With this, my journey with the Half-Orcs is over (for now). There's been many moments I loved throughout the series, many characters I loved, and for most of them I grieved. The first part is going to be about overall all the main characters, and then I'll review the book.
I want to begin with my three beloved ones: Jerico, Tarlak. and Qurrah. Jerico was always my favorite one during both the Paladins and the Half-Orcs. The man who changed my view of the world, the man who taught me the importance of love and compassion. The man I admired, the man I really cried for, the man I felt him being a broken human despite all the heroic actions he performed, and probably the man I spent most of my time. It was so nice to witness his journey through almost 9 books. Every time I read him, I just wanted to give a hug to that huge, unshakable, indestructible man. But sometimes I felt like his emotions weren't completely shown. But not in this book, it's for another book.
Tarlak, who I deemed 'rip-off yellow Gandalf' the moment I saw him but grew with him as the story continued. I felt his pain in every moment he was sad, I always saw his inner side, which was broken and cloaked under his wit. Yet I enjoyed every moment I spent with him.
And Qurrah, who I said "This man literally grew up, became a real man!" at the last moments of his life. Though his death wasn't how I expected it. Not bad, but not enough. I also can say that Qurrah was, unarguably, most complicated and most changed character throughout all the story, and one of the very few whom I enjoyed to read every second of him.
Now let's talk about those who I loved lesser. These are Lathaar, Tesenna, Haern, Dieredon, Jessilynn, Delysia, Mira, Brug, Antonil Copernus, Aheasarus, and probably a few others who I don't remember their names right now. I can't say much about those. These dudes were (mostly) nice and interesting, yet I never felt the same emotions what I felt for Jerico or Qurrah or Tarlak. When something happened to them, I just said 'eh', when they died, I just said 'whatever', when they were happy, I just said 'okay', when they felt sad, I just said 'meh'. There hasn't been a bond between me and them.
And those I never loved: Aurelia and Harruq. It isn't like they were mediocre-written or something. It was just because they never felt reliable. They were the gods of Dezrel, those who reshaped the entire history with their thoughts, and this just felt, 'awkward'. Despite their losses, despite their pain, I couldn't feel anything for them. And I never worried about them, for I knew they were too OP to die, and this also ruined the relationship between them and me. For example when Jerico was about to die at the end of book three, I just cried almost all the day. But when they were in the same situation, I just said 'Nah, they will survive anyway.'
Now, I want to talk about the book. It was quite nice, and I really enjoyed many moments especially the fall of the Citadel, but also there were a few moments I didn't like and a few flaws.
The first is Darius. I mean I love him, as much as I love Tarlak and Qurrah. But why him? Why does he have to be Jessilynn's guide? I think he's the last man who deserves to be mentor of someone. It would be nice if he only had showed up to Jerico. I also didn't like the part where Azariah sees himself getting killed by Harruq. It would absolutely be better with the slightest change: Put Judarius in stead of Harruq, and voila! With that, you have the tenfold better scenario. Especially right before the conflict between them, that scene would be thousands of times better. Brothers could question each other and the relationship between them could completely collapse. And I also would like a part to be spared for the moment where Jerico and Darius meeting by a lake in Dezrel. Not the most necessary thing, but it would be nice anyway.
And the flaws. The first one is Anora. While she died in the book seven, she appears at the Hemman Fields in the book eight. I thought it's because the passing 5 years between the seventh and eighth books, but I'm not sure since Dalglish said that he read the book six and seven before writing the book eight. Another flaw is the angels and beasts. While Dieredon said that there were almost 20000 beasts approaching the Castle of Yellow Rose, and Ahaesarus said that he had 3000 Angels with him, a third of them, we see that there are only 400 Angels and 6000 beasts. Beasts can be explained since there are many reasons for their numbers to decrease, but what happened to 2400 Angels who didn't see their fallen brethren until the battle in the Hemman Fields?
Speaking of flaws, there's also a huge flaw about every villain throughout the entire story. Velixar and Thulos dies so weird and in a 'fairytale' way. Kevin Maryll had a great potential, and despite his small appearance during the Paladins series, he really managed to impress me in book six. I always thought what would happen in a scenario where he survived, killed Harruq and Aurelia before their really idiotic victory against him, and fought against Azariah, led his people into a grim future, an almost-impossible victory, instead of Harruq. But he really died too idiotically. Also Azariah's death was too 'unreliable'. Every main character alive and in Mordeina gathers, Azariah defeats all of them one by one, and then, in the blink of an eye, protagonists win, without losing anyone in that battle. I think David Dalglish really hates the villains he writes and kills them in most absurdly and fairytale-ish way.
Overall, it was a nice journey and truth be told, I felt empty when it ended. And I don't think that one last book is necessary. I think there's no stuff you can tell. We earned our two fairytale-ish endings and I think unless David Dalglish is gonna write a few more books, there's no need for book nine. Perhaps he can tell what happened to those damn Orcs and their Demon Lord but other than that there's not much he can tell.
P.S: I didn't feel anything at the epilogue, unlike other readers. Perhaps it's because I never read the Shadowdance series, and probably never will (because Haern isn't most interesting man in my book).