(3.5 rounded up to 4)
I seem to be on a Holmes streak these days, probably because I'm waiting for spring to appear on this mountaintop. I have a couple of months until my landscape turns from white, to green and brown, so I'm reaching for the familiar.
Davies' Mrs. Hudson is a bit of an enigma, although one that perfectly suits the household of Holmes and Watson. Flotsam, her assistant both in housework and in detecting, is a jewel of a character. Holmes and Watson appear often enough to bind everything and provide context, but never detract from the protagonist. (I'm unsure that either Hudson or Flotsam could carry a story without the two male detectives.)
I found the storyline of this installment to be a little weaker than the previous book. This one seems to spread in tendrils, if that makes sense, instead of being delivered in a more linear fashion. To be honest, sometimes the rabbit trails bored me and didn't move the story along or enhance the characters, but the descriptions of locations and interesting detail kept me reading.
Recommended.