It was a mix of a light read and a heavy read for me.
On one hand, it was very much an amalgamation of your go-to tropes and themes from these kinds of romance books. Friends to enemies to friends to lovers romance plot. And, as I have frequently found, a healthy mix of inner monologuing condemning misogyny and thinly veiled misogyny from many characters.
On the other hand, the dead brother plot point really got to me. Perhaps it has to do with my own experience of losing a sibling figure in my life recently, but it still got me in my feels frequently.
On that note, I was really confused and distressed about how the three friends went about their attempts to help the ~MC~. She was very clearly clinically depressed after losing her brother and begins to act out with self-destructive behaviors. One may think a gentler approach would better suit the situation from all parties, but no.
We have these dudes (mainly Reid) just saying the most buck-wild things to someone who just lost their brother. "You're disgracing your brother's memory," for wearing sweats and dyeing her hair? Dude told her that she was just attention-seeking and it "wouldn't bring her brother back." Any morsel of tact could've been cool, or whatever.
Also, they just straight up refuse to let her have any free will? Like, I understand they're trying to push her to continue with life and not let herself get sucked into the tide of grief; however, the whole forcing her to wear things she doesn't want to and forcing her to go places she doesn't want to (thinly-veiled kidnapping) was mad weird. I understand how it can be explained away, but it just reeked of "you, a girl with a whole brain and sense of self, cannot possibly know what is best for you, so I, a high school guy with the emotional maturity of a saltine cracker, will make every decision for you." Like, this is a human person, not a fucking barbie doll.
Also, speaking of high school guys with the emotional maturity of a saltine cracker, the relationship Reid had with Sasha (the antagonist of the book series) made no sense. Firstly, ~MC~ is consistently told that sex will not heal her, but Reid's relationship with this genuinely terrible person is constantly excused as "his way of healing." Their relationship had been toxic through and through, described as only ever fighting or f*cking. Secondly, this girl was a bully. She said and did some of the most horrendous things in just the first half of the book to the ~MC~, but Reid was still with her. ~MC~ is constantly told by both Reid and others that he cares and worries about her, but I cannot for a second believe that when he still allows her to say and do these awful things. He knows she's a bully, he knows she has said downright despicable things to ~MC~ regarding her dead brother, and he still lets it happen.
This book also had some buck-wild moments that just made me cackle. Sometimes the author just pulled out the snappiest comeback that had me rolling on the floor in shock and laughter.