Having read and enjoyed the first novel in A.J. Pine's Meadow Valley series, My One and Only Cowboy, I was eager to read the next book in the series, and although it got off to a rather slow and unsettling start, by one-quarter of the way in, I was so hooked that I read the rest of the novel straight through until 6:00 a.m. and although there was one minor issue in the novel that bothered me, it was nevertheless a deeply moving, well-written and emotional read and it gets 4 stars from this reader.
As the novel open, brothers Ben and Sam Callahan are in a doctor's office waiting for the results of Sam's test, a test that will determine his future. In the first Meadow Valley novel, which I highly suggest you read first, we learn that their father, Nolan, has early-onset Alzheimer's disease and is living in a nursing home. Ben secretly had his blood tested 6 months earlier, and the result was positive--something he didn't share with his family, not wanting to burden them. Knowing what his future looked like, he developed a rather devil-may-care attitude, couldn't see the point in starting any long-term relationships, and also began slacking off at the family ranch. But this is the day Sam will get his results, and Ben is stunned when the doctor gives them the good news--neither brother carries the genetic marker for early-onset Alzheimer's. Ben is stunned by the news, but after the doctor does some checking, he discovers that Ben was given the results of another Ben Callahan living in the county, and once he knows he has a future to look forward to, he decides to start taking his life and each day in it more seriously--especially after having a no-strings, 2-week fling with Doctor Charlotte North, a New York pediatrician who was taking a couple of weeks off from her busy practice to spend some mandatory vacation time with her grandmother who runs the Meadow Valley Inn.
Charlotte returned to New York after her vacation, but isn't back long when she receives a phone call from her cousin, letting her know that her beloved grandmother has fallen off a ladder, been injured and rushed to the ER, and will need help running the inn for at least the next 6 to 8 weeks. Charlotte packs her bags, takes a 2-month leave of absence, and takes the first flight she can get back to Meadow Valley. As soon as she gets to the ER waiting room, there sits Ben, asleep. He's been waiting there a good part of the day while Grandma Pearl was in surgery, and Charlotte, whom Ben refers to as Doc, drops her suitcase and rushes past him rather rudely. For a good part of the novel, I spent quite a bit of time disliking Charlotte and her tendency to become so self-absorbed by her medical practice in New York, and her attitude of self-importance in the practice. There are sick children everywhere, and who ever heard of an unemployed physician? Quite frankly I didn't quite understand why Ben found her so alluring.
Once Charlotte gets to the inn, she is overwhelmed by what she doesn't know about running such an establishment, but Pearl, wheelchair-bound with one arm in a sling is soon ensconced in her room, and there are other employees who show Charlotte the ropes. Grandma Pearl is well aware that outside of her practice, Charlotte doesn't have much of a social life, and almost immediately starts matchmaking, which is the last thing Charlotte wants. Out of desperation and still attracted to Ben, she enlists his help to pretend to be her fake date for the duration of her stay, although she's very clear that they will simply be friends for the duration of her stay, but these two friends started out as a hot fling, and it's clear that both are attracted to one another, although Charlotte, keeps reminding both Ben and herself that as soon as her grandmother is back on her feet, she's returning to her career in New York, ad nauseum, and that is the reason I spent a good deal of this book disliking her. She wants Ben but she doesn't want to want him, not for the long-term, and she gives him plenty of mixed messages. As a romance reader, I'm not a fan of waffling, or of one person in a relationship using the other, and yet despite her on again, off again, flirting, jealousy, and distancing, Ben was simply wonderful to her, attentive, kind, and willing to do anything he possibly could to help her out, please her, and spend time with her, wanting, for the first time in his life, to take a relationship seriously. I did, however, like the role-reversal, and found it refreshing that in this novel, it wasn't the male lead character who was doing the waffling for a change, in this lovers to friends to lovers romance.
Despite the waffling on Charlotte's part, I eventually was drawn into this well-plotted, emotional read and the excellent development and depth of its characters, most especially Ben. All in all, despite my issues with the heroine, I found Make Mine a Cowboy to be a rather satisfying read and I am happy to recommend it.
I voluntarily read an advance reader copy of this novel. The opinions expressed are my own.