per my last update of this book, I decided not to rate this book because it does not deserve so. And I was not going to write a review because of my huge disappointment & frustration; but after much deliberation, I decided to write one (mainly venting) for my goodreads friends as a friendship courtesy because you guys deserve to know not only why I’m feeling the way I am, but in hopes of saving you time, money, and energy.
.
I know the author is on this site, but someone needs to say it, and I’ll do it. This is mostly going to be me venting my frustration at the author, publisher, and publishing industry, so if you’re looking for an in-depth review of the book and/or not interested in reading a reader venting, feel free to stop here. Please respect & understand that people will have differing opinions & thoughts regarding an author and/or book, and I try to never cross the line of writing negatively about the author, I always try to stay focus on the book in itself. There are few instances where I do have to mention something about the author, it happens mostly for nonfiction books where I can be more matter-of-factly, where I deeply feel they could’ve done better for the level they’re on, and when I strongly feel that their fans and/or readers deserve much, much better.
.
From here, I’ve taken bits of my own review of Bernstein’s “Judgement Detox” because I felt exactly the same after finishing Rubin’s book. Whenever a book doesn’t work out for me, I always say — there are no bad books, just bad timing or chemistry. First of all, I’ve read all of Rubin’s books and listened to her podcast for awhile, but no longer do. Not a fan per say, but somehow ended up riding along her popularity. You guys know, I love self-help, personal-development, and spirituality books, so I’ve read it all, heard it all. I want to be respectful of author’s effort & time, I know it’s a lot of hard work & not easy putting your work out there and certainly feel they should be rightly compensated for it. However, this book is just wrong. It shouldn’t have ended up in a book form, she should’ve kindly shared it in a blog or as an article. To put this ultra-popular declutter concept and writing it as if it’s something of your own and/or making it sound like such a revolutionary concept just seems really silly to me, also unfair to the readers & her fans. I cannot be the only person that felt like this book was written just for the sake of writing a book, just to put something out there — nothing new, nothing interesting, nothing groundbreaking, but certainly could be useful to some people. It’s like, “here, let’s declutter, so buy a book!”
.
I know, there really isn’t anything “new” out there, per say. If you think about it, everyone is just “borrowing” each other’s ideas and writing it in their voices, for their readers. Even for Marie, it wasn’t that her idea was new or fresh, but she took initiative to bring it mainstream & popularized it, so many people thing she created the concept.
.
As someone considered as though-leader, expert, and guru of our generation, she could’ve done better. We deserve better as readers who is also spending hard-earned money. I never want to say don’t buy a book, but try borrowing it from the library first. This is where I’m upset about the publisher & publishing industry, I can’t even believe that the editors didn’t say, we can’t publish this. Is this something worth the value? There’s a popular topic/concept, Rubin’s considered expert in living best life, so let’s put together a book. I know Rubin is well-known for her painstaking research for her books, but this was like gather ideas readers already know & wrap it in a nice cover w/easy-to-read formatting. I am pissed of as an avid reader and someone who have supported her work that she thought this was deserving of our attention, money, and time. I am pissed off at the publishers taking advantage of readers with a popular is topic & popular author. It’s frustrating that this will be one of the biggest & bestselling books of the year, and I guess that’s why publishers will publish it. I am mad at myself for falling for it, again. I know this wasn’t fun to read, but if you made it to the end, thank you! It certainly wasn’t fun to write it, but someone needs to say it. If you’ve never read a book on this topic, you may like it or find it helpful, it’s a pretty quick read.