Of the multitude of books written about George Washington, very few focus exclusively on his post-presidential years. In a life full of historic events, this makes sense: Washington by that point in his life had done everything that a man could possibly do, and he lived less than three years after leaving office, so we are also dealing with a relatively short time period. However, these few years were not void of drama, and despite Washington vowing to basically stick close to home and rarely leave, he did leave once and it made news.
Being the first President, there was of course no precedent for being the first former President. He had not wanted to remain in the presidency, citing both his age and the importance it would mean to the young nation to see a peaceful transfer of power to someone else. When Washington voluntarily retired, what was left for him to do? The nation was at peace. There was no higher government job to go into. And he had spent the majority of the past quarter century away from his beloved plantation of Mount Vernon in Virginia. So that is where he returned.
Aside from Washington occasionally venturing the dozen or so miles into the new federal city being built on a site that he chose, only one event of true importance occurred during this time period. There was a quasi-war with France (there never actually was a war - thanks mainly to a few cooler heads in Paris and also to new President John Adams never giving up on negotiating - but most everyone thought there would be one). Cajoled (or perhaps manipulated is a better word?) by his former Secretary of the Treasury, Alexander Hamilton, into once again being willing to answer the call of his country, Washington allowed himself to get caught up in Hamilton's grasp for his own military glory and authority. A charade began over the ranking of major generals who would serve under Washington. Honestly, reading this now, nobody came out of here looking good. Hamilton, as usual, was a schemer and a megalomaniac. Adams was weak, allowing himself to be bounced like a yoyo between Washington and his own disloyal Cabinet who were basically acting as mouthpieces for Hamilton. The Secretary of War, James McHenry, was somewhat of a dunce who took his marching orders from Hamilton. In addition to this farce, Washington became obsessed with getting a new uniform. It turned out that the uniform never arrived prior to his death because everything had to come from Europe, and even then America apparently did not have anyone skilled enough to sew on the fancy epaulets and stars.
Jonathan Horn details all of this, along with Washington's regular activities at his home, and the slow construction of the soon-to-be nation's capitol. Thankfully the book is a relatively short read, and Horn had the habit of putting multiple different words within the same sentence in quotation marks. What he was doing was taking individual words, or sometimes phrases, from a letter, and putting that word into a sentence, but also putting other individual words from other letters into that same sentence. Here is an example from page 47:
Those trying to fill the void knew "nothing of cooking" or "arranging a table." The "inconvenience" for Martha was especially "great" given that her personal attendant, Oney, "who was brought up and treated more like a child than a servant," had also recently fled.
That annoyed me. If it was a few sentences scattered throughout the book, I could accept it. But this was on almost every page. That probably comes down to personal preference. He also would frequently shift perspective within chapters, letting someone see a few pages from Adams' views, then bringing in Thomas Jefferson for a few pages. I found this a little jarring as well.
Horn does do a good job of showing how Washington allowed himself to be Hamilton's tool in 1798 during the Quasi-war. He also reviews Washington's role as a slaveowner, but he does not go into especially great detail here. Nor does he dwell on Washington's dire financial straits, although they are mentioned periodically. Washington's final illness is covered well. The end came quickly, as up to even just a few days prior to his death, Washington was a healthy man, especially given his age (67) during that era. Each time I read about Washington's death scene, it is almost nauseating due to the amount of times that his dumb doctors bled him. That did nothing! Except make him weaker. It really makes you realize how barbaric the practice of medicine was back then. Death seemed to perch itself on everyone's front porch and just wait for the next virus to come along.
Horn finishes with two chapters following Washington's death. They are about the beginnings of government in Washington D.C., and the 1800 election. Horn posits that, had he lived, Washington would have allowed himself to have been convinced (probably at least in part by Hamilton) to stand for election. Given that Washington did not have to be pushed too hard to return as a general, I think that is a fair assumption. This was a man who was long used to power and influence. Just riding around his plantation, when it came down to it, was not enough. It is also difficult to see Washington, once the seat of government shifted to D.C. in the fall of 1800, being able to stay away with him living just a few stone's throws down the Potomac River.
I do appreciate that Horn decided to focus on what is usually treated as an afterthought period of Washington's life. Washington was still busy enough to make this part of his life interesting to read about. I would have preferred a different writing style though.
Grade: D+