Disclaimer: I am relatively new to the arena of ASD, do not have a Dr diagnosis, and my education/experience is primarily self-directed and based on “high-functioning”/“low support” experience.
I *do* share Hendrickson’s Biblical worldview (generally) so really wanted to like this book, but it’s iffy at best, and falls into the unfortunate error of early “Biblical” counseling where the physical realities of an ailment are severely downplayed or outright overlooked in a sincere effort to address the - also real - spiritual and emotional elements.
I would recommend this only as a very soft, introductory reading on the topic, to be read alongside and compared with more knowledgeable resources. For the parent who’s new to asd and in the throes, the sympathetic tone of the first couple chapters could provide an encouraging balm before needing to push on to more solid and in-depth sources of practical wisdom on the topic.
She does offer some good principals and strategies for parenting, in general, though.
I made the assumption that because it’s written by a Dr., it’d have much more scientific and medical background and explanation of ASD. Instead, it’s largely anecdotal. There are some wise principals, but they’re explained primarily through personal examples of her son.
Some of the info appears outdated or not thoroughly researched (e.g. Asperger’s is still referred to as a separate dx.). She refers to the movie Rain Man more than scientific or medical data that explains what’s happening in the ASD brain and body.
Also, Hendrickson is a former psychiatrist and not a specialist in ASD. Multiple times when she makes practical suggestions, it’s because “this is what the behaviorist we hired did,” without much further support or explanation. It actually made me want to read a book by the behaviorist instead of this one.
My concerns:
1)Her focus on stimming is about limiting and modifying it, without developing an understanding of WHY it’s happening and resolving problematic stims by getting to their root (ie. recognizing and reducing overstimulation). She writes, “And for whatever reason it happens, stimming is very gratifying,” without delving into any science that provides very good reason why stimming is happening, and therefore truly helpful and effective ways to address it, when needed.
She also gives the blanket statement “Stimming interferes with learning , because when a spectrum kid is stimming , he’s paying attention to his stem, not to what you are trying to teach him.” While this may be the case in some situations, she clearly hasn’t experienced the mental relief and ability to focus that can come directly from stimming.
2)I am personally not familiar with nor experienced with therapies, but she does recommend ABA which I know has become controversial in ASD circles.
3)She addresses “3 Main Emotions that Motivate Problem Behaviors” - which is fine, but problematic when she brushes past the very real physiological issues happening underneath those. She gives those a quick acknowledgment but leaves her readers without direction and answers on this very much needed topic so they can truly understand what an ASD person is experiencing and therefore how to approach it more effectively. I do appreciate that she still addresses the spiritual and moral responsibilities of an ASD person, though.
4)When addressing social/communication issues, she says, “The problem is, a spectrum kid genuinely doesn’t know how to meet others in the middle.” As if it’s always the ASD person’s flaw/fault there, when in reality many typical people don’t know how to be flexible enough to meet an ASD person in the middle. It’s sadly ironic she doesn’t consider this here as on the very next page she addresses how frequently ASD people are taunted, bullied, and manipulated by typical people, but then immediately still turns the arrow at the ASD person for “selfish and sinful” behavior it seems we “[make] excuses for.” She continues “So training your [ASD] child to understand others better is only part of your job. The other part is constantly confronting him with Christ’s claims on his life.” SO true but also so harshly directed at the ASD kid even in the direct context of a bully of a typical kid - who doesn’t even have a disorder as an excuse, right? - who is demonstrating a gross lack of understanding for atypicals, and needs confrontation for blatant meanness and cruelty vs the atypical’s unintentional yet perceived “rudeness.” The author would do well to address how parents can support their ASD kid who gets bullied instead of only making the ASD kid the bad guy, the only one who needs to change.
Basically, the main tone of the book becomes how to “improve” the ASD kid - which if done for their benefit and for their gain, great! But what the author doesn’t seem to know to factor in is the steep cost to the individual at which “improvement” (which often becomes masking) can come.
So generally speaking she shares some helpful principles and strategies, but the imbalance of a lack of understanding and knowledge of what the ASD person is actually experiencing physiologically makes it fall flat and leaves some major gaps in how to fully support that child in effective way.
The last chapter ends on a high and encouraging note focused on God’s sovereignty on who we are and what we become. So that one would be worth a read for those new to ASD parents struggling with those questions and concerns.