; endlessly quotable film; peak-Lohan; Amanda Seyfried's film debut; breakout role for Lizzy Caplan; one of Rachel McAdams' two breakout roles of the year; continued momentum for SNL greats Tina Fey and Amy Poehler), Napoleon Dynamite (another cult classic and endlessly quotable movie), Dodgeball, The Notebook (another breakout role for Rachel McAdams as well as Ryan Gosling), Anchorman (another endlessly quotable comedy classic), Garden State (surprisingly successful directorial debut by Zach Braff; awesome soundtrack that introduced a lot of people to The Shins; Natalie Portman plays a character who ends up becoming a classic example of the Manic Pixie Dream Girl trope), Harold & Kumar Go To White Castle (a successful comedy that boosted the profiles of its two leads, John Cho and Kal Penn; helped revitalize the career of Neil Patrick Harris), Layer Cake (a film that starred Daniel Craig that is often cited as the motivating factor that led to him being cast as James Bond), I Heart Huckabees (great, underrated David O. Russell film), Friday Night Lights, Team America: World Police, Saw (James Wan directorial debut that started a new, wildly successful horror franchise), Kung Fu Hustle, The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou.
2007:
High Performers: Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End, Harry potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Spider-Man 3, Shrek the Third, Transformers, Ratatouille, I Am Legend, The Simpsons Movie.
Other Noteworthy Films: No Country for Old Men (winner of the Best Picture award in a very stacked year), There Will Be Blood (While I love No Country, I personally think this is the better film; it might be my favorite film of the 21st century actually), Atonement (also nominated for Best Picture; breakout role for Saoirse Ronan), Juno (also nominated for Best Picture; breakout role for Ellen Page), Michael Clayton (also nominated for Best Picture), Away from Her, The Savages, Sweeney Todd, Eastern Promises, The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, Into the Wild, I'm Not There, American Gangster, Gone Baby Gone (Ben Affleck directorial debut), Lars and the Real Girl, Once, The Lives of Others, Zodiac, 300, The Lookout (underrated film starring Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Jeff Daniels), Grindhouse (interesting double feature movie event even if it ultimately was not the best work of either Robert Rodriguez or Quentin Tarantino), Hot Fuzz, Waitress, Knocked Up (breakthrough role for Seth Rogen), Live Free or Die Hard, Hairspray, Hot Rod (cult classic), Superbad (comedy classic; Jonah Hill breakthrough role; Emma Stone breakthrough role), 3:10 to Yuma (pretty great adaptation of Elmore Leonard Western story), Across the Universe, Before the Devil Knows You're Dead (final Sidney Lumet feature film), Enchanted (Amy Adams' first major success as lead actress), Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story.