WARNING: POSSIBLE SPOILERS AHEAD
I absolutely enjoyed this book, with there not having been a moment where I was not absorbed, having been reading it all day yesterday, and it was certainly a day well spent.
This was a very enthralling and captivating read, having been initially drawn in by seeing that the story (or at least part of it) took place on the Titanic and would depict the infamous catastrophe of it back in 1912, with this always having been a major interest of mine. I was curious to see whether the story would manage to span over the four days, as I have actually read a book that managed to do that (though then again it switched between settings showing other characters), though we only get to see them aboard the Titanic for about 2 or 3 chapters. Most of the story ends up taking place in New York, but the incident of the Titanic is still pretty significant to the story and the following events that unfold.
The story opens with Flora and Connie, with Flora doing her duty as Connie's Lady's Maid, with Flora and Connie having a close friendship as well, despite the class differences-both girls are happy, their lives being pretty simple. Even though Flora comes from a poor, working-class family, she is still doing pretty well for herself as a Lady's Maid, especially as she had initially started off as a lower ranking house maid, and manages to support her family with her wages-she likes her job and is treated well, while also having a good relationship with her family, a steady boyfriend who she loves and a good friend in Connie. Connie too of course lives a very comfortable and cossetted life as the daughter of one of the richest men in London, has a good relationship with her father and is also doted upon by the staff, particularly Mrs Merry the housekeeper, who has always been like a mother to her.
Which is why the subsequent events that unfold are most distressing and upsetting, with these simple, comfortable lives suddenly being no longer so simple and comfortable at all! This all begins with the sudden death of Connie's father from a car accident, which Connie was also unfortunate enough to have witnessed, having been in there, but luckily she survives, with no more than a broken arm. Because Connie is not of age yet to own a house and live there as the owner, she is forced into going to live with her estranged aunt in New York, and how will she get there? Of course none other than by the Titanic itself.
This then complicates things for Flora as Connie expresses her desire for her to go with her, since she feels uncomfortable going by herself, to a new country to stay with a virtual stranger and by a big ship of course, especially given how sheltered she is! After things get complicated with her boyfriend, Jamie, with the interference of Mrs Merry the housekeeper who prevents the couple from communicating again and making amends after they had an argument about her leaving, since Jamie now accepts Flora going away, Flora is led on to thinking that Jamie has simply let her down and so this prompts her decision to go with Connie on the Titanic to live with her and her aunt in New York for three years, until she comes of age.
It is the infamous sinking of the Titanic itself that then turns everything upside down, with nothing being so simple at all, as poor Connie is not so lucky in surviving an accident this time and ends up being one of the many victims claimed by the Titanic. Flora of course survives, meaning she finds herself all alone in a new place where she doesn't know anyone, while also grieving the loss of her good friend/mistress, and it is from there that everything spirals out of control and gets very complicated indeed. I have to say I was most horrified and upset when Connie died as a result of the Titanic sinking! Poor Connie, the poor girl was already terrified enough as it was, and initially refused to jump into one of the lifeboats, and of course what happens-she ends up actually dying from falling off a lifeboat of all things! This was such a horrific way for her to go, after having initially been scared of jumping into a lifeboat, just as it seemed she would be saved to, AND according to google in real life nobody on the Titanic even died from falling off a lifeboat, so it really did seem most unusual-I don't think they even showed that happen to anyone in the film (though I will have to watch it again to see!). I was honestly so horrified and upset when Connie died and wish she had lived, as she seemed like such an interesting, likeable kind of character, yet we hardly get to see any of her-I mean we were just getting to know her and then suddenly she's killed off. There definitely seemed lost potential there, which I'm half using as a criticism and half not, because it really would have been interesting to see more of Connie and her character, with her having been shown to have hidden depths and good potential as a character for development when seeing her taking an interest in the suffragette movement, even while being sheltered, so it was such a disappointment to see her killed off so early on like this. However, I do also understand that it probably would have been quite hard to make a story out of what would happen if Connie had survived, like what would happen after both girls arrived in New York (though then again I can think of the odd possible options!)
So of course it is from there that things spiral out of control as Flora does something she is not proud of and takes on Connie's identity, feeling that she doesn't have a lot of choice as she does not know what to do after having been left alone due to Connie's death. This was one of the things I most admired about the story, seeing just how complex and three-dimensional the characters are, with Flora being a lovely person yet still makes crucial mistakes, doing something really bad that makes you feel horrified with her yet at the same time sympathetic. The same goes for Mrs Merry, the housekeeper, who we see gets in the way of Flora and Jamie's relationship by making sure they don't communicate with one another before Flora goes away with Connie, in case she changes her mind. While this might seem like a really horrible and antagonistic thing to do, she does not do it out of spite or actual antagonism, as she is just that worried about the idea of Connie going away on her own that she is determined Flora go with her, and clearly feels very guilty about it and is very conflicted. The characters like this are not all good or all bad, which I really like. The really sad and awful thing about Mrs Merry reluctantly yet determinedly intercepting Flora and Jamie's relationship is that it was all for nothing, as Connie ended up dying aboard the Titanic anyway even when Flora was with her, so it really would have made no difference in the end.
The story is very eventful, with Flora starting off living in London and working as a Lady's Maid at Connie's place, then she is living in New York with Connie's aunt, pretending to be Connie (although this doesn't last long), then she runs away and finds work in the Chinese Laundry House which is run by the slave driving Mrs Yung, and ends up making good friends in her roommates, the Irish Colleen and Jia Li, then they leave and go to start their own business together in a cafe, then a good bit later towards the end of the novel Flora finally returns home to London, and in the epilogue, is living in Nuneaton! So it is definitely packed and crammed with a lot, but that actually made it rather exciting. I must say though that although I found her newfound friendships with Colleen and Jia Li very heartwarming and beautiful, it just made me miss Connie all the more, as you're further reminded that she's no longer here and that Flora has started a new life without her and moved onto making new friends. Like many of Rosie Goodwin's other novels, this story does include yet another rape scene resulting in a pregnancy, HOWEVER, I was pleased to see that for a change it wasn't our main protagonist who was the victim this time (only pleased that this was different this time, NOT that it happened at all of course). Poor Jia Li, and honestly, I absolutely hated the vile scumbag Yung Huan with an absolute passion! He was by far the most evil, vile, sickest scumbag I have ever come across, being literally as evil, vile and scummy as you could possibly get, for not only does he rape poor Jia Li, but he also is a serial raper, having a history of raping several other girls who worked at the laundry, AND, on top of that, actually tries attacking Jia Li again and almost beats the poor girl who he thinks is Jia Li to death. I honestly felt so angry-I thought Gilbert in Our Dear Daisy was the biggest scumbag of them all but this guy seriously took the cake! It's a good think I tend to read in solitude, as I was cheering away when he got his long-deserved comeuppance and finally died, having been badly beaten then thrown in the river to drown-honestly couldn't have been a more fitting comeuppance!
I think one of the few things I would critique, and even then it would only be somewhat mildly, is the way Flora was still adamant about not returning home even though her mother wrote to her telling her she was not disgusted with her for her identity fraud and was longing for her to come home. Yes she was still scared of getting found by the police or the horrible uncle, Margaret or Toby, but I still don't see why she could have tried, like it might not have been that likely. I feel that things got a little bit repetitive and fillery, like she could have done with returning home a bit earlier, with the main portion of the story taking place in the new cafe business they have, and she ends up staying away from home for over a year-a year and three months at that! I think the fact it was focusing on all the different character's personal adventures and experiences that it meant Flora's own predicament had to be put on hold, with the solution to it being further delayed. It was good to see that with the other characters, but I still feel like it perhaps could have been condensed a little bit-it was virtually 3-4 stories in one, yet somehow wasn't even that long a book. Oh and I know we were probably supposed to know/suspect but I knew straight away that Colleen's new beau Will was Ben, Flora's brother!
I was a bit disappointed as well to be honest that not only is the cover and blurb rather misleading, with the story itself not actually centering around the Titanic, which is merely only a plot device and afterthought which lasts one or two chapters at most, but even more so that the main story that takes place after it doesn't even continue to focus on the Titanic events or refer to it. Instead it focuses on Flora's new adventures and friendships she makes in New York, which actually had nothing to do with the Titanic events and thus the events of the Titanic itself seemed pretty pointless being included in this story. I mean you would think that there would at least be more reference and direct impact from the Titanic throughout the story, but no, it's just Flora embarking upon a new adventure and striking up new friendships in New York, which literally could have taken place at any point in history without the Titanic having been included at all. It just had no relevance and that kind of annoyed me.
It was a beautiful ending too, though still sad when you remember Connie died, who I thought was going to play a bigger part, but we hardly get to know her and I felt that there was not quite enough reference to her after she died, although Flora does name her firstborn after her of course! Still I feel like there should have perhaps been more mention of Connie, like depicting Flora's grief over her more and regret to keep her safe (not that this was her fault really but it would have made sense for her to have a case of survivor's guilt, beyond the identity fraud of course). It would have been interesting I think to further explore Flora's feelings and reflection about the whole situation with Connie and her friendship with her, with her barely even getting mentioned once she makes friends with Colleen and Jia Li and is running the cafe with them. It would have been interesting as well to see Mrs Merry's reaction to Connie's death, having been so worried about the prospect of her going on her own, so she clearly must have been very distraught when she found out that it was her who died and not Flora. But it's like Connie was pretty much just cast aside once she'd died, like she'd fulfilled her role and that's it.
I also didn't feel too happy with Flora telling Jia Li when she is worried about her current unplanned pregnancy- as a result of rape no less-that all mother's love their child as soon as they lay their eyes on them. Not only is this not true but also not very tactful when dealing with a friend's very sensitive problem, just simply romanticising the whole thing as if she should be happy about having a child even though that child was indeed a result of rape and the child of a most grotesque, monstrous scumbag! Who was she to say this anyway not having gave birth herself at this stage?!
Overall though still a wonderful, enthralling and captivating read, enough to earn a good 5/5 stars.