Disclaimer: I received a free advanced readers' copy of this book, though I like would have bought the book simply on the strength of CJ Box being the author, as I'm a huge Joe Pickett fan and I enjoyed the first Cody Hoyt book, "Back of Beyond". I keep Joe Pickett novels, in fact, on perpetual pre-order-without-a-thought mode.
First, the book's strengths:
The setting. As always, Box provides a great sense of place, in this case, the world of truckers, and the usual rural areas of Wyoming and Montana near Yellowstone. His description of the typical truck stop seems spot on from my (admittedly non-trucker) experience with the one near my town, which is in a rural area along an interstate. I've been in the truck stop at various times and there's definitely a "truckers vs civilians" vibe... and never the twain really meet. I could definitely feel the pulse of the interstate in this novel. Interstates to the casual eye seem relatively benign places that we zip along in our automotive cocoons, but anyone who's lived near one can tell you the dangers zipping by, from drug runners to murderers and rapists looking for victims. As outlandish as the Lizard King might seem, it's not too far a stretch to believe such a criminal could exist.
The general plot. Box always does well to put together thrillers with a twist, and this is no exception, generally speaking. The plot moves along fairly quickly and comes together logically, and there's a sense of urgency throughout.
*Some* of the characters. I enjoyed seeing Justin again, Hoyt's son. And I liked Gracie's pluck and spirit.
But now for the reasons I could only give the book 2 stars:
The characters. The book really should have been called "The Lizard King", because it seemed like most of the best-detailed chapters centered on him. Box created quite an evil criminal, and while it's interesting, I guess, to see into the mind of a reprobate serial killer, it's also disturbing and not really something I enjoy. I much prefer staying in the head of the "good guy". Also, one of the victims--a teenage girl--was so annoying I found myself actually hoping that she'd soon be killed. That's... probably not a response you want to evoke in your readers, but then again, Box has gone in a darker direction with this one, so maybe that was his intention.
And the biggie: the mid-novel plot twist. I say "twist" but I'm really thinking "shocker". Trying not to be spoilery, but it's impossible to express my thoughts here without it being fairly obvious what happens: Cody Hoyt is basically out of the series named for him. This to me was just... unacceptable. I put the book down and it was nearly two weeks before I could pick it up again and finish it (and by "finish", I mean, "skim to the end"). I felt cheated, almost as if I'd been on the receiving end of a bait-and-switch scheme. Admittedly, I tend to get very attached to protagonists, and Hoyt was such an imperfect hero that I had invested quite a lot in rooting for him and hoping that he'd eventually get his act together despite himself. It was maddening, then, to have that yanked so precipitously away, in no small part because it comes across very much like Box had written himself into a corner with Hoyt's character and instead of finding a way out of it, took the easy route and simply dispensed of the troubled man. I *might* not have been so annoyed if the secondary character who takes over the chase had been introduced with more depth, but she seemed too much a barely-there supporting character up to that point, and though she became more dimensional after that point, the book suffered for her weak development in the beginning. I never felt any connection with her (probably because I'm still smarting over what happened to Hoyt).
So... with this disappointment behind me, I'm still very much looking forward to the next Joe Pickett novel (and crossing all fingers and toes that Box doesn't make a similar move with him. I admire an author taking such risks if the story demands but... yeah, killing off Joe would break my heart in eight million tiny pieces, so if you read this, Mr. Box, don't. Just... don't!)
I might or might not read the next novel in this now-misnamed Cody Hoyt series. If I do, it will be via the library.