2.5 rounded down
I...have very mixed feelings on this book, which I've realized is super common for me and this author. Something about the stories this author writes doesn't 100% jive with me, but there are enough good things overlapping that I keep coming back for more in hopes that this time will be perfect...
Anyway, to start with the good. I really liked both of the MCs quite a lot, both individually and together, and their chemistry was seriously off the charts. The sex here was insanely hot, and their dynamic really, really worked for me. There are quite a few sex scenes throughout the book, but it never felt excessive or boring to me. I liked the POC rep with Puerto Riccan Miguel and I thought Aldrich's touch aversion was interesting. Legitimately, the sex was so hot I almost rounded this up, but in the end, there were too many issues for me to do so.
For the things that didn't so much work for me...
-As mentioned above, I really liked the POC rep, but I felt like the author was trying too hard. The amount of Spanglish used here often felt a little forced and over-abundant. I've spent a lot of time around latinxs and though this wasn't bad by any means, and I actually *super* appreciate that the author worked to ensure the representation was meaningful and not just in name, there were a number of times where it felt a bit clunky, and I wondered if they had a sensitivity reader to maybe polish that. Suuuper small thing, though!
-I found the whole Luna/Dev background thing to be a little weird/random? Luna being a Domme and super kinky felt like it suddenly came out of left field and then was a little overkill and I wasn't sure what purpose it was serving. Relatedly, and this may just be personal preference, but meddling friends and family is a huge squick for me, and I thought a lot of Luna's actions here were crossing a line. There is a scene where she starts yelling at Aldrich for his treatment of Miguel, and he tells her it's none of her business, and she keeps yelling saying that it is and... No. It's not. Yeah, he was shitty, but it really doesn't involve you and I found her violation of his personal space to be really uncomfortable.
-Going along with that, when the relationship is transitioning to something ~more~ I was really put-off by Miguel's blithe dismissal of the real-world consequences of hooking up with his professor. Yes, Aldrich had other fears, but he also was absolutely right to be concerned about LOSING HIS FUCKING JOB and the fact that Miguel kept dismissing that as unimportant was really immature and short-sighted, and frankly showed more lack of respect for Aldrich's boundaries
-The non-consensual voyeurism was borderline for me. I can kind of handwave because fiction, and Miguel is so obvi into it, but it got into uncomfortable territory when Aldrich/others were acting like Dev (who'd reported Aldrich to his Dean for spying on a previous roommate without their consent) was in the wrong when... No, he wasn't, that's not okay behavior in the real world. And then the epilogue really put me off with Miguel and Alrich spying on the new neighbors, but it's "okay" because the dude is homophobic and his girlfriend is "a bitch". No. Like, if you want to write hot kinky voyeurism, I'm clearly all for it. But when you start trying to justify it as totally okay in the narrative, that's when I have issues.
-Right after they admit their feelings and basically become a couple, Aldrich has a thought that is basically "I'm not ready to bottom for Miguel. I may never be ready. I'm worried that's a dealbreaker." though he doesn't say this out loud. Literally DAYS later, and in like the next chapter, he's bottoming and, of course, loving it, because love makes your physical reactions to being penetrated suddenly change! I can totally appreciate the emotional impact the author was going for, to physically show the emotional change in their relationship, but it made ZERO sense how quickly it moved, and the result was that all that emotional impact was totally lost, because I was just there in confusion like, oh, magic dick, of course. I mean, the *author* is the one that wrote Aldrich struggling with the concept of bottoming, so for them to completely do a 180 in a chapter left me with a bit of whiplash.
-To go with that, in a much smaller critique, I really enjoyed the sort of light D/s vibe they had going, and I found it pretty unsatisfying that that entire dynamic basically evaporated the second they officially became a couple. There were still a few sex scenes, but they were all more vanilla and smushy, and I didn't love this implication that kink isn't for "real" relationships.
-The entire climactic moment with the asshole professor was so fucking random and unnecessary and weird. It 100% felt like the author got 3/4 of the way through the book, realized she'd written her way out of any kind of tension to provide the book with a climax, and then came up with this random-ass sexual assault plot to engineer some. It felt super out of place, inorganic, and just uncomfortable.
-The suddenly married epilogue, while very common in the genre, felt really out of place in this book (also common in this genre) and the entire epilogue was random and not satisfying, IMO.
LOL, okay, I clearly had a lot to say. Honestly, this all makes it sound like I dislike the book more than I did. I actually generally enjoyed myself, but there were enough constant issues that my enjoyment was continuously underlined by this nagging frustration and disappointment...