Based on the reviews of the Gideon Oliver books here on Goodreads, I picked one up at my local used bookstore. I am pleasantly surprised and relieved - the community here has, indeed, helped me find a book I want to read.
What sticks out in my mind most after having finished reading Make No Bones is that Aaron Elkins has Agatha Christie's talent for creating warm, pleasantly rounded characters, especially middle-aged and older ones. He also has the same knack for making his characters distinctive enough from each other that he can gather a large group and not confuse readers. If I were rating on character alone, I would give this book 5 stars.
The mystery is a solid 3.5-4 star mystery, complex enough to hold my attention and not seem childish, simple enough for me to follow and understand why people are interested in answering the questions they're interested in, and with a solid twist at the climax of the story. I can't give 5 stars because the resolution was rushed and under-explained.
Yes, it was possible, and no, I wasn't shocked in the sense of too many clues pointing a different way. I believed the solution that was set out. I simply didn't fully understand it, and it lacked a gravitas I'm accustomed to enjoying in a murder mystery conclusion. Agatha Christie and Rex Stout both have the knack of creating a solution in which the reader can see and feel in retrospect there was no other way for the characters' lives to go: the murder was inevitable, inescapable. Aaron Elkins, at least in this book, doesn't capture that feeling.
Besides a few stylistic hiccups, like putting too many qualifications/job titles/physical description details in one sentence, I enjoyed Elkins' writing.
Overall, a solid 4 stars, and I will definitely read another Gideon Oliver book.