What do you think?
Rate this book
Court of Shadows #1
Play of Shadows
Swordplay, magic, intrigue and friendships stronger than iron: the first volume in the new swashbuckling fantasy series by the bestselling author of The Greatcoats
Damelas Shademantaigne picked a poor night to flee a judicial duel.
He has precious little hope of escaping the wrath of the Vixen, the most feared duellist in the entire city, until he stumbles through the stage doors of the magnificent Operato Belleza and tricks his way into the company of actors. An archaic law provides a temporary respite from his troubles - until one night a ghostly voice in his head causes Damelas to fumble his lines, inadvertently blurting out a dreadful truth: the city's most legendary hero may actually be a traitor and a brutal murderer.
With only the help of his boisterous and lusty friend Bereto, a beautiful assassin whose target may well be Damelas himself, and a company of misfit actors who'd just as soon see him dead, this failed son of two Greatcoats must somehow find within himself the courage to dig up long-buried truths before a ruthless band of bravos known as the Iron Orchids come for his head.
Oh, and there's still that matter of the Vixen waiting to duel him . . .
528 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 2, 2024
186 people are currently reading
7186 people want to read
About the author
Sebastien de Castell
54 books5,036 followersHi Folks!
My eighteenth novel, MALEVOLENT EIGHT is now available. Cade Ombra and his misfit band of mercenary war mages are determined to prevent a cataclysmic war between supernatural beings. But peace at any price might mean killing an awful lot of people. The Malevolent Seven might be heroes, but they'll be the good guys . . .
My seventeenth novel is titled PLAY OF SHADOWS. A swashbuckling fantasy set in the world of mystical theatre where exalted actors can channel the spirits of the historical figures they portray on stage. But Damelas Chademantaigne seems to be summoning the spirit of a notorious villain whose secrets could unleash a civil war!
My sixteenth novel is CRUCIBLE OF CHAOS. Estevar Borros is my favourite swashbuckling investigator of the supernatural, so come investigate alongside him and his dauntless mule, Imperious inside a mysterious abbey where the gods seem to be driving the monks mad!
My fifteenth novel is FATE OF THE ARGOSI. The Argosi series is one of my favourites and I hope you'll come along for Ferius Parfax's adventures!
You can get a pair of free stories here.
The best way to stay up to date is at www.decastell.com, but I'm also on that Facebook thing. Also that Twitter thing. One day I'll even remember to get on that Instagram thing.
As to who I am? Well . . .
Sebastien de Castell had just finished a degree in Archaeology when he started work on his first dig. Four hours later he realized how much he actually hated archaeology and left to pursue a very focused career as a musician, ombudsman, interaction designer, fight choreographer, teacher, project manager, actor, and product strategist. His only defence against the charge of unbridled dilettantism is that he genuinely likes doing these things and that, in one way or another, each of these fields plays a role in his writing. He sternly resists the accusation of being a Renaissance Man in the hopes that more people will label him that way.
Sebastien's acclaimed swashbuckling fantasy series, The Greatcoats. was shortlisted for both the 2014 Goodreads Choice Award for Best Fantasy. the Gemmell Morningstar Award for Best Debut, the Prix Imaginales for Best Foreign Work, and the John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer. His YA fantasy series, Spellslinger, was nominated for the Carnegie Medal and is published in more than a dozen languages.
Sebastien lives in Vancouver, Canada with his lovely wife and two belligerent cats. You can reach him at www.decastell.com
My eighteenth novel, MALEVOLENT EIGHT is now available. Cade Ombra and his misfit band of mercenary war mages are determined to prevent a cataclysmic war between supernatural beings. But peace at any price might mean killing an awful lot of people. The Malevolent Seven might be heroes, but they'll be the good guys . . .
My seventeenth novel is titled PLAY OF SHADOWS. A swashbuckling fantasy set in the world of mystical theatre where exalted actors can channel the spirits of the historical figures they portray on stage. But Damelas Chademantaigne seems to be summoning the spirit of a notorious villain whose secrets could unleash a civil war!
My sixteenth novel is CRUCIBLE OF CHAOS. Estevar Borros is my favourite swashbuckling investigator of the supernatural, so come investigate alongside him and his dauntless mule, Imperious inside a mysterious abbey where the gods seem to be driving the monks mad!
My fifteenth novel is FATE OF THE ARGOSI. The Argosi series is one of my favourites and I hope you'll come along for Ferius Parfax's adventures!
You can get a pair of free stories here.
The best way to stay up to date is at www.decastell.com, but I'm also on that Facebook thing. Also that Twitter thing. One day I'll even remember to get on that Instagram thing.
As to who I am? Well . . .
Sebastien de Castell had just finished a degree in Archaeology when he started work on his first dig. Four hours later he realized how much he actually hated archaeology and left to pursue a very focused career as a musician, ombudsman, interaction designer, fight choreographer, teacher, project manager, actor, and product strategist. His only defence against the charge of unbridled dilettantism is that he genuinely likes doing these things and that, in one way or another, each of these fields plays a role in his writing. He sternly resists the accusation of being a Renaissance Man in the hopes that more people will label him that way.
Sebastien's acclaimed swashbuckling fantasy series, The Greatcoats. was shortlisted for both the 2014 Goodreads Choice Award for Best Fantasy. the Gemmell Morningstar Award for Best Debut, the Prix Imaginales for Best Foreign Work, and the John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer. His YA fantasy series, Spellslinger, was nominated for the Carnegie Medal and is published in more than a dozen languages.
Sebastien lives in Vancouver, Canada with his lovely wife and two belligerent cats. You can reach him at www.decastell.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 252 reviews
Want to read
June 17, 2020
May 13, 2024
BookTube channel with my awesome brother, Ed - The Brothers Gwynne
My personal BookTube channel - William Gwynne
My 12th Sebastien book, and one of my favourites. It has an excellent introduction that immediately sucks you in, and then it does not go. A swashbuckling tale, with twists and turns, standout characters, great world building and sharp, witty prose throughout.
We join Damelas Shademantaigne just as he is chaotically running away from a group of his enemies who evidently are not out to help him. Somehow, through this, he finds himself saved by pretending to be in a play in a theatre…. If that isn’t a unique fantasy setting, I don’t know what is!
Just as Damelas feels he may be able to fade into the shadows, he is cast into the spotlight and more trouble than ever, as the play becomes a focal point for many local powers, including the Duke. Through this, I loved how de Castell explores the power of literature and the power of performance, as the history of the ducky presented in Damelas’s play has resounding consequences on his own life and all those around him, especially as there are powerful people who do not like this new turn of events…
Just as always, Sebastien de Castell’s prose hooks you. With its sharp intelligence, we gradually piece together the mysteries of the world, whilst being accompanied by humour and wit that few authors can rival.
A truly fantastic start to a new series that is not too epic in scope, but feels grand enough. He brings characters to life by their distinct characteristics and dialogue, and in doing so crafts a story not only humorous and gripping, but also moving, with heart and drive as well.
5/5 STARS
My personal BookTube channel - William Gwynne
My 12th Sebastien book, and one of my favourites. It has an excellent introduction that immediately sucks you in, and then it does not go. A swashbuckling tale, with twists and turns, standout characters, great world building and sharp, witty prose throughout.
We join Damelas Shademantaigne just as he is chaotically running away from a group of his enemies who evidently are not out to help him. Somehow, through this, he finds himself saved by pretending to be in a play in a theatre…. If that isn’t a unique fantasy setting, I don’t know what is!
Just as Damelas feels he may be able to fade into the shadows, he is cast into the spotlight and more trouble than ever, as the play becomes a focal point for many local powers, including the Duke. Through this, I loved how de Castell explores the power of literature and the power of performance, as the history of the ducky presented in Damelas’s play has resounding consequences on his own life and all those around him, especially as there are powerful people who do not like this new turn of events…
Just as always, Sebastien de Castell’s prose hooks you. With its sharp intelligence, we gradually piece together the mysteries of the world, whilst being accompanied by humour and wit that few authors can rival.
A truly fantastic start to a new series that is not too epic in scope, but feels grand enough. He brings characters to life by their distinct characteristics and dialogue, and in doing so crafts a story not only humorous and gripping, but also moving, with heart and drive as well.
5/5 STARS
June 7, 2024
PERFECTION
June 3, 2024
5 stars again, reading this for the second time.
As a diehard de Castell fan, I loved this even more the second time around. For a theatre lover and a swashbuckling action lover, this book is a must-read. Damelas grew on me much more the second time, as did his fellow troupe of actors. All of the de Castell classics are there: speeches about honor and courage, feats of derring-do, femme fatales, dueling, discussions of justice, and, of course, THE GREATCOATS. What a great start to a new series, this one delving in to how history defines a people, and that sometimes, it's hard to find a single villain for all the world's ills.
While I didn't love it as much as the OG Greatcoats, it's simply a sine qua non for fans of De Castell's other works.
As a diehard de Castell fan, I loved this even more the second time around. For a theatre lover and a swashbuckling action lover, this book is a must-read. Damelas grew on me much more the second time, as did his fellow troupe of actors. All of the de Castell classics are there: speeches about honor and courage, feats of derring-do, femme fatales, dueling, discussions of justice, and, of course, THE GREATCOATS. What a great start to a new series, this one delving in to how history defines a people, and that sometimes, it's hard to find a single villain for all the world's ills.
While I didn't love it as much as the OG Greatcoats, it's simply a sine qua non for fans of De Castell's other works.
April 9, 2024
This review was originally posted on Books of My Heart
Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
4.5 hearts
I read the Greatcoats series a few years back. It was a little the Three Musketeers with Gods, Saints and Magic. Play of Shadows is the first book in a new series set in the same world year later in the Court of Shadows series, following a new cast of characters saving Trista in a brand new way.
Damelas Shademantaigne, Grandson of two Greatcoats, offered to stand in for a duel meant for his Grandfather and then escaped to a theater to avoid it. Basically in hiding for a year, he has made some great friends in the theater and possibly found his place in the world, even if he isn't a great actor. That is until one night, overtaken by the spirit of a long dead actor, Demelas changes some lines in the play and it seems lights the city on fire as the man they came to be a hero in the histories might be false.
Damelas and troupe is ordered by the Duke to construct a new play from the perceived villains point of view in hopes of discovering the truth of the feud between two powerful men of the past and how the histories got it all wrong. This means Damelas is now the lead in the play since he is possible channeling a spirit from the dead. There is also a group of bully boys out in the city naming themselves the Iron Orchids who have made some rules against blasphemy, which this new play certainly will be seen as and everyone in the theater company will be at risk.
While I don't think that you would need to have read the Greatcoats series to enjoy this book it would help to have some of the history of Trista and the saints and gods of that land. I enjoy Sebastian de Castell's blend of storytelling and witty lines. In Play of Shadows, he gets to really play with the language and turns of phrase, as actors are allowed to be a bit over the top at times. This made the overall story even more enjoyable for me as I really enjoy stuff like that in my reading.
The plot of the story was interesting as we are discovering how the events of the past are the seeds to the current issues in the city with the Iron Orchids and how they play into a bigger plot at hand against the people of Trista. Demelas is also an interesting character. Brought up to be brave by two of the greatest Greatcoats in history but living so timidly afraid to hurt anyone. He has some great friendships in the theater troupe and I especially enjoyed the brotherly bond between him and Beretto. Best friends, they will do anything to help the other. There is also a small love interest for Demelas and she is deadly, just as likely to kill him as kiss him to make the story all the more fun.
The story timing was laid out well and I enjoyed how the events of the past were reveled a little at a time until we are hit with all the truths near the end. This is a great beginning to a new series in the world of the Greatcoats and I can't wait to see what else is in store for our funny troupe of actors turned revolutionaries next.
Review copy was received from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
4.5 hearts
I read the Greatcoats series a few years back. It was a little the Three Musketeers with Gods, Saints and Magic. Play of Shadows is the first book in a new series set in the same world year later in the Court of Shadows series, following a new cast of characters saving Trista in a brand new way.
Damelas Shademantaigne, Grandson of two Greatcoats, offered to stand in for a duel meant for his Grandfather and then escaped to a theater to avoid it. Basically in hiding for a year, he has made some great friends in the theater and possibly found his place in the world, even if he isn't a great actor. That is until one night, overtaken by the spirit of a long dead actor, Demelas changes some lines in the play and it seems lights the city on fire as the man they came to be a hero in the histories might be false.
‘Fled a duel, did you?’ he asked me.
‘I prefer to think of it as engaging with the enemy honourably but from a safe distance.’
Damelas and troupe is ordered by the Duke to construct a new play from the perceived villains point of view in hopes of discovering the truth of the feud between two powerful men of the past and how the histories got it all wrong. This means Damelas is now the lead in the play since he is possible channeling a spirit from the dead. There is also a group of bully boys out in the city naming themselves the Iron Orchids who have made some rules against blasphemy, which this new play certainly will be seen as and everyone in the theater company will be at risk.
‘I can never quite tell if you’re a timid person who pretends at times to be brave, or a brave one who’s been trying to convince himself for far too long that he’s a coward.’
While I don't think that you would need to have read the Greatcoats series to enjoy this book it would help to have some of the history of Trista and the saints and gods of that land. I enjoy Sebastian de Castell's blend of storytelling and witty lines. In Play of Shadows, he gets to really play with the language and turns of phrase, as actors are allowed to be a bit over the top at times. This made the overall story even more enjoyable for me as I really enjoy stuff like that in my reading.
'My grandfather always said, ‘Love is an onion, my boy. Leave it too long and the heart of it will rot. So you’ve got to carefully peel back the layers until you find beneath something so beautiful it brings you to tears.’
The plot of the story was interesting as we are discovering how the events of the past are the seeds to the current issues in the city with the Iron Orchids and how they play into a bigger plot at hand against the people of Trista. Demelas is also an interesting character. Brought up to be brave by two of the greatest Greatcoats in history but living so timidly afraid to hurt anyone. He has some great friendships in the theater troupe and I especially enjoyed the brotherly bond between him and Beretto. Best friends, they will do anything to help the other. There is also a small love interest for Demelas and she is deadly, just as likely to kill him as kiss him to make the story all the more fun.
The story timing was laid out well and I enjoyed how the events of the past were reveled a little at a time until we are hit with all the truths near the end. This is a great beginning to a new series in the world of the Greatcoats and I can't wait to see what else is in store for our funny troupe of actors turned revolutionaries next.
‘Let’s teach these blackguards the first rule of the sword,’ Beretto cried, running into the fray, ignoring the wounds he’d already suffered.
Corbier’s usually cold and calculating voice asked with interest, The first rule of the sword?
An old Greatcoats saying, I informed him as I raced after Beretto. ‘Put the pointy end in the other guy first.’
March 7, 2024
I think my review could boil down to just four words. I'm not sure which four words best sum up my experience but there are some options:
I didn't like it.
It wasn't for me.
Alas, I did try.
I persevered, I battled to the bitter end and turned each and every one of the near to 500 pages hoping I would change my mind. As much as I wanted to get swept up in the story or the camaraderie, I just couldn't get behind the premise. As a fantasy reader, I've conjured up realistic dragons, dwarves and even the odd unicorn in my mind. I've placidly tagged along on doomed quests dreamt up with questionable logic or shaky motivations. However for whatever reason, I just couldn't let go and give in to the suspension of disbelief that the singular way the hidden truth of society's corruption could be uncovered is through a play-by-play reenactment of a ghost's long-forgotten memories in front of a live audience. It also didn't sit comfortably that the dangerous and bloodthirsty enemy were waiting in the shadowy wings, ready to swoop in and deliver death blows to all those who dared act in this blasphemous performance.. though they were of course always happy to watch and wait for the final curtain or intermission to intervene.
I'll admit, I have not read this author's previous works and so I'm not familiar with the rest of the books within the Greatcoat universe. I've also never been big on theatre or performance-based art, nor fencing or duelling. Perhaps the charm of this book was lost on me, due to my lack of understanding when it comes to those pursuits and the shared culture of those individuals who love them as much as the author does. I think for those people, this book will be a wonderful adventure and I do not want my opinion to deter or put them off in any way. De Castell's passion and knowledge shine through in his work, I can only regret that it was lost on me.
The writing was of great quality and I found myself indulging in a snort laugh or two at the humour (eaten by cows/eaten by crows moment was a personal favourite, as well as the panic of seeing red/facing the curtain). In line with any story set primarily on a stage and involving a troupe of performers, it did lean into the melodrama a tad. The pretentious, embellished language of the theatre was plentiful and there were more than a fair share of smug or over-dramatised characters indulging in poetic soliloquies and monologues, often to massage their egos and further inflate their self-importance. I would roll my eyes if I met them in person, so it's only natural I found myself doing the same when meeting them on the page.
Thank you Quercus Books & Sebastien de Castell for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
I didn't like it.
It wasn't for me.
Alas, I did try.
I persevered, I battled to the bitter end and turned each and every one of the near to 500 pages hoping I would change my mind. As much as I wanted to get swept up in the story or the camaraderie, I just couldn't get behind the premise. As a fantasy reader, I've conjured up realistic dragons, dwarves and even the odd unicorn in my mind. I've placidly tagged along on doomed quests dreamt up with questionable logic or shaky motivations. However for whatever reason, I just couldn't let go and give in to the suspension of disbelief that the singular way the hidden truth of society's corruption could be uncovered is through a play-by-play reenactment of a ghost's long-forgotten memories in front of a live audience. It also didn't sit comfortably that the dangerous and bloodthirsty enemy were waiting in the shadowy wings, ready to swoop in and deliver death blows to all those who dared act in this blasphemous performance.. though they were of course always happy to watch and wait for the final curtain or intermission to intervene.
I'll admit, I have not read this author's previous works and so I'm not familiar with the rest of the books within the Greatcoat universe. I've also never been big on theatre or performance-based art, nor fencing or duelling. Perhaps the charm of this book was lost on me, due to my lack of understanding when it comes to those pursuits and the shared culture of those individuals who love them as much as the author does. I think for those people, this book will be a wonderful adventure and I do not want my opinion to deter or put them off in any way. De Castell's passion and knowledge shine through in his work, I can only regret that it was lost on me.
The writing was of great quality and I found myself indulging in a snort laugh or two at the humour (eaten by cows/eaten by crows moment was a personal favourite, as well as the panic of seeing red/facing the curtain). In line with any story set primarily on a stage and involving a troupe of performers, it did lean into the melodrama a tad. The pretentious, embellished language of the theatre was plentiful and there were more than a fair share of smug or over-dramatised characters indulging in poetic soliloquies and monologues, often to massage their egos and further inflate their self-importance. I would roll my eyes if I met them in person, so it's only natural I found myself doing the same when meeting them on the page.
Thank you Quercus Books & Sebastien de Castell for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
February 27, 2024
A great new swashbuckling series with no-one’s-idea-of-a-hero main character and his trusty band of actors and friends. This is set in the Greatcoats world, some time on. Damelas is in fact the grandson of two Greatcoats. The story is crammed full of fight scenes, at which Sebastien de Castell excels. As always with his books, the characters and story have real heart. Very satisfying! Many thanks to Netgalley for an arc of this book.
May 11, 2024
Full review: https://youtu.be/wvy0jschfG0?si=a17VH...
I think most fans of the Greatcoats will really enjoy going back to Tristia. Falcio’s story and his battles are over, but Tristia is not a peaceful nation and there are new battles to fight, new schemes to uncover, and new heroes stepping into the dueling circle to fight for honor, for justice, for glory, and for love.
In other words, there’s a new cast and new plot, but same great writing and same Tristia.
It’s time to raise the curtain and let the next act of the greatcoats begin! Unlike when Falcio is telling the story, magic takes center stage here. But at the same time, it’s magic unlike anything I’ve seen before. The banter while still good, isn’t quite at the level of the greatcoats. But that’s alright, you wouldn’t want too much banter to take the characters off script. The cast is likable and they form a nice found family.
This isn’t the easiest book to talk about without going into spoilers, so I’ll just say this one last thing before exiting stage right; for the love of Saint Zaghev-who-sings-for-tears, give this book a try!
P.s. the epilogue was quite good!
I think most fans of the Greatcoats will really enjoy going back to Tristia. Falcio’s story and his battles are over, but Tristia is not a peaceful nation and there are new battles to fight, new schemes to uncover, and new heroes stepping into the dueling circle to fight for honor, for justice, for glory, and for love.
In other words, there’s a new cast and new plot, but same great writing and same Tristia.
It’s time to raise the curtain and let the next act of the greatcoats begin! Unlike when Falcio is telling the story, magic takes center stage here. But at the same time, it’s magic unlike anything I’ve seen before. The banter while still good, isn’t quite at the level of the greatcoats. But that’s alright, you wouldn’t want too much banter to take the characters off script. The cast is likable and they form a nice found family.
This isn’t the easiest book to talk about without going into spoilers, so I’ll just say this one last thing before exiting stage right; for the love of Saint Zaghev-who-sings-for-tears, give this book a try!
P.s. the epilogue was quite good!
February 2, 2024
’Rest, Rabbit, rest. It's really for the best! There's nowhere left to hide - besides, It's long past time you died!'
O, what wit. What depravity. What deceit. What plots.
3.75🌟
Damelas Chademantaigne, the grandson of two Greatcoats but a rubbish sword hand, only escaped the wrath of the Vixen, the most feared duellist in the entire city, by tricking his way into the Operato Belleza and its company of actors.
However, it appears that there is long-buried truths regarding the current foreign Duke who has commissioned a play that can only be described as treasonous by portraying the duchy's most notorious usurper and child-killer as a hero.
De Castell has a magic with words. A genius with beautiful prose and cutting wit. His main character is always a multitude of emotions, conflict, and tension. He writes drama with such thrill, he describes battle with such vigour, he describes human nature with pessimism sprinkled either hope.
’I can never quite tell if you're a timid person who pretends at times to be brave, or a brave one who's been trying to convince himself for far too long that he's a coward.'
You can feel the absolute passion de Castell has for performance, for all kinds of art.
Sometimes his prose can feel pretentious, out-of-place, indulgent. But this isn’t my first rodeo with his adult fantasy, so I went in knowing what to expect and was delightfully bemused.
’Love is an onion, my boy. Leave it too long and the heart of it will rot.
So you've got to carefully peel back the layers until you find beneath something so beautiful it brings you to tears.'
Thank you to Quercus books for providing the arc in exchange for a review.
Bookstagram
O, what wit. What depravity. What deceit. What plots.
3.75🌟
Damelas Chademantaigne, the grandson of two Greatcoats but a rubbish sword hand, only escaped the wrath of the Vixen, the most feared duellist in the entire city, by tricking his way into the Operato Belleza and its company of actors.
However, it appears that there is long-buried truths regarding the current foreign Duke who has commissioned a play that can only be described as treasonous by portraying the duchy's most notorious usurper and child-killer as a hero.
De Castell has a magic with words. A genius with beautiful prose and cutting wit. His main character is always a multitude of emotions, conflict, and tension. He writes drama with such thrill, he describes battle with such vigour, he describes human nature with pessimism sprinkled either hope.
’I can never quite tell if you're a timid person who pretends at times to be brave, or a brave one who's been trying to convince himself for far too long that he's a coward.'
You can feel the absolute passion de Castell has for performance, for all kinds of art.
Sometimes his prose can feel pretentious, out-of-place, indulgent. But this isn’t my first rodeo with his adult fantasy, so I went in knowing what to expect and was delightfully bemused.
’Love is an onion, my boy. Leave it too long and the heart of it will rot.
So you've got to carefully peel back the layers until you find beneath something so beautiful it brings you to tears.'
Thank you to Quercus books for providing the arc in exchange for a review.
Bookstagram
Want to read
November 17, 2020Me reading the description: hmm looks good
Me upon seeing the word "Greatcoats" in the description: oH MY GOD
Me upon seeing the word "Greatcoats" in the description: oH MY GOD
July 12, 2024
Crucible of Chaos ★★★
Play of Shadows ★★
DNF ~55%
I was so excited about this new series as I was a big fan of the Greatcoats series, and this is supposed to be somehow related to that. Crucible of Chaos was okay. I contemplated reading this or not for a long time and finally decided to give it a chance given that it was supposedly better but for me it was very underwhelming.
I think the idea of a play did not work for me very well. Compared to the original series this felt like a historical fantasy and history and I aren't much of friends. I wanted to DNF earlier but lowered my expectations, went with a different mindset, persisted a bit and then I was just waiting to finish the book knowing I won't continue the series and I thought to myself why I should put myself through that. And that was when I stopped reading this at chapter 40 a bit more than halfway through the series.
Looking at the reviews. I saw a few people who agree with me specially those who did not read the main series. As someone who did, I still felt the same. On the other hand, a lot of readers enjoyed this, and the average rating is currently great so take this review with a grain of salt and just maybe try it for yourselves!
Play of Shadows ★★
DNF ~55%
I was so excited about this new series as I was a big fan of the Greatcoats series, and this is supposed to be somehow related to that. Crucible of Chaos was okay. I contemplated reading this or not for a long time and finally decided to give it a chance given that it was supposedly better but for me it was very underwhelming.
I think the idea of a play did not work for me very well. Compared to the original series this felt like a historical fantasy and history and I aren't much of friends. I wanted to DNF earlier but lowered my expectations, went with a different mindset, persisted a bit and then I was just waiting to finish the book knowing I won't continue the series and I thought to myself why I should put myself through that. And that was when I stopped reading this at chapter 40 a bit more than halfway through the series.
Looking at the reviews. I saw a few people who agree with me specially those who did not read the main series. As someone who did, I still felt the same. On the other hand, a lot of readers enjoyed this, and the average rating is currently great so take this review with a grain of salt and just maybe try it for yourselves!
Read
April 16, 2024tl;dr
Plenty of world building supports a layered story about a normal guy caught up in a political game much bigger than him.
Thoughts
Damelas isn't a hero - he just plays one onstage. Scratch that, he's a bit player and he can barely even get that part right. But he and the ragtag band of actors he hangs out with are immediately sympathetic, very messy, and if you've ever seen a group of actors together, you'll recognize every player in the text here. Ostensibly a story about one man and his quest to not get skewered by a particularly vengeful duelist, the past layers (literally and figuratively) onto Damelas' world, tying the efforts of his small acting troupe into a much larger power struggle. There's a lot to keep up with, and the first half of the book takes a little bit of time to set up all the pieces before setting everything in motion. The back half moves at a much quicker pace, with some big reveals at the end that set up the rest of the series admirably. I've not read the original Greatcoats series, but this new series introduces the world without any confusion The world building is very strong from the getgo, with a heavy emphasis on the history and politics of the world. And oh, how much of it there is! If you like political machinations and surprise reveals punctuated with some really well-written swordplay, this one's for you.
Thanks to NetGalley and Arcadia for a review copy. All thoughts in this review are my own.
Plenty of world building supports a layered story about a normal guy caught up in a political game much bigger than him.
Thoughts
Damelas isn't a hero - he just plays one onstage. Scratch that, he's a bit player and he can barely even get that part right. But he and the ragtag band of actors he hangs out with are immediately sympathetic, very messy, and if you've ever seen a group of actors together, you'll recognize every player in the text here. Ostensibly a story about one man and his quest to not get skewered by a particularly vengeful duelist, the past layers (literally and figuratively) onto Damelas' world, tying the efforts of his small acting troupe into a much larger power struggle. There's a lot to keep up with, and the first half of the book takes a little bit of time to set up all the pieces before setting everything in motion. The back half moves at a much quicker pace, with some big reveals at the end that set up the rest of the series admirably. I've not read the original Greatcoats series, but this new series introduces the world without any confusion The world building is very strong from the getgo, with a heavy emphasis on the history and politics of the world. And oh, how much of it there is! If you like political machinations and surprise reveals punctuated with some really well-written swordplay, this one's for you.
Thanks to NetGalley and Arcadia for a review copy. All thoughts in this review are my own.
February 9, 2024
This was brilliant. Superb.
Sebastian de Castell is back in the world of the Greatcoats, and honestly, I just love everything about the world and stories within it.
This really is nothing like the previous Greatcoat series in terms of the story telling or even the story itself. It does, however, have enough links and connections to the Greatcoast series to make it feel a connected series. I love that we didn't just get another book with the same characters (despite loving Kest, Basti, and Falcio) and that we got to explore events through a new main character.
We got to live through our new hero?!? 🧐 Damelas
Damelas Chademantaigne, is the grandson of two Greatcoats but a rubbish sword hand, and his story starts when he escaps the wrath of the Vixen, the most feared duellist in the entire city, by tricking his way into the Operato Belleza and its company of actors.
The story then takes some unexpected turns, and because I want to avoid the spoiler of what drives this story, I'll say no more.
All I will say is that this is more than an honourable inclusion to the Greatcoat series. Deep characters, phenomenal world building, politics and intrigue, and what we have come to expert from SdC incredibly written prose, full of sarcasm, wit, and humour
Sebastian de Castell is back in the world of the Greatcoats, and honestly, I just love everything about the world and stories within it.
This really is nothing like the previous Greatcoat series in terms of the story telling or even the story itself. It does, however, have enough links and connections to the Greatcoast series to make it feel a connected series. I love that we didn't just get another book with the same characters (despite loving Kest, Basti, and Falcio) and that we got to explore events through a new main character.
We got to live through our new hero?!? 🧐 Damelas
Damelas Chademantaigne, is the grandson of two Greatcoats but a rubbish sword hand, and his story starts when he escaps the wrath of the Vixen, the most feared duellist in the entire city, by tricking his way into the Operato Belleza and its company of actors.
The story then takes some unexpected turns, and because I want to avoid the spoiler of what drives this story, I'll say no more.
All I will say is that this is more than an honourable inclusion to the Greatcoat series. Deep characters, phenomenal world building, politics and intrigue, and what we have come to expert from SdC incredibly written prose, full of sarcasm, wit, and humour
July 28, 2024
On my blog.
Rep: gay character, lesbian side character
Galley provided by publisher
At this point, Sebastien de Castell is an author whose books I am guaranteed to enjoy and Play of Shadows merely proved that further to me. It’s a welcome return to the world of the Greatcoats (and some of its characters!) and a book I thoroughly enjoyed.
In this one, we follow the grandson of two Greatcoats, Damelas: at the moment we meet him, he’s doing his best to avoid fighting a duel. Damelas at the beginning of the book is, if we might be blunt, a coward. A lot of the book is about Damelas being forced to discard that cowardice (through the help of a ghost possessing him — a particular type of magic in this world), but it’s also about history, truth, and propaganda. In finding himself possessed for the first time, Damelas accidentally reveals that the city’s legendary hero may, in fact, have been a traitor.
Of course, this news is not welcome to several groups of people and Damelas finds himself suddenly a target for more than one person. It’s here that he discovers the people who have his back, and that’s another aspect of this book (as well as most of de Castell’s works, come to think of it). It’s about the relationships formed along the way of the plot, the main character who thinks they can only really rely on themselves, but still endangers themselves to save other people, only to then find that they’ll do the same. The company of actors that Damelas finds himself in is 90% antagonism, 10% outright arguments (which, I admit, remains that way through most of the book), but they all come together throughout.
It helps that this book is set within a previously established world of course, but Sebastien de Castell is, to me, unmatched in this kind of worldbuilding, the sort that feels based on swashbuckling books like Dumas’s, those kinds of romantic adventures. It’s not solely about the aesthetic: there’s a lot of thought gone into all parts of the world and how they work together. As I said, this book introduces a new kind of magic to the Greatcoats universe, one that leaves you with tantalising possibilities.
This isn’t a book where you need to read the previous series to understand (although I would highly recommend those too!) meaning that, if you want, you can dive straight into de Castell’s works from here. And I strongly suggest that you do!
Rep: gay character, lesbian side character
Galley provided by publisher
At this point, Sebastien de Castell is an author whose books I am guaranteed to enjoy and Play of Shadows merely proved that further to me. It’s a welcome return to the world of the Greatcoats (and some of its characters!) and a book I thoroughly enjoyed.
In this one, we follow the grandson of two Greatcoats, Damelas: at the moment we meet him, he’s doing his best to avoid fighting a duel. Damelas at the beginning of the book is, if we might be blunt, a coward. A lot of the book is about Damelas being forced to discard that cowardice (through the help of a ghost possessing him — a particular type of magic in this world), but it’s also about history, truth, and propaganda. In finding himself possessed for the first time, Damelas accidentally reveals that the city’s legendary hero may, in fact, have been a traitor.
Of course, this news is not welcome to several groups of people and Damelas finds himself suddenly a target for more than one person. It’s here that he discovers the people who have his back, and that’s another aspect of this book (as well as most of de Castell’s works, come to think of it). It’s about the relationships formed along the way of the plot, the main character who thinks they can only really rely on themselves, but still endangers themselves to save other people, only to then find that they’ll do the same. The company of actors that Damelas finds himself in is 90% antagonism, 10% outright arguments (which, I admit, remains that way through most of the book), but they all come together throughout.
It helps that this book is set within a previously established world of course, but Sebastien de Castell is, to me, unmatched in this kind of worldbuilding, the sort that feels based on swashbuckling books like Dumas’s, those kinds of romantic adventures. It’s not solely about the aesthetic: there’s a lot of thought gone into all parts of the world and how they work together. As I said, this book introduces a new kind of magic to the Greatcoats universe, one that leaves you with tantalising possibilities.
This isn’t a book where you need to read the previous series to understand (although I would highly recommend those too!) meaning that, if you want, you can dive straight into de Castell’s works from here. And I strongly suggest that you do!
Want to read
May 19, 2020
March 31, 2024
I’ll start this review by saying that Sebastian de Castell is a master at creating characters and stories. Play of Shadows is a Renaissance Era kind of book, and the theatre is the stage for magic, since the story is told by the lens of a play. However, just as in Crucible of Chaos (the other book in the Court of Shadows series), there are some spoilers for The Greatcoats, so depending on where you’re in the series, proceed with caution before diving into these one.
The action throughout this story takes place in only one city and it’s set in The Greatcoats universe, and it gives us a little more detail about this world. We have plotting, drama, villains, and darkness all with a dose of humor in it. The writing is amazing, and I could feel the pretentious language of the theater through the book. The plot of this story is well drawn out, and we have self-discovery moments within the story while we unravel the secrets.
Overall, this was a story full of snarky characters, conspiracies and politics set in the world of theater, which is a very different way to read a fantasy book. It has a slow start but then it really picks up. The fact that the romance never takes over the main plot was a great touch, and I really enjoyed this story. To those who are diving into Castell books, and specially into the Greatcoats, this is a great introduction to this world.
Thank you, NetGalley & the publisher, for approving me to read this arc and write this review.
The action throughout this story takes place in only one city and it’s set in The Greatcoats universe, and it gives us a little more detail about this world. We have plotting, drama, villains, and darkness all with a dose of humor in it. The writing is amazing, and I could feel the pretentious language of the theater through the book. The plot of this story is well drawn out, and we have self-discovery moments within the story while we unravel the secrets.
Overall, this was a story full of snarky characters, conspiracies and politics set in the world of theater, which is a very different way to read a fantasy book. It has a slow start but then it really picks up. The fact that the romance never takes over the main plot was a great touch, and I really enjoyed this story. To those who are diving into Castell books, and specially into the Greatcoats, this is a great introduction to this world.
Thank you, NetGalley & the publisher, for approving me to read this arc and write this review.
June 25, 2024
I read this book for the #clearursht readathon.
Damelas is the rabbit of the town after fleeing a fight with the notorious Vixen. He’s determined to hide out from the fight as he doesn’t want to get his family into trouble, and in order to hide he flees into a theatre and pretends to be a part of the troupe. This becomes his home for a good number of years, but one day his life goes from hidden stage hand to real Veristor and actor. The magic of the Veristors is that they are ancient real people who can connect with current-day actors and can talk and act through them, kind of like a vessel.
This book does link into the world of the Greatcoats somewhat with the heritage of Damelas and also in some of the minor side characters, so if you have read that series you may enjoy it slightly more, but this is the first in a new series so you have no need to actually know anything much about the Greatcoats series.
I really enjoyed getting to know Damelas and I think that the second half of the book was pretty fast paced with action and mystery going on. Damelas is constantly trying to understand what is really unfolding around him and his new powers, and he’s caught up in a whirlwind of events. I think the first half of the book is more stage-setting and introducing the ideas of the veristors and the world Damelas inhabits.
The magic was a really cool part of the story and seeing people vying to take control of the present from the past and trying to tell their stories was good. It does feel like there’s more to learn about all the different types of people and their various powers, but I think more is going to be unfolded in future books.
Overall, a very enjoyable read but it didn’t quite have the banter I loved in Greatcoats. I think that I will keep reading as I believe that the story may have a bit more of that in future books. 3.5*s.
Damelas is the rabbit of the town after fleeing a fight with the notorious Vixen. He’s determined to hide out from the fight as he doesn’t want to get his family into trouble, and in order to hide he flees into a theatre and pretends to be a part of the troupe. This becomes his home for a good number of years, but one day his life goes from hidden stage hand to real Veristor and actor. The magic of the Veristors is that they are ancient real people who can connect with current-day actors and can talk and act through them, kind of like a vessel.
This book does link into the world of the Greatcoats somewhat with the heritage of Damelas and also in some of the minor side characters, so if you have read that series you may enjoy it slightly more, but this is the first in a new series so you have no need to actually know anything much about the Greatcoats series.
I really enjoyed getting to know Damelas and I think that the second half of the book was pretty fast paced with action and mystery going on. Damelas is constantly trying to understand what is really unfolding around him and his new powers, and he’s caught up in a whirlwind of events. I think the first half of the book is more stage-setting and introducing the ideas of the veristors and the world Damelas inhabits.
The magic was a really cool part of the story and seeing people vying to take control of the present from the past and trying to tell their stories was good. It does feel like there’s more to learn about all the different types of people and their various powers, but I think more is going to be unfolded in future books.
Overall, a very enjoyable read but it didn’t quite have the banter I loved in Greatcoats. I think that I will keep reading as I believe that the story may have a bit more of that in future books. 3.5*s.
February 2, 2025
Absolutely brilliant. I’m a theatre teacher, so I love a theatre troupe in a novel, and this is done so well! Demelas is an awesome protagonist and there are so many great side characters as well. I’ve read some of the Greatcoats novels, but now I need to read them all.
March 25, 2024
A beautifully crafted -or rather, staged- novel complete with a stunningly beautiful moment of carthasis that had me smiling through my tears.
Once upon a time, the Greatcoats went out into the world to right injustice wherever they found them, fighting for the truth. (And no, you don't need to have read their stories to enjoy this one. Although you should, if you ask me. And if you do know and love them already, you'll get to meet some old friends here!)
Now, the grandson of two of them is rather lost, running away from duel of honor and fearing he could never live up to their reputations (spoiler alert, he totally does, in the end. And it is SO beautiful to watch). Hiding with a group of players, Damelas Chademantaigne finds his fate unexpectedly tied to that of the villain in his city's history - who fights to have his story told by gifting his memories to Damelas. And our not so cowardly actor has to find the strength to fight for the truth, uncovering a plot to overthrow the government and wreak havoc on his home...
This is (and yes, I'm being repetitive) freaking beautiful, effortlessly flawless, and truly awesome and swashbuckling (I mean. It's De Castell doing what he does best) story, staged like a play, complete with beautiful frontispieces for every act. Watching the plot unfurl is truly mesmerizing, and I can't wait to be reuinted with our group of players!
*I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
Once upon a time, the Greatcoats went out into the world to right injustice wherever they found them, fighting for the truth. (And no, you don't need to have read their stories to enjoy this one. Although you should, if you ask me. And if you do know and love them already, you'll get to meet some old friends here!)
Now, the grandson of two of them is rather lost, running away from duel of honor and fearing he could never live up to their reputations (spoiler alert, he totally does, in the end. And it is SO beautiful to watch). Hiding with a group of players, Damelas Chademantaigne finds his fate unexpectedly tied to that of the villain in his city's history - who fights to have his story told by gifting his memories to Damelas. And our not so cowardly actor has to find the strength to fight for the truth, uncovering a plot to overthrow the government and wreak havoc on his home...
This is (and yes, I'm being repetitive) freaking beautiful, effortlessly flawless, and truly awesome and swashbuckling (I mean. It's De Castell doing what he does best) story, staged like a play, complete with beautiful frontispieces for every act. Watching the plot unfurl is truly mesmerizing, and I can't wait to be reuinted with our group of players!
*I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
January 17, 2026
didnt enjoy the characters as much as the greatcoats trio. I also needed more descriptive scenes
May 6, 2024
4.25 stars
Thanks to NetGalley and the Editor. I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
It is not easy to write a review for this book (and lately this is almost a refrain in my reviews, sorry about that!) because I have some mixed feelings toward this book. I still enjoyed it a lot. I don’t have any doubt about this, I had fun, I had feelings, and I am extremely happy to have read this book. But I think that trusting the author here made all the difference.
The point is that in the beginning I was at first fascinated by this new setting because it is the same world as the Greatcoats series, but the MC is not a Greatcoat, he is completely different, so it was all sort of new but in a familiar contest (and I appreciated this immensely) but then we get started pretty soon with the mistreatment of Damelas (more on that in a second) and I was just so mad! But not because the author did a poor job or something like that. I was mad because it was just so unfair! (And I mean, what the heck was I expecting? I knew how things were with this author!). Poor Damelas is thrown in bad spot after bad spot, with a ton of responsibilities (and he didn’t ask for any of those!). And I know that it is immensely naive on my part, but the unfairness of all this, time and again, really hit me hard. (And I think that if the author wasn’t someone I loved… well, I would have probably ditched the book because I was not ready for all that suffering!). But let’s rewind a second here!
The Greatcoats is one of my favorite series so I was curious and scared about this one because, as I said, it is set in the same world, but we are not following the characters that I loved to pieces, but a completely new one, whit a completely different career. (But Falcio is mentioned around and at every mention of him, my little heart soared. This small thing made me so incredibly happy! And in the end, we see one of the fantastic trio on the scene and I was full-on in fan-girl mode! That really made my day!!)
That said Damelas is a great character who the author treats unfairly. Because De Castell is one of those authors who mistreat their characters. And I hate them for this. But I love them for the characters, the world they create, and the story they gift us. So yeah, I am complaining because he is bad, but I love him because he is bad.
Anyway, Damelas is the MC, but with him, we have a full cast of interesting characters, some I loved to pieces (Beretto, Shariza, and Zina above all), some I loved to hate (Albastrini, and damn, he is an amazing character! He is a masterpiece, trust me!) and some I despised so much! (Iron Orchids and the Vixen ).
And let me tell you a thing about the Vixen. She is bad, and I really mean bad, but she is also your classical villain, the one that is always there, that appears from nowhere every time things are going bad for our beloved hero. So much so that you start to roll your eyes when you see her appear, because really? Again?? It wasn’t enough all the rest?? And I think that here the author did an amazing job, too. Even if I wanted her dead from the start. So so dead!!
And the characters are not the only good thing in this book. The plot is pretty full of action, mystery, and plot, it is never boring, but what I really loved was the dark and dry humor that we can see from time to time, and that cracked me up. I just live for those moments when the humor of the author shows. De Castell has a peculiar sense of humor, that makes his books funny even when they are not, by any means, funny books. And yet, from time to time, I find myself laughing or smiling because, sure, they are pretty dark but there is still some light in them. And I so love this!
And, last but not least, I love that we have some epic scenes, that almost made me cry out because they are so so satisfying and epic! And yes, satisfying because sometimes we get to see some justice or some payback delivered in some delightful way. And in these cases, the feelings are all over the place, and it feels so rewarding!!
So… yeah, I loved this book. A lot. It made me suffer, it made me mad, but it made me also delighted, and happy, and it made me go fangirling around. It is the whole package: smile, laugh, tears, rage, satisfaction… whatever! It is just soooo good!
Thanks to NetGalley and the Editor. I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
It is not easy to write a review for this book (and lately this is almost a refrain in my reviews, sorry about that!) because I have some mixed feelings toward this book. I still enjoyed it a lot. I don’t have any doubt about this, I had fun, I had feelings, and I am extremely happy to have read this book. But I think that trusting the author here made all the difference.
The point is that in the beginning I was at first fascinated by this new setting because it is the same world as the Greatcoats series, but the MC is not a Greatcoat, he is completely different, so it was all sort of new but in a familiar contest (and I appreciated this immensely) but then we get started pretty soon with the mistreatment of Damelas (more on that in a second) and I was just so mad! But not because the author did a poor job or something like that. I was mad because it was just so unfair! (And I mean, what the heck was I expecting? I knew how things were with this author!). Poor Damelas is thrown in bad spot after bad spot, with a ton of responsibilities (and he didn’t ask for any of those!). And I know that it is immensely naive on my part, but the unfairness of all this, time and again, really hit me hard. (And I think that if the author wasn’t someone I loved… well, I would have probably ditched the book because I was not ready for all that suffering!). But let’s rewind a second here!
The Greatcoats is one of my favorite series so I was curious and scared about this one because, as I said, it is set in the same world, but we are not following the characters that I loved to pieces, but a completely new one, whit a completely different career. (But Falcio is mentioned around and at every mention of him, my little heart soared. This small thing made me so incredibly happy! And in the end, we see one of the fantastic trio on the scene and I was full-on in fan-girl mode! That really made my day!!)
That said Damelas is a great character who the author treats unfairly. Because De Castell is one of those authors who mistreat their characters. And I hate them for this. But I love them for the characters, the world they create, and the story they gift us. So yeah, I am complaining because he is bad, but I love him because he is bad.
Anyway, Damelas is the MC, but with him, we have a full cast of interesting characters, some I loved to pieces (Beretto, Shariza, and Zina above all), some I loved to hate (Albastrini, and damn, he is an amazing character! He is a masterpiece, trust me!) and some I despised so much! (Iron Orchids and the Vixen ).
And let me tell you a thing about the Vixen. She is bad, and I really mean bad, but she is also your classical villain, the one that is always there, that appears from nowhere every time things are going bad for our beloved hero. So much so that you start to roll your eyes when you see her appear, because really? Again?? It wasn’t enough all the rest?? And I think that here the author did an amazing job, too. Even if I wanted her dead from the start. So so dead!!
And the characters are not the only good thing in this book. The plot is pretty full of action, mystery, and plot, it is never boring, but what I really loved was the dark and dry humor that we can see from time to time, and that cracked me up. I just live for those moments when the humor of the author shows. De Castell has a peculiar sense of humor, that makes his books funny even when they are not, by any means, funny books. And yet, from time to time, I find myself laughing or smiling because, sure, they are pretty dark but there is still some light in them. And I so love this!
And, last but not least, I love that we have some epic scenes, that almost made me cry out because they are so so satisfying and epic! And yes, satisfying because sometimes we get to see some justice or some payback delivered in some delightful way. And in these cases, the feelings are all over the place, and it feels so rewarding!!
So… yeah, I loved this book. A lot. It made me suffer, it made me mad, but it made me also delighted, and happy, and it made me go fangirling around. It is the whole package: smile, laugh, tears, rage, satisfaction… whatever! It is just soooo good!
January 19, 2025
4,5 because it takes a while to get going and some sentences and word choices gave me a god damn head ache but other than that I DEVOURED this. It was absolutely everything I want from a fantasy adventure story and I'm true and wholly frustrated that I cannot make a countdown for book two yet because it doesn't even have a release date yet.
April 12, 2024
8 / 10 ✪
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com...
Damelas Shademantaigne, grandson of not one but two legendary Greatcoats, has fled a judicial duel. He is, in fact, still in the process of fleeing one when the jackals catch him. Unable to fight the Vixen—the most dangerous duelist in the city—and unable to leave the city itself, he’s in a bit of a pickle.
But, Damelas has a cunning (and desperate) plan. He’s going to become the greatest actor the city has ever known, indispensable to the Operato Belleza—one of the city’s oldest and most respected theatre-houses—such that it will become illegal to force him into a duel.
Problem is, Damelas has never worked—or indeed spoken to anyone—at the Operato Belleza, and he only has one opportunity to make a good impression, one where he’s beaten, bloodied, and surrounded by jackals waiting to drag him off to the Vixen.
Fortunately enough, with a little luck, the intervention of what will surely be a great new friend, and an exotic assassin that will surely see him dead before he ever has to face the vixen, Damelas’ plan goes off without… well, too many hitches. Now all that’s left is that “greatest actor in the city” part, and the ability to redeem the city itself before it all burns down around him.
Seems easy enough.
—
Where the Raven flies, death always follows.
—
Now, normally I’d leave this til last, but I want to lead with how amazing it is to return to the writing of Sebastien de Castell—as told via the dulcet tones of Joe Jameson, the narrator that has read (as far as I’m aware) every single one of his books. I’m a huge fan of Jameson’ read books, and would listen to basically anything narrated by him—as should you!
And with that out of the way—well, do you need any more reason to read this? It took me a little to get into, but once I did, I was hooked. After maybe the 2 hour mark, I had no thoughts of stopping—pretty good for an 18-hour book.
For a book about an opera, this was surprisingly good. Damelas may be a bit of a showboat, but that’s not exactly a bad quality for lead. Even less for a book about acting—specifically acting drawn out of history. The main problem with Damelas is… well, some people are going to find him whiny, and/or annoying. It’s the same problem Kellen had in the Spellslinger series. Shit just keeps ruining his life, and he has opinions about it. Now, I didn’t mind it then and I don’t mind it now, so it’s difficult to say just how bad it is. I’d say… less so than Spellslinger, but I’m just guessing.
Aside from the narrator and the narrative, what more do you want? I mean, this is a book essentially about the theatre, but it’s also the successor series to the Greatcoats, so it’s bound to earn some patience in either regard. The characters are relatively good, though I’d’ve liked (and would like to see) greater development moving forward.
Speaking of moving forward, I do wonder just how much of a thrill this particular troupe of players can muster. Day upon day, night upon night… book upon book? Honestly, I’m a bit concerned moving forward, but nothing more. As far as I’m concerned, this Sebastien de Castell has earned some faith.
https://arefugefromlife.wordpress.com...
Damelas Shademantaigne, grandson of not one but two legendary Greatcoats, has fled a judicial duel. He is, in fact, still in the process of fleeing one when the jackals catch him. Unable to fight the Vixen—the most dangerous duelist in the city—and unable to leave the city itself, he’s in a bit of a pickle.
But, Damelas has a cunning (and desperate) plan. He’s going to become the greatest actor the city has ever known, indispensable to the Operato Belleza—one of the city’s oldest and most respected theatre-houses—such that it will become illegal to force him into a duel.
Problem is, Damelas has never worked—or indeed spoken to anyone—at the Operato Belleza, and he only has one opportunity to make a good impression, one where he’s beaten, bloodied, and surrounded by jackals waiting to drag him off to the Vixen.
Fortunately enough, with a little luck, the intervention of what will surely be a great new friend, and an exotic assassin that will surely see him dead before he ever has to face the vixen, Damelas’ plan goes off without… well, too many hitches. Now all that’s left is that “greatest actor in the city” part, and the ability to redeem the city itself before it all burns down around him.
Seems easy enough.
—
Where the Raven flies, death always follows.
—
Now, normally I’d leave this til last, but I want to lead with how amazing it is to return to the writing of Sebastien de Castell—as told via the dulcet tones of Joe Jameson, the narrator that has read (as far as I’m aware) every single one of his books. I’m a huge fan of Jameson’ read books, and would listen to basically anything narrated by him—as should you!
And with that out of the way—well, do you need any more reason to read this? It took me a little to get into, but once I did, I was hooked. After maybe the 2 hour mark, I had no thoughts of stopping—pretty good for an 18-hour book.
For a book about an opera, this was surprisingly good. Damelas may be a bit of a showboat, but that’s not exactly a bad quality for lead. Even less for a book about acting—specifically acting drawn out of history. The main problem with Damelas is… well, some people are going to find him whiny, and/or annoying. It’s the same problem Kellen had in the Spellslinger series. Shit just keeps ruining his life, and he has opinions about it. Now, I didn’t mind it then and I don’t mind it now, so it’s difficult to say just how bad it is. I’d say… less so than Spellslinger, but I’m just guessing.
Aside from the narrator and the narrative, what more do you want? I mean, this is a book essentially about the theatre, but it’s also the successor series to the Greatcoats, so it’s bound to earn some patience in either regard. The characters are relatively good, though I’d’ve liked (and would like to see) greater development moving forward.
Speaking of moving forward, I do wonder just how much of a thrill this particular troupe of players can muster. Day upon day, night upon night… book upon book? Honestly, I’m a bit concerned moving forward, but nothing more. As far as I’m concerned, this Sebastien de Castell has earned some faith.
February 26, 2024
How have I not heard of Sebastian De Castelo until now? I’m honestly shocked, as it appears there is a Greatcoats series that I’ve now added to my TBR as it sounds amazing.
Alas, let’s talk about Play of Shadows, which I read as a standalone. I’m not sure how this book fares as a continuation of a series, but for me it was a wonderful addition to the fantasy genre. It has everything to make a great fantasy novel (and a beginning of a series), from the world building, dueling, complex characters and conspiracies… mixed with the art of theatre. It added a dramatic and over the top layer that, somehow, works beautifully.
Our main character is a man, descendant of Greatcoats and of whom much is expected because of that, that takes refuge in a theatre after running away from a duel. Eventually, he finds out that he has a rare talent that allows him to re-enact scenes of the past and to discover that history, as it is known, is a lie. So he is swept in a conspiracy based on historical events that transpired one hundred years before.
The only less positive thing I have to point out is that the beginning felt a bit slow. But eventually picked up the pace and became fast paced and exciting.
The characters are incredibly flawed but charming, with a sense of humor that made me laugh out loud in some scenes. The eccentric theatre troupe and their attempts to survive violence, danger, the judgement of their audience and political threats, while always keeping hope and sight of what is right, made this such an enjoyable read for me.
I am definitely continuing this series, as I expect that the next book will be even better as it will expand on the mystery and adventure with this cast of wonderful characters.
Thank you very much Quercus Books, Jo Fletcher Books and NetGallery for providing me this ARC.
Alas, let’s talk about Play of Shadows, which I read as a standalone. I’m not sure how this book fares as a continuation of a series, but for me it was a wonderful addition to the fantasy genre. It has everything to make a great fantasy novel (and a beginning of a series), from the world building, dueling, complex characters and conspiracies… mixed with the art of theatre. It added a dramatic and over the top layer that, somehow, works beautifully.
Our main character is a man, descendant of Greatcoats and of whom much is expected because of that, that takes refuge in a theatre after running away from a duel. Eventually, he finds out that he has a rare talent that allows him to re-enact scenes of the past and to discover that history, as it is known, is a lie. So he is swept in a conspiracy based on historical events that transpired one hundred years before.
The only less positive thing I have to point out is that the beginning felt a bit slow. But eventually picked up the pace and became fast paced and exciting.
The characters are incredibly flawed but charming, with a sense of humor that made me laugh out loud in some scenes. The eccentric theatre troupe and their attempts to survive violence, danger, the judgement of their audience and political threats, while always keeping hope and sight of what is right, made this such an enjoyable read for me.
I am definitely continuing this series, as I expect that the next book will be even better as it will expand on the mystery and adventure with this cast of wonderful characters.
Thank you very much Quercus Books, Jo Fletcher Books and NetGallery for providing me this ARC.
May 24, 2024
This book made me laugh, got me riled up, and hurt my heart. But overall it made my heart so happy to read. You’ve done it again Sebastien! Thank you for your stories!
March 29, 2024
Thank you so much Quercus Books and NetGalley for providing me with this arc in exchange for my honest review.
Sebastien de Castell is a master at creating characters and this 528 pages long start of a very exciting new series, is an incredibly impressive piece of writing art.
I fell in love with the characters and felt entertained from start to finish. There were so many times I was on the edge of my seat and thought I would fall together with the character(s) and sometimes we did and sometimes we didn’t. I honestly never knew which direction any of the huge amount of mysteries and twists in this book would take me.
What I appreciate a lot, every time I read a book by this author, is that there’s always room for humor and lightheartedness.
This starts with a very uncommon hero, one who calls himself a coward, a 25 year old descendant of Greatcoats, called Damelas Chademantaigne. He is running from a lawful duel. Running is his talent but he is about to discover soon that there’s much more to him than he thinks. He ends up at Operato Belleza, home of the Knights of the Curtain who take him in and although it doesn’t seem that way at first, they become the best and most courageous family of friends (and misfits), I could have ever imagined.
Damelas is never safe.. Assassins, a professional duelist, citizen militia, even a fellow actor, political intrigues and a very unexpected but dangerous gift he develops, keep him on his toes all the time. I am so glad he had the best and most loyal friend anyone could imagine, to wind down with in their rickety apartment, with a hilarious landlady!
The city of Jereste, where this takes place, knows a lot of different crimes and poverty. I love how every class and age group had its voice in this novel. And the best thing of all, the common people are given the power to change things. And the way this happens made me have goosebumps and made my yaw drop more than once.
This book brought the meaning of history plays to another level and I can only be grateful that I was allowed to be a member of the audience!
Sebastien de Castell is a master at creating characters and this 528 pages long start of a very exciting new series, is an incredibly impressive piece of writing art.
I fell in love with the characters and felt entertained from start to finish. There were so many times I was on the edge of my seat and thought I would fall together with the character(s) and sometimes we did and sometimes we didn’t. I honestly never knew which direction any of the huge amount of mysteries and twists in this book would take me.
What I appreciate a lot, every time I read a book by this author, is that there’s always room for humor and lightheartedness.
This starts with a very uncommon hero, one who calls himself a coward, a 25 year old descendant of Greatcoats, called Damelas Chademantaigne. He is running from a lawful duel. Running is his talent but he is about to discover soon that there’s much more to him than he thinks. He ends up at Operato Belleza, home of the Knights of the Curtain who take him in and although it doesn’t seem that way at first, they become the best and most courageous family of friends (and misfits), I could have ever imagined.
Damelas is never safe.. Assassins, a professional duelist, citizen militia, even a fellow actor, political intrigues and a very unexpected but dangerous gift he develops, keep him on his toes all the time. I am so glad he had the best and most loyal friend anyone could imagine, to wind down with in their rickety apartment, with a hilarious landlady!
The city of Jereste, where this takes place, knows a lot of different crimes and poverty. I love how every class and age group had its voice in this novel. And the best thing of all, the common people are given the power to change things. And the way this happens made me have goosebumps and made my yaw drop more than once.
This book brought the meaning of history plays to another level and I can only be grateful that I was allowed to be a member of the audience!
March 21, 2024
Did I stay up until 7AM reading this book? Fuck yes I did! And I don't regret a second of it. That alone should tell you how much I loved it.
From the characters, to the setting, to the plot, everything was masterfully done. Is one twist predictable? Yep! But what matters is how we got there, and boy oh boy, did I have a fucking wonderful time. Seriously, this book made laugh out loud at 4AM. It made me cry! Do you know how long it's been since I last cried reading a book? You don't, but I do, and it's been a bloody long time (coming from someone who read The Poppy War trilogy AND The Green Bone Saga in 2024!)
The best way I can describe this book is this: If We Were Villains and One Dark Window had a very witty, sarcastic, chaotic baby. Perfection.
I hadn't read any of the author's other books prior to this, but I sure will now, as I eagerly await the sequel.
Thank you NetGalley and Jo Fletcher for the ARC.
From the characters, to the setting, to the plot, everything was masterfully done. Is one twist predictable? Yep! But what matters is how we got there, and boy oh boy, did I have a fucking wonderful time. Seriously, this book made laugh out loud at 4AM. It made me cry! Do you know how long it's been since I last cried reading a book? You don't, but I do, and it's been a bloody long time (coming from someone who read The Poppy War trilogy AND The Green Bone Saga in 2024!)
The best way I can describe this book is this: If We Were Villains and One Dark Window had a very witty, sarcastic, chaotic baby. Perfection.
I hadn't read any of the author's other books prior to this, but I sure will now, as I eagerly await the sequel.
Thank you NetGalley and Jo Fletcher for the ARC.
January 16, 2025
I thought this would never end
March 14, 2024
"Play of Shadows" is the first book in the new fantasy series “Court of Shadows” by Sebastien de Castell. The narrative centres on Damelas, the grandson of two of the most acclaimed Greatswords, and a terrible swordhand, who is evading the most infamous dueller, the Vixen. The way he does it? Tricking his way into the company of actors, The Knights of the Curtain, who reside at the Operato Belleza.
The Belleza provides sanctuary due to an archaic law and Demalas maintains his residence at the Operato by performing supporting roles such as the Herald. However, on one particular show night, his world gets turned upside down after he fumbles his lines on stage and announces that the city’s most legendary hero may not be that after all…
De Castell exhibits a deft hand in character development, crafting a diverse cast who are flawed yet charming in their own way, with great humour and witty banter! Particularly noteworthy are Paeder's poignant reflections on his late wife, Virany, which resonate deeply and had me crying . De Castell definitely captured the feeling of eternal and unwavering love with this character.
Due to the complexity of the plot, there is a lot going on in this book, and I did occasionally struggle to keep up in places. I also found that the pacing of the book overall was quite varied, with some parts feeling much slower than others.
However, if you love the arts, fantasy plots thick with magic, spirits, betrayal, duelling and battles, this book is definitely for you! I look forward to reading more of de Castell’s work in future to see where these character’s end up.
Thank you to Netgalley and Jo Fletcher Books for the eARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.
The Belleza provides sanctuary due to an archaic law and Demalas maintains his residence at the Operato by performing supporting roles such as the Herald. However, on one particular show night, his world gets turned upside down after he fumbles his lines on stage and announces that the city’s most legendary hero may not be that after all…
De Castell exhibits a deft hand in character development, crafting a diverse cast who are flawed yet charming in their own way, with great humour and witty banter! Particularly noteworthy are Paeder's poignant reflections on his late wife, Virany, which resonate deeply and had me crying . De Castell definitely captured the feeling of eternal and unwavering love with this character.
Due to the complexity of the plot, there is a lot going on in this book, and I did occasionally struggle to keep up in places. I also found that the pacing of the book overall was quite varied, with some parts feeling much slower than others.
However, if you love the arts, fantasy plots thick with magic, spirits, betrayal, duelling and battles, this book is definitely for you! I look forward to reading more of de Castell’s work in future to see where these character’s end up.
Thank you to Netgalley and Jo Fletcher Books for the eARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.
September 5, 2025
3.5⭐️ round up for Goodreads.
Play of Shadows by Sebastian De Castell is unlike anything I’ve read in a while. The setting is deeply unique, steeped in art, theater, and poetry. It feels more like stepping into a sonnet than a fantasy novel. The language is gorgeous and artistic, and at times I was completely immersed in its beauty.
That said, the pacing did drag here and there, and I’ll be honest… sometimes I felt lost. I don’t exactly “speak” in actor, singer, or troubadour, so I had to slow down and really parse the words to keep up. The plot itself was good, but it felt like we were thrown in without much background, and I wanted just a touch more grounding.
Beretto, though? He has my whole heart. ♥️
Ultimately, this is a book I’d recommend to readers who love theater-inspired fantasy or stories with a troubadour flair. It’s beautiful, immersive, and poetic, even if it sometimes left me working harder than I expected to follow along.
Play of Shadows by Sebastian De Castell is unlike anything I’ve read in a while. The setting is deeply unique, steeped in art, theater, and poetry. It feels more like stepping into a sonnet than a fantasy novel. The language is gorgeous and artistic, and at times I was completely immersed in its beauty.
That said, the pacing did drag here and there, and I’ll be honest… sometimes I felt lost. I don’t exactly “speak” in actor, singer, or troubadour, so I had to slow down and really parse the words to keep up. The plot itself was good, but it felt like we were thrown in without much background, and I wanted just a touch more grounding.
Beretto, though? He has my whole heart. ♥️
Ultimately, this is a book I’d recommend to readers who love theater-inspired fantasy or stories with a troubadour flair. It’s beautiful, immersive, and poetic, even if it sometimes left me working harder than I expected to follow along.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 252 reviews