While I liked Witchblood, I had some issues along the way, which made me not love it.
Let's start with the cover - it's lovely, enough, but that guy is almost as pale as I am and in the story he is repeatedly described as much darker skinned (Seb is interracial - Japanese/Black). Why the hell is the dude on the cover so damn white?! Also, I think the story could have used another round of editing. It was very repetitive and dragged in several places. And then there's Seb -- when characters refuse to get out of their own way, it kind of makes me want to smack them with their own book, and boy was he in his own way. I certainly got where his trust issues came from. He wasn't treated well by the wolves of the pack he grew up with, and he was abused by the son of the pack alpha, repeatedly, so I got his apprehension, but, damn. Lastly, I felt there was a fuck-ton more telling, than showing, which could also explain why my patience with Seb was a bit lacking.
There was a lot of promise, here, though. I kind of liked that the shifters were different from my normal shifter novel. In this universe, wolves are made, not born, and the trauma is long lasting. Once a wolf is made and lives through the process, they live until they kill themselves or each other. Also, once they find their true-mate, they typically die if their mate does...well, except for a couple other wolves who managed to survive it, weirdly enough. That was kind of different for me, and I liked it.
I do like a lot of conflict and angst in my stories, and Witchblood certainly delivered there, so while I'm rating it at 3 stars, I think, with some decent editing and a cover that actually matched the character, it could have a 4.5 star potential, so not a bad effort, I suppose.