I’m Susie O'Brien's mother, so this review won’t be impartial, but I don’t think that matters. I loved Susie's book and I’d like to explain why.
I’m clearly not the intended audience, but I found a detailed, thoughtful and often hilarious picture of how a parent a generation on from me approaches the difficulties and challenges as well as the joys of modern parenting.
Susie's views are informed by her upbringing; her deep involvement in the school, sporting and social lives of her three children; her work as a journalist who has researched and reported on many aspects of current child-rearing practices, drawing on both academic research and social media; and, not least, by her wide circle of friends who share their lives as modern parents. Above all, she brings to her subject a mix of humour, practicality and compassion that I find particularly appealing.
Susie draws on very funny recollections of her own childhood, lived in the 70s and 80s, as she explains, in small outback mining towns, and then in suburban Adelaide. She's not the only commentator to draw attention to the comparative freedom of children in earlier decades. It wasn’t perfect of course, and Susie doesn’t pretend it was. She points out for example that many modern restrictions from seat belts to concerns about bodily integrity have improved safety and happiness for everyone.
Susie's main concern with life today is the intensification of child-rearing: the division of children's lives into an increasing number of segments, each of which needs to be overseen by parents (mothers, mostly, society being the way it is). Her argument, drawing on her observations of everyday life, academic research and her acquaintance with parenting blogs, is that many parents today feel guilty that they are failing to maintain the required control over their children's lives. Her counter to this is that parents should let go of the guilt, reject impossibly high standards and instead focus on the enjoyment to be had from bringing up children.
It’s her humour, her refusal to take herself or anyone else too seriously, her requirement that child rearing be as satisfying as possible for parents and children, that I find so enjoyable. She might seem flippant and overly critical of current preoccupations but there is always a serious purpose. For example, you don’t have to agree with all her criticisms of current schooling to find plenty to ponder.
The second half goes beyond fault-finding to suggesting “How-tos” and “Half-arsed solutions”. For example, Susie ruthlessly exposes the pretensions of social media performers and suggests that half-arsed mothers get on with life, pleasing themselves, enjoying their children, doing their best and being realistic about what is possible. There are lots of anecdotes from parents who have done their best to avoid impossible expectations, and advice from researchers who emphasise the value of talking with children, of spending relaxed time with them, rather than over-scheduling their lives.
These paragraph headings give an idea of Susie's approach: Embrace the mess ... Vegemite pasta and other half-arsed dinners .... Let them play .... Let them get bored. Sooooo bored.
This is a very funny book about a serious topic. There are hilarious anecdotes, witty take-downs of social media personalities, reminders about movies and social media sites where mothers and fathers fail to take themselves seriously, reassurances that to be less than perfect is unlikely to be fatal. There could be a lot that some readers won’t agree with, but I found it a warm, loving, clear-eyed view of the world parents inhabit; as Susie says, ...”have a laugh, keep it real and don't judge others too harshly.”