Difficult to read, mixed on the takeaway. I feel like I knew going in I would be disappointed--partly as someone who knows most of the bands mentioned in this collection of interviews (both mainstream and smaller acts), partly as someone who loves show stories, and partly as someone who just loves the broad spectrum of metal music. The ethos and medium of the book are a bit muddied and odd; there's little actual writing on Wiederhorn's part (400+ pages of just interviews is mind-bogglingly tedious, dry, not to mention how some of the interviewee's answers should have just been cut for how uninteresting they are). There are fun passages here and there, and I appreciated how Wiederhorn wasn't afraid of hearing from musicians across subgenres of metal that don't get the attention that most classic heavy metal does.
Reading this makes me feel a void inside where a strong piece of literature chronicling metal music could be. Maybe I'm not looking hard enough or I'm just afraid I'll read more tiresome stuff like this book. Academic or non-academic, metal literature seems to be the hardest to find, despite one element that Wiederhorn clearly illuminates with this book: there are interesting voices, influences, and stories behind the myriad metal musics, ones well worth investing journalistic investigation. But Wiederhorn ultimately seems too caught up in senseless glorification, focusing too much on a towering quantity of stories rather than fewer, higher quality ones.
Ugh. My first serious review in a long time. I really don't want to think about this book anymore. I don't even care about what kind of picture this book paints for metal music--I'm not an elitist--but the preservation of music culture as it pertains to history is something I think good music writing, criticism, journalism, archival, and narrative can do. In a way, Wiederhorn does succeed in that. But most of these stories are just... stories without any substance. Maybe that's where my biggest disappointment lies. I read this book and struggled to feel much of anything--no energy, no soul, no fire, no nothing.