This book has 3 short stories in the MacLeod/de Paiget series and the last story is a tenuous continuation of the Macleod clan.
THE GIFT OF CHRISTMAS PAST
I have to say that I found this really frustrating. I am not a fan of talking animals, so talking ghost animals was really annoying, especially the “mobster” bulldog. I struggled with the speed of the action, we weren’t given enough time to get to know Abigail Garret or Miles de Paiget (our heroine and hero). I think that they deserved better than this short story. It was so short that there was no: plot development; character development; or romance.
THREE WISE GHOSTS
Another frustrating short story. The ghosts of Ambrose MacLeod, Hugh McKinnon and Fulbert de Paiget were matching making with Megan MacLeod McKinnon and Gideon de Paiget (our heroine and hero). The 3 ghosts through means fair or foul needed to keep Megan and Gideon together long enough for them to fall in love. Sadly, as with The Gift Of Christmas Past, they were just annoying. Again the plot is rushed and Gideon turns from the workaholic, rude CEO of Artane Inc. to a nice romantic man far too quickly. Megan was the best character, and deserved more romance than this.
AND THE GROOM WORE TULLE 3 Star
This was my absolute favourite short story in the book. We first met Ian MacLeod (our hero and Jamie’s cousin) in A Dance Through Time, when he was left in a Scottish dungeon. He next appears in a wedding dress shop in New York 700 years in the future. His mission now is to go home to Scotland and find Jamie. Enter Jane Fergusson (our heroine) a long distant descendent of Ian’s enemy who had him in the dungeon.
The story is funny, with a good plot, great characters, and time for the romance between Jan and Ian to develop. The image of Ian, a big, strong, broad Scot warrior appearing in a Scarlett O’Hara style wedding dress to make his plea to St. Peter’s angels was truly a highlight of this book (and one of the series as well). Lynn Kurland didn’t go into much detail about Ian’s adjustment to 20thC America, the story was too short. However, we did get some sense of his confusion mixed with his wonder and curiosity.
The descriptions of Jane’s work in the bridal salon were also highly entertaining (and I suspect quite close to the truth). This short story was well written and enjoyable. It was great to catch up with Elizabeth, Jamie and their family as Ian finds his way home.
THE ICING ON THE CAKE
This was a fun, romantic story set in Alaska, between Sydney Kinkaid (our heroine) and Sam MacLeod (our hero). They are opposites: Sydney owns a wilderness tour company, and is a strong, competent woman who: is a mechanic; does her own home maintenance, including chopping the wood; runs her wilderness tours; but can’t cook. Sam is a strong man who: is a successful writer; can cook (and loves it) but he is not at all mechanical or handy. They are thrown together when Sam lodges with Sydney. Sparks fly and the fun starts
The plot is funny and well written with great secondary characters, especially The Clan and The Ladies Aid Society. However, despite a through away line about a Scottish ancestor there is no real clue as to where Sydney and Sam’s tale fits into the MacLeod/de Paiget series.
A major issue I have with these four stories (and the series as a whole) is trying to place them in sequence so that the characters and actions flow smoothly.