If I were to write a book about Samuel Johnson, this is almost exactly the book I’d write. Not only does Henry Hitchings focus on the elements of Johnson that I most admire, his writing (and in particular the Rambler essays) but he also uses the lessons acquired from Johnson’s life and writings to apply to modern life.
As such, this was almost the perfect book for me and as such I began to lose interest. Not because the book was bad, it was great, nor because the book was badly written, it was smooth and engaging, but because the book didn’t challenge me at all. It was like a stand-up comic speaking to an audience who agree on every view, there may be smiles of joy, may be applause for putting unsaid things into words, but little laughter - it’s preaching to those on the same page. ‘Samuel Johnson: In Context’ provided surprises and unknown parts of history but ‘The World in Thirty-Eight Chapters or Dr Johnson’s Guide to Life’ did not.
I highly recommend this book interested in those getting into Johnson, it provides a nuanced and in-depth look at his life and work, always pulling it back to its usefulness to today. I also agree that a lot of what Johnson talked about could be more widely disseminated in modern culture; happiness is not the same as a healthy mind, there are great emptinesses in life which fill up, the world is a fascinating place and the human kind a great object for study.
In each chapter, even the more rambling ones, there are great points which are both interesting in the context of Samuel Johnson’s life and applicable to our own. Not one page of this book fails in providing something thought-provoking - if the reader hasn’t had Johnson himself provoke that thought before.
Chapter 24 begins with a description of what makes Johnson fascinating to his contemporary and) modern devotees;
“rational but full of feeling, stern but compassionate, orthodox in many things but unenamoured of conformism.” That chapter then goes into a discussion about why Johnson’s much mocked definition of ‘network’ is clearer and more precise then it first appears - it makes an argument that I’ve been making for years, although his language may seem complicated, he doesn’t waste words.
I imagine that this is a book I shall return to when I want a bit of Johnsonian ‘bark and steel’ but don’t have time to consult the original source. I really hope this book gains a wide readership because any sane person reading this will get at least a little glimpse of why Samuel Johnson means so much to me.
The only problem with this book is that it is an almost too accurate and concise depiction of what Johnson means to me, meaning that it ultimately has little to say to me that I don’t already feel. For anyone who isn’t into Johnson, I strongly recommend this as a place to start.