Secrets We Keep, broadly speaking, is the film Fatal Attraction in book form. A married man has a brief but intense sexual encounter with a single woman; she wants the affair to continue, he does not. What you read below takes place in the first third of the book. The remaining two-thirds, which I will not disclose, is where the story really gets going.
John is the Michael Douglas character. In this version, he is a published American author, whose unstable wife Vicky does not satisfy him sexually. While alone in London on business, John meets the seductive Lottie in a bar, and despite being drunk and tempted, he is determined not to cheat on his wife. He had never done so before and he was not about to begin now.
The next morning, however, he wakes up naked in Lottie’s bed with no memory of how he got there or what he did there. John is consumed with guilt and regret from Lottie’s lurid description of their one night together. He wants only to return to his wife, children and life in America, and since he had not told Lottie his real name, John figured she would never be able to find him again.
But of course, anyone who’s watched Fatal Attraction knows that a slighted woman can be ruthless. Lottie is not simply a literary fan of John, she is fanatically his fan, and had concocted an elaborate plot to meet, seduce, entrap and endanger him, not only while he was in London, but after he returns to what he thought was the safety and security of his home in New York.
But wait, there’s more. John’s unstable wife Vicky is also his business partner and co-author of a successful series of popular books they had written together. Married twice before to unfaithful husbands, Vicky had told John she would never tolerate him cheating on her. If she ever discovered even one indiscretion, he would lose her, their daughters and his livelihood.
John desperately needs to rid Lottie from his life, but he’s trapped because her pursuit of him is relentless, she’s in multiple ways squeezing him where it hurts the most, and he’s torn between loathing and lust. I had thought that the book’s resolution might borrow from another famous film, Crimes and Misdemeanors, where a man’s marriage and profession were also threatened by his infidelity.
Secrets We Keep is full of dread, dirty words and deeds, and surprises. How John balances and handles his two unstable women is derivative pulp fiction at its finest. A word of caution: Before beginning Chapter 35, don’t forget to fasten your seatbelts.