After an eventful summer and an especially eventful festival, a lot was said between Adachi and Shimamura. And finally, (finally!) they're a couple. But what, exactly, does that mean? And while they're reckoning with that, they'll both be grappling with the fact that, on paper, this isn't necessarily the greatest idea...
From humble, somewhat fraught beginnings came this series that started rough, but then turned into a ball of endless angst and charm that is definitely out to appeal to a certain audience (hello!) but doesn’t forget to be interesting along the way.
On the one hand, this feels like an immediate payoff to six previous volumes of simmering tension (at least on Adachi’s part) and subtle hints and exasperated conversations and heartfelt declarations. If that was all the book was, it wouldn’t need to proceed any further than its first chapter, where reflections on the previous evening are had and phone calls are made and words, oh yes, words, are said (the series could have ended there and I’d have been set).
But this series is more than that and its characters are more than that and it’s why this series constantly feels like something special. There is no question that the laser-focused Adachi is obsessive about her relationship with Shimamura to an unhealthy degree.
There is a big question, however, about why Shimamura is putting up with this to the extent that she does - she says things that have a weight to them that she may not even fully appreciate, but also realizes that Adachi’s got nothing else in her life except for her love for Shimamura and that can’t be good for either of them.
Or can it? There are a lot of ways to take what happens in this instalment (one of my favourite aspects of the series), which is full of Adachi being as disastrously lesbian as she’s ever been and Shimamura just accepting her, but realizing that her new girlfriend might go way, way too far.
What any good relationship can do, no matter its romantic inclinations, is change the people involved for the better and, well, Adachi is not oblivious to her own failings any more than Shimamura is unaware that she’s emotionally shallow and is now faced with somebody who can fill that pool up and then some.
I can’t explain what’s so fascinating about these two, but they never fail to be interesting and watching them wrestle with this issue, whether consciously or not, is compelling. Adachi ends up paired with a surprising conspirator while planning a date that brings back one of the oddest running bits in the whole series.
It’s a subtle nod that, yeah, Adachi only has eyes for Shimamura, but finally having that acceptance in her life is making her open to the idea of other people. Further, Adachi acknowledges that she can’t push too hard or it will shove Shimamura away. There’s growth here, slowly.
Shimamura’s subconscious, meanwhile, makes an extensive appearance during the last chapter and provides a valuable piece of her puzzle - we get a much better idea of who she was in junior high and why accepting Adachi might just make sense for her. At the very least she sees something to admire in her new partner.
Despite all this introspection and analysis, the book doesn't forget to be fun either. It isn't hilarious, but there are more than a few chuckles throughout. Shimamura is absolutely vicious (playfully!) in knowing how to push Adachi's buttons and she leans hard into doing so with gleeful abandon at times.
There are also great separate moments where BOTH girls mention how Nagafuji and Hino have to be more than just friends at this point, which is pretty great (doubly so since… not so much…)
I would be remiss if I did not single out the interlude that ends this novel as being absolutely freaking adorable. Destiny is normally a bit of an eye-roller, but this digression kind of goes the extra mile and it's an oddly reassuring thing to know that no matter what alternate reality one might visit, there's an Adachi and a Shimamura and they will figure out a way to make it work.
You could argue this strips some of the narrative tension, and you'd be right, but we had tension for six light novels; it's okay for things to just be fluffy - you can't say that it wasn't earned. This is comfort food that eats like a meal.
5 stars - these two don't necessarily need to go anywhere else, but they will, and it'll definitely be fun seeing how things develop and what kind of mischief they get up to. Certainly imperfect, but no less lovable for it. Now where have I heard that before?