Eleven-year-old "Blue" Warren is cursed with three bothersome brothers, a too-busy father, a recently deceased mother, and she's annoyed. With humor, hijinks, and heart, this debut novel is a touching tale of grief and the healing power of family.
Eleven-year-old Beulah "Blue" Warren spends every waking moment surrounded by boys: her three brothers, her father, her best friend, even the family dog, but that's never stopped her from being her usual rambunctious self. Grappling with the loss of her mother, Blue is determined to do what she wants without fear of consequences. When she is sent to the principal's office, she gets out of it like a pro. When the witchy neighbor next door trashes her yard, Blue doesn't just get even, she gets ahead. No clean underwear because she hasn't done the laundry? No worries. That's what her little brother's Superman underwear is for, isn't it? But everything changes on the day she explores the attic and finds her mother's death certificate. Blue will need to muster all the strength she has to deal with the truth, find forgiveness, trust in her father, and grieve for her mother once and for all.
Blue is surrounded by boys. She lives with her 3 brothers and her Dad. Her best friend is a boy and even her dog is a boy!! Her mother died when she was young and Blue is starting to forget her. So she is trying to remember her and be like her but as hard as she tries she is nothing like her mom. Can Blue find her was in the sea of boys?
I really liked this book. I loved Blue and how she handles the world around her. From bothering her neighbor to trying to win the contest to meet her favorite actress, you will fall in love with Blue. You also follow her family and the grief of losing their mother. I think it is an important read for middle graders but also light hearted. I really loved this story and I highly recommend it!!
This book was difficult to review because there were some parts that the author wrote so well, but somehow missed its mark in the pacing.
Here’s what I liked about the story. The author wrote the characters very well. Even though they are a bit clichéd, you immediately start to like all of them (well, except Jackson). Blue is stubborn and annoyed because she is the only girl in the family. Hence, you immediately root for her so that people take her seriously. Arnie is adorable and mischievous, and Seth is a good big brother towards them. Jackson is annoying for the most part but has his moments.
The author describes some scenes very nicely. For example, I really liked Blue’s reaction when she meets her idol, London Malloy. I also loved how Blue reacts when she finds out what really happened to their mother. Also, I enjoyed the bond that Blue and Jane form from their conversations.
However, the main problem I had with this story is that there are a lot of random things that happen without any focus to a bigger story-line. Even though there is a larger theme to the story where Blue tries to remember her mother, quite a few chapters had no connection to the theme. For example, Blue babysits the girl who poops at inappropriate times. While this is hilarious (in a gross way), it did not connected to the larger theme.
Moreover, I really did not think that the father made a good role model for the children. Everyone laughs at Blue for wearing Jackson’s underwear. However, this happens only because their father decides to stop doing their laundry (and doesn’t even give them a heads-up beforehand). In another scene, Blue starts bleeding profusely for what Seth did, and rather than checking on her condition, the father decides to take them on a road trip instead. I think I disliked the father figure most of all.
Overall, “The Messy Life of Blue” had potential but became a bit messy in its execution.
I read this as an ARC provided by the publisher for an honest review.
Alright, I have a lot to say about this book so I am going to make a list. Overall problems were inconsistencies, stereotypes, not flushed out characters, not flushed out plots, and the overall sense that this was more like a second draft rather than a basically complete book. There was a problem with their ages and when their mother died. She died when Arnie was born (he’s four) and it said that Jackson was three (however he turns 10 in the book).
1.) Inconsistencies. In the beginning of the book you have Blue staunchly telling her brothers to stop calling her a girl. She does a lot of gender rejection. Then, you also have her proclaiming to be proud of being a girl. She also constantly calls her brothers dorky but also numerous times says Seth is cool.
2.) Stereotypes. There are also a lot of gender stereotypes. Brothers don’t like “girly” things like nail polish. Girly stuff makes girls pretty. She describes her own hands as tiny and Seth’s as big, it was very awkward (pg 27). She also says she has “delicate, princesslike skin” (pg 61).
3.) Character Confusion. None of the characters are flushed out, especially Blue. I think a lot of the inconsistencies with Blue, and a lot of the stereotypes, comes down to the author not having this character pinned down. She acts like ten different characters throughout this book. She seems borderline abusive in both actions and thoughts. There is a lot of physical violence between her and her brothers, her and her best friend (she literally pushes him into a bush), and her and her classmates (she literally hit another kid in the head with a book). She clearly has anger issues. None of it came across as “kids will be kids” or as though Blue is a strong female. No, she clearly has anger issues that need to be dealt with immediately.
4.) Barely a Plot. I’m not sure what I was suppose to focus on here. Blue goes through a lot, there are a lot of scenes where things happen, and then everything is pushed aside for the next thing. Nothing is flushed out. Even the two “main plot points” are barely mentioned and there’s no real substance to them. Blue is forgetting her mom and wants to do things to be more like her. I feel like the author just threw this plot in randomly throughout the book so we wouldn’t forget she has a deceased mother. Also the whole wanting to meet her favorite actress. It’s brought up a few times just so we won’t forget. Then she meets her and the actress is a jerk.
I feel like the potential is there. For the most part it is well-written and entertaining. It just seems like the author had a list of things she wanted to add into a book and she checked them off as she added them in, even though none of it is flushed out. IE new girl, crush, contest, dead mother, best friend, mean next door neighbor, annoying brothers, new shoes. Honestly, all the ideas in this book could fill like a four-book series. I would enjoy that. I would like to see Blue deal with her current best friend while making a new one. I would like to see how she’s dealing with the death of her mother at the same time it seems like her dad is ready to date.
I think the editor and author need to spend more time figuring out what they want to say with this book. If it’s purely for entertainment that’s great! I love to read just to be entertained, but you’re giving me little tastes of too many things. I want just a couple and I want more than a little taste.
Do I think kids will enjoy this, maybe, but I think they will have the same “left wanting” feeling I had when I finished this book. I wanted more. #ARC
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Hilarious, messy family story about a young girl surrounded by brothers who worries she can’t remember her dead mother. . . . This debut book has a few small flaws (pacing a bit off and a couple of dropped storylines), but certain parts just sparkle. I giggled through the whole book (a chorus solo performed with her tights tucked into her underwear! So many sibling shenanigans including scaring a little brother with clown costumes!) until the end when I was choking back sobs. Fabulous! . . . #middleschoollibrarian #middleschoollibrary #library #librarian #futurereadylibs #iteachlibrary #bookstagrammer #bookstagram #librariesofinstagram #librariansofinstagram #librariesfollowlibraries #librarylife #librarianlife #schoollibrarian #middlegrade #middlegradebooks #iteach #librarylove #booksbooksbooks #amreading #bibliophile #schoollibrariansrock #bookreview #bookrecommendation #igreads #malibrary #msla #mediaspecialist
I really loved this book! At first glance you might not think you have much in common with Blue, but you would be so very wrong, anyone can connect with her stories. I was immediately rooting for Blue with her family since she is the only girl in a house of boys and all their tricks. This book made me laugh at life and friendship, cry at old school memories and rejoice with Blue as I seemly become her new best friend and confidant. It’s overall packed with really funny moments that keep you giggling; with a bit of family dynamics and schoolyard antics, but the loss of her mother and Blue processing so many new and adult emotions made it incredibly deep and touching too. Even though we haven’t shared many of the same life experiences, the human experiences in the book are profound. The ending was totally unexpected for me but written perfectly. This book left me feeling good and somehow proud of Blue; like a mom, dad, friend or brother would be of her…Great book, highly recommended!
I don't usually leave reviews, but I wanted to take a moment to share. Last week I heard my older daughter laughing in the other room when she was supposed to be reading/studying. (We are homeschooling during covid - 8 and 12 year old girls) I marched in there expecting to find her goofing off, but instead I found her curled up in a chair reading this book. I was curious so I read it that night after she went to bed, and I was blown away by such a fun, yet heartfelt book! It's about a sweet girl who is surrounded by mostly males (her dad, brothers, etc) and who is trying to remember her deceased mother's memory. Based on the summary, I thought it would be more serious, but it's just one fun adventure after another! My youngest is reading it now and I'm curious to see what she thinks. My only complaint is that Shawna Railey hasn't written any other books that I can find.
I read this book to my 4th grade class and we enjoyed it so much! There were moments that we would laugh as a whole, as well as a few times I got choked up just trying to read it aloud. I would highly recommend for any child, not just those who have experienced loss.
My 10 year old daughter read this and wanted me so read it too so I obliged. It was cute and entertaining with some positive messages and I’m happy to share any books with my kids that they enjoy reading!
I can not imagine being the only girl in a house full of boys. Blue seems to handle it pretty well for the most part and her dad seems to take everything in with a great sense of humor. I loved Blue's progression and thought the book was really fun overall.