I bought this collection of short stories in a Kaitaia bookshop, just because it was in the 'Top 10 NZ Fiction' line-up, and I was feeling like I should support local authors, regardless of whether I'd heard anything about them. I even bought at the same time her second collection of short stories, in the hope that I wasn't purchasing a dud.
Thankfully, this certainly was no dud. Karen Phillips writes beautifully. They're slice of life stories, and Phillips portrays the lives of her protagonists with sympathy and lyricism. I'll admit to my eyes watering during a few of the stories...
If there's one criticism to be levelled, it's that I wanted more detail in some of the stories. 'Accident' is about a mother coming to terms with her son going through the court process ('"I though I didn't love him any more,' she said. 'That was the hardest part'."), but what he actually did is brushed over, almost an irrelevancy. Perhaps that's merely my criminal lawyer background rearing its ugly head, when the story is purely about the mother's feelings. Likewise, in 'Night Cleaner', a cleaner reads things in a file which she shouldn't, and it's weighing on her mind... Yet we never know what she read, and with no specifics, it's hard to really get caught up in the narrator's moral dilemma.
Overall though, this was a very enjoyable collection of stories, capturing a variety of different lives and experiences. Phillips is no one-trick pony, writing the same story or characters over and over. Her second volume of stories is now down from my to-be-read bookshelf, very soon to be started.