So much hope and promise but ultimately let me down.
I was jumping for joy and giddy with glee when this book dropped. A butch rancher with a soft spot for puppies falling in love with the femme veterinarian? Oh, Hell yes, sign me up!
I adore stories set in the country, and I love reading about the butch rancher taking on those backbreaking tasks around the ranch, but unfortunately, I was disappointed with the lack of description with a lot of things. I felt cheated for one. Only a few times we got to see Bobbie working on the ranch and none of those times really let us sink our teeth into the kind of work she was performing. Two, I still don't know what Bobbie Del Ray really looked like. There was a scene where she joked to two female patrons at a restaurant about needing her hair held back when she was sick. Then there was a scene where she had run her hand through her hair, tousling it on top of her head as if it were cut short. What'd I miss? Apparently, she was tall and broad, but that's it. It grates on my nerves when I don't know what the characters look like. I understand that Mending Fences was the author's debut, and as much as they excelled in some areas, they fell flat for character description. Bobbie was a sweetheart with patience, even if it was mentioned several times by other characters that she was the opposite. I didn't really see the impatience they referred to on more than one occasion. Bobbie, however, also flipped her personality during sex and turned into some kind of dominant sex fiend. The language that poured off her tongue jolted my system. Now, I am no prude, and I love dirty talk, but this dirty talk didn't quite match the character and her kind of personality. It felt forced and bordered on cringe-worthy. And as soon as the sex ended, ol' sweet Bobbie was back in formation. *scratches head*.
Side note: I love me explicit sex, but "covered in come" made me think of a bukkake scene in a bad porn.
Grace Hammond the sweet veterinarian. This woman couldn't make a decision for the life of her. I couldn't even find it in me to sympathize or empathize with her, let alone pity her. She was one of those women that boo-hooed her way through life. She claimed to be happy in certain aspects of her life and how she was this independent woman, but she just couldn't make a decision! I pitied her husband/ex-husband at times, and the line he delivered was gold:
"Goddamnit, Grace. You avoid conflict to the point you leave a trail of misery in your path. Get a fucking backbone. Be honest with yourself and maybe you'll stop breaking everyone's heart."
I wanted to high five him. Only a little, because he was an ass mostly. He acted oblivious to Grace's feelings and wants most of the time. However, I couldn't fault him too harshly because he was married to a woman who withheld her true identity from him for years, and then dropped the D bomb on him. It was just a cluster-f*ck of a marriage that was fueled by neglect, discrimination, and low self-esteem. Thanks to Grace's parents. And as for asses, Grace's mother was one real piece of work, too. She was cold, just plain cold. I couldn't warm up to Grace's and her mother's reunion, because it felt unnatural. I didn't have enough ground work for me to have any kind emotion towards their volatile relationship. As for Grace's co-workers/friends, well, they drove me bonkers. Women who giggle and get drunk then fall down laughing, I can't stand women like that in real life and I loathe having to read women like that. And Grace was probably the worst.
I was hoping for heat and passion when the two protagonists reunited with the puppy, but instead, it felt like old friends catching up. With the lack of character description, I couldn't understand where their physical attraction for one another came from. I certainly understood the emotional side because they had been in love as teenagers and their love never wavered. You can only say how good looking one is until the reader, themselves, want to know what it is that is so damn hot or "studly" like one character had described Bobbie. What the hell was so studly about her? Tell me!
Side note: another fault I found was in one scene Grace was wearing a beautiful, feminine floral dress that had Bobbie swooning, and later on in the day, Grace was wearing jeans and a shirt. I retraced my steps to see if she had changed clothes during their date, but I found no evidence. Details like that can really distract the reader if they're honed in on descriptive details, and I'm one of them.
I'm not giving up on this author since this was their debut. I could have sugar-coated my review but then how would the writer learn from their mistakes? It's how I learned. 3 stars from me.