Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Thing in the Cellar

Rate this book
• The Thing in the Cellar • (1932) • shortstory by David H. Keller, M.D.
• The Psychology of Fear • essay by David H. Keller, M.D.
• Interview with Dr. Keller • interview of David H. Keller, M.D. • interview by Mort Weisinger and Julius Schwartz

32 pages, paperback

First published January 1, 1940

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

David H. Keller

228 books16 followers
David Henry Keller was a Doctor and a Lieut. Col., U.S.A., ret.

David Henry Keller (1880–1966) was most often published as David H. Keller, MD, but also known by the pseudonyms Monk Smith, Matthew Smith, Amy Worth, Henry Cecil, Cecilia Henry, and Jacobus Hubelaire. He was a writer for pulp magazines in the mid-twentieth century who wrote science fiction, fantasy and horror.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
33 (25%)
4 stars
43 (32%)
3 stars
43 (32%)
2 stars
9 (6%)
1 star
4 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews
Profile Image for Rosh (on a medical break).
2,634 reviews5,811 followers
March 13, 2020
One of the first horror short stories I had read in my life! And one of the absolute best! It's a classic for a reason.

I had asked my horror-loving friend for scary short-fic recommendations and of the three names she had provided, this is the one that created the maximum impact. The haunting aftereffect still stays with me.

Little Tommy Tucker has always been unhappy in the kitchen, and his parents don’t know why. Right from when he was a baby, he did all he could to get out of the kitchen – cry or crawl or complain. When he learns to talk, he tries explaining his reasons to his parents, but they consider it foolish. After a few years, when his behaviour shows no signs of changing, his parents resort to calling the neighbourhood physician to rid Tommy of his irrational fear. What happens next? You have gotta read and find out!

Such tales are the perfect example of how horror can be written by using nothing but atmosphere. There’s no gore on the page, nor are there any paranormal entities jumping out of corners. And yet, the ending will leave you chilled. I have read this story thrice, and a small part of me still hopes for a different finale each time. The writing is spot on in generating a sense of fear without penning anything openly scary. In fact, it starts off very innocently, but soon it seems like only two people know something is drastically wrong – Tommy and the reader.

This isn’t a story for the faint-hearted. It is creepy. It is macabre. It is disturbing. It is brilliant. It is, by far, my favourite horror short. The ending doesn’t offer any closure.

5 spooky stars.

This story first appeared in Weird Tales Magazine in March 1932, and is in the public domain. As such, it can be read for free online. I read it from the below link:
https://weirdfictionreview.com/2012/0...


A fifteen-minute audio version is available on the below link, but I haven't tried it out. I prefer reading paranormal stories. :)
https://horrorbabble.bandcamp.com/alb...


———————————————
Connect with me through:
My Blog | The StoryGraph | Facebook | Twitter
Profile Image for Peter.
4,214 reviews889 followers
September 30, 2019
Tommy Tucker, a small boy, is very afraid of the cellar in his parents' house. What can they do to overcome his fears? Dr Hawthorne (like the name of the doctor) recommends closing him in for one hour in the kitchen with the door to the cellar wide open. Only a little candle lightens up the room. The doctor returns in the evening since he regrets his advice after a colleague of his thought this treatment might be too hard for the little boy. Now you will ask in what condition they met young Tommy Tucker? Nasty little tale with a fine twist at the end. A classic tale with some creepy moments!
Profile Image for Berengaria.
1,206 reviews237 followers
November 3, 2024
3 stars
Read for free here: https://weirdfictionreview.com/2012/0...

Listen for free here: https://horrorbabble.bandcamp.com/alb...

short review for busy readers:
This short story first appeared in the American magazine "Weird Tales" in 1932. Interesting is that apparently Keller was one of the first psychiatrists to write horror fiction, and in this story, it really shows.

in detail:
On the surface the story is typical in style of early 20th century horror or strange tales, with a not-terribly-exciting build up and a completely predictable ending. Ho hum and easily forgotten.

But if examined psychologically, we find an interesting examination of the childhood causes of PTSD and other mental-emotional difficulties that plague the souls of grown men for their entire lives.

Today, we'd called what unimaginative Mr Tucker does to his 6-year old son, Tommy, child abuse. He is bent on hardening the boy by exposing him -- alone and with only a feeble lamp -- to exactly the thing the child's been very visibly terrified of since birth. "I'll make a man of him," Mr Tucker says, clearly believing that a 6-year old should show the same stoic grit of an adult male when facing danger. ("Full throttle toxic masculinity" in today's parlance).

The cellar can be seen as the unconscious or the subconscious. The place where all the ur-fears reside. "There's something there," says Tommy, although he can't say what. He's never seen it, nor heard it, nor smelled it...but it's there. He knows it is, and it terrifies him (as it does all of us).

What happens to little Tommy at the end is what happens to our fragile psyches when we are forced into traumatic situations "for our own good" or to fulfil expectations.

Those who suffer from various fear and anxiety related difficulties are often told by non-specialists to "fight it" or "just face it and it will go away." It's not that simple and even confrontation therapy has to be monitored and done in small segments. You never throw anyone in at the deep end, and certainly not a child. But this is exactly what people tend to do even today, believing direct exposure to be a sure-fire cure, and not the exacerbating of trauma it actually is.

For that, the story is quite rich and a very good showcase piece on early therapy forms. But as fiction, it's fairly a wash-out, being rather plain, tame and not providing much in the way of a real creep factor.
Profile Image for PinkPanthress.
268 reviews83 followers
November 11, 2022
Geh nie durch diese Kellertür!
Tommy Tucker is afraid of the Cellar, from the Day he is born the boy hates the Door to it and the Cellar itself, but adores the old Door Lock! His parents being 'poor and simple folks' think nothing of it and are only annoyed. By the time he hits 6 and is in Primer Class, his parents are more than bothered and his father has given poor Tommy a few savage beatings because of his odd behaviour regarding the Cellar.

One Day all three of them go to visit Dr. Hawthorn. In a matter of minutes everything is explained by the parents… but upon talking to the Boy, the Doctor can't find the cause of it and things it just a queer, childish habit.

Later that Day the Doctor talks to an old friend, Mr. Johnson, about the case. Mr. Johnson, who is specialised in Psychiatry and has a keen interest in Children advices him to go talk to the Tuckers once more and maybe retract his initial opinion on the Case, but it is too late and we see if everything is fine with the Boy or not.

A quick read of 5 pages (≈ 15 minutes).
Goodness gracious! That one was a slap in the face…
»First and foremost I have to digress a tiny bit… you see, the house I grew up in and lived for the first 13'ish of my life was an old house. Haunted, yes… I said what I said!
It used to be on of those old german, 3 story family homes. The owner had it 'cut up' and given/rented each family a small apartment per floor. And we? We lived in the smallest flat on the 3'rd floor, right under the roof.
Each floor had a ceiling height of about 3,5 metres, which suited me just fine. Since that gave me about 10+ metres space between my little, scared bum and the shared cellar.
The house was 'voll unterkellert', meaning fully cellared with the same measurements as the house itself. (Meaning it was a big one with 4 'Rooms')

I HATED going down that basement and never went down there by myself alone. Even as I grew older. My mother gave me hell for it, most of all by the time I grew out of the single digit age. She though I was just too lazy for the 80+ steps down so we had fights about it.
What I didn't tell anyone was that I was even afraid when she went down WITH me to the laundry room to hang the clothes to dry.

Behind the basement stairs was a tiny part that had no real wall and I can't describe why but I waited every time for a hand to creep out from behind that hidden spot. Every DAMN time. Sometimes you could hear weird noises form that corner, too.
Years later I told my brothers about it while we were eating with our parents, living in a totally different flat.
And to my surprise (not really) they said they thought and had heard the same but being boys they never said a thing because it sounded ridiculous.
So, in a not so short way, I want to say, that this short story had me shiver!«
I knew from the first sentence of this short story, if or if not something was in that Cellar. The Author knew exactly what he was doing!
AND I thought it was fun, that the Author's family name Keller is the german word for Cellar/Basement! :D Coincidence!?

If you would like to read or listen to this short story, here are the Links.
For your ears -> »The Thing in the Cellar« @ Youtube
For your eyes -> »The Thing in the Cellar« @ Archive.org

Geh nicht durch diese Kellertür
Profile Image for Lizz.
483 reviews137 followers
May 29, 2025
I don’t write reviews.

Look, if your dog, cat or kid is freaked out by a place, just trust them and avoid like the plague. And don’t ask “science’s” opinion.
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
719 reviews57 followers
June 15, 2020
Here’s an oldie but a goodie—creepy, atmospheric, and still plenty disturbing. I enjoyed this short narrative immensely, and I recommend it to any horror fan looking for a quick tale. Although the short fiction form works well here, and the story is exceptionally well-crafted, there is a part of me that would have wanted this story to last a little longer. I felt the characters’ anguish, and I found I wasn’t ready to leave that world at the end of the brief journey. All in all, a gripping, horrifying tale.

A quick shout-out to my Goodreads friend Peter, whose review of this story made me drop everything and read it. I would never have heard of this book or this author if not for you.
Profile Image for Tim Pendry.
1,239 reviews519 followers
July 14, 2018

David Keller is an interesting writer, the first psychiatrist to write in the fantasy and horror field and very much a mid-twentieth century Lovecraftian. Neglected perhaps because of his ferociously right-wing and bigoted views, this story is, regardless of that, exceptional.

Keller is interested in fear (there was an essay on fear published with this tale which I have not read). This horror set within an American lower middle class family is fundamentally about what his profession explains away as just childhood fantasy being, in fact, grounded in reality.

The idea is simple, almost trite, but he carries it off by seeing the drama through the eyes of a vulnerable child with whom we identify ... through to its brutal conclusion. This is true, visceral horror and leaves one with a strong feeling of sadness for a fictional boy.

Deep down, what I think it does is appeal to a long-lost memory of our own - not of monsters but of not being listened to and respected as an independent little person in a world of adults with power. If the lad had been trusted and listened to, there would have been a different ending.
1 review
February 26, 2014
This is the short story that got me hooked on horror fiction! It was in a book of collected "scary stories" for kids, that I found at our local library back in the mid-1960s. Thanks to the internet, I was able to find and re-read this childhood favorite, and it's STILL scary (and I'm 54 now!)
Profile Image for Mayda.
4,075 reviews68 followers
June 8, 2020
A little boy’s parents are given some bad advice by a doctor. The boy is drastically fearful of their basement, and when the parents seek help, their doctor tells them to keep the boy in the kitchen, which has access to the basement, for an hour. And, oh yes, nail the basement door open. This turns out to be very bad advice, indeed. Well constructed with a sense of growing horror as the story progresses, this tale is scary even if you anticipate the ending.
Author 1 book
May 24, 2022
I remember this story for two reasons. First, it's creepy and chilling, especially for young readers. Great literature? Maybe not, but it stays with you.

Second, it won first prize in our 8th grade Language Arts short story competition in Ohio back in the mid 1960s. Yeah, I know it was written in 1932, but a boy in my class trimmed some verbiage, changed the name of the child to Steve Skinner from Tommy Tucker, and submitted it as his own work. We were bowled over. The rest of our stories, even the ones in 2nd and 3rd place, paled in comparison. Because he had removed much of the story, there wasn't as much build up and the ending was, ironically, more shocking for being unexpected.

Thinking back, I now understand why the "author" looked a little uncomfortable when his story was voted #1. Years later I stumbled across it somewhere by accident. I wonder what he thought then, and if he ever thinks about it now. It was my first experience with plagiarism, although we didn't know that at the time. I never tried to out him and won't now. We all do things we regret when we're young and foolish.
3,714 reviews46 followers
January 1, 2025
4.25⭐


The story is about a young boy, Tommy Tucker who suffers from an irrational fear that revolves around a mysterious and unsettling presence in the cellar of his parents' old house. For some reason, he has the sneaky suspicion that there is some sort of monster lurking in the cellar. He exhibits an inexplicable fear of the kitchen and the cellar door from a very young age. His parents, puzzled by his behavior, try to understand the cause but are unable to pinpoint it. The cellar itself is described as a large, dark, and foreboding space, filled with junk and hidden from view by a barricade of firewood and old items. The door to the cellar is particularly strange, being thick, sturdy, and reminiscent of a castle gate. As Tommy is soon to start school the parents decide to see a doctor who recommends to the parents that the best solution to the problem is to make their son face his irrational fears. As the story unfolds, it becomes clear that the cellar holds a sinister secret, and Tommy's fear is not unfounded.
Profile Image for Liz.
1,836 reviews13 followers
March 13, 2021
A psychological horror story that is actually written by a psychiatrist. There are no big surprises in this story, and it is actually obvious where it is heading. But, it is told in such a straight forward rather chilling way. This story is disturbing because we know where it is heading and that there is no way to stop it. The themes that come up are predictable and equally terrible. There is the working class family who follows the doctor's incompetent recommendations much to their misfortune. Then there is the father who is concerned that his little boy isn't manly enough due to his phobia. This is a simple story with a strong impact.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Darla.
5,275 reviews1,404 followers
October 31, 2024
Poor little Tommy Tucker.

The genius of this story is the lack of evidence. It is all left to our imagination. Each one of us can vividly imagine the horror of that little boy locked in the kitchen with the dreaded cellar door wide open.

Thank you to my GR friends (especially Tina and Rosh) who gave this story high marks. I made sure I read it when the sun was still up. Even though there is no basement door off my kitchen, that room will give me the creeps for awhile. 😨

Below is a link for listening to the Horror Babble production on Youtube:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mvHgR...
1 review
January 2, 2022
I re-read the story as an adult; big deal. Hack writing and a superficial idea that ran out of steam like a whodunit with the crime solved in the first page. (He's no Poe...) Even Stephen King, who's usually in need of an editor, is far above this. However, they had us read "The Thing In The Cellar" in elementary school and as a professional educator and parent, my question today is: what the hell were they thinking? "The world's a nasty place, so traumatize them young?"
Profile Image for Tina .
887 reviews842 followers
October 31, 2024
I'm not much of a horror reader but this short story is perfect for the night before Halloween 🎃

A little boy named Tommy Tucker has always been afraid of the basement. His parents seek help with a Doctor and are given some ill-fated advice.

This story was originally published in 1932 in Weird Tales Magazine.

You can listen to the audio for free at the following link.

https://horrorbabble.bandcamp.com/alb...
6,726 reviews5 followers
March 14, 2022
Entertaining horror listening
This was in Box set Classic tales of Horror - 500+
Tommy would not stay in the kitchen, he was afraid. They take him to a Dr. who recommends that they lock him in the kitchen with the cellar door open. Tommy dies. What killed him? Enjoy reading 2022
Profile Image for Donald.
1,828 reviews16 followers
December 22, 2022
From his youngest days as a baby , Tommy fears the cellar in his home. But why? What is down there?
When Tommy turns 6, a doctor decides to put the boy to the test. And…

A short, scary story! Quick to read, and just as quick to give you the chills! Definitely enough to stay out of any cellars!
Profile Image for Welther.
97 reviews2 followers
March 26, 2019
Decent little horror story, with an expected ending.
Profile Image for Yoana.
474 reviews15 followers
December 28, 2020
I read this in maybe the 8th or 9th grade and it left me *terrified*. I suddenly felt chills sitting in our living room in broad daylight. I actually get scared retelling it.
Profile Image for Flora.
293 reviews
July 16, 2023
Very creepy, eerie little tale that would have scared the hell out of me as a kid.
Profile Image for Sascha Nolte.
274 reviews1 follower
March 10, 2024
Ebenso simple, wie eindrucksvolle Horrorschnurre. Höchstnote!
Profile Image for Chantel.
527 reviews375 followers
September 9, 2022
When reviewing Horror I keep in mind that the genre is brimmed with occurrences, ghouls, goblins, ghosts, & shadows that will be subjectively interpreted. Who is to say that what I find frightening is the pinnacle of horror? Who is to say that a book recommendation cannot be taken as a window into the mind & experiences of the reader? In this case, I would say that on both such questions, the answer would be no one, no one at all.

Keller has written a story that seems to transcend the ages & plays on a palpable fear for many young people. This fear of the basement; the unknown cavity laying dormant in the nucleus of a home, unvisited, unseen & riddled with ghastly monsters. At some point in time, many of us grow up & realize that the silent darkness that is the cellar, the attic, the basement, a closet, or even any room, in particular, is a rather peaceful aspect of a home—something we can appreciate when surrounded by the high energy & fast pace of life.

I was once a child who was convinced that the basement of my childhood home housed demons of the most stealth kind—those who wander around you but whom you cannot see. I cannot say that I was particularly afraid of them, they were simply an aspect of life I was certain existed & therefore what could I, in my little entity, do about that? In this story, Keller presents a child who does do something against the ‘thing’ that inhabits the cellar of his family’s home.

This child, Tommy, screams & cries, he wines & rolls out of the room that leads to the cellar. At every opportunity, he finds a way out of the kitchen so that he is not confronted by the vicious evil that inhabits the cellar. His parents remain convinced that he’s a ninny & has no substance to his being acting as scared as he does by a simple room in the house—a room pray tell that is used for who knows what, during the hours that Mrs. Tucker does who can tell?

The substance of this story & the family at play is essentially inconsequential. The Tuckers roam around & do things the reader might assume they do. Keller encourages the reader to leap & bound through assumptions so that the bones of the story fit into skeletal formation.

When Tommy is old enough—a child rather than an infant—a doctor tells his parents that he should be left to face his fears, alone. Tommy’s parents bolt the kitchen door, ram the cellar open & place Tommy in a chair like an offering to an elderly spirit, marbled in the walls. After some time & a transition later, the doctor returns to the family asking them what has become of Tommy. Due to a colleague's advice, he realized that perhaps scaring the bejesus out of a child in forced disconnect was not the ideal way to work through their fear.

Unfortunately, there was indeed something or someone in the cellar. Tommy is dead on the floor when the adults barge into the kitchen. Then the story ends. I would like to say a special thanks to my personal friend & book-fiend confidant, « Scott » who gave me a laugh when this story left me flustered in annoyance. Certainly, this premise holds true for many people & if you can imagine yourself now or in the past, feeling as Tommy felt, you might even chance a sentiment of fear.

As for myself, I have been too acclimated to life, literature, & everything in between to find this anything but a substantial blow to the eagerness I fostered when reading the synopsis. This brings me to the introductory portion of my review—fear is subjective. The experience is different for everyone & is lived in varied ways throughout life. I have no one to whom I would recommend this story but I think it would play out well as a tale of horror during slumber parties or as an episode on my beloved “Freaky Stories” (1997).

If you would like to read this story too I direct you to :
Weird Fiction Review who have the full story & a dedicated introduction listed on their website & Horror Babble who have a wonderful audiobook format of Keller’s tale on their website available to all.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Maureen .
1,800 reviews7,523 followers
September 4, 2022
*3.5 stars*

Little Tommy Tucker has had a morbid fear of the cellar that leads off from the kitchen in his home, ever since he was a baby. If the cellar door is left open he screams uncontrollably. If it’s shut, locked and bolted, he can at least eat his meals in peace.
Tommy’s father can’t understand why he behaves in such a manner. Other than this problem, Tommy is a perfect, obedient, intelligent little boy. His father can’t understand it and has no patience with it. Eventually, when Tommy is old enough for school, his father decides to take him to see a physician. The doctor suggests a solution to Tommy’s problem but I won’t say any more than that. Here’s the free link if you want to read it yourself https://weirdfictionreview.com/2012/0...
3 reviews
January 4, 2015
I gave this short book 5 stars, because I first read it as a child and it made a big impression on me as well as scaring me to bits, I am now 57 but the story has stayed with me and probably led to foray into other horror type books. I reread it the other day for the second time in my life and didn't find it scary at all, but as a child and scared of the dark it fed those horrors of a thing waiting to get me.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 32 reviews