MANY WRONG TURNS LEAD TO CATHARSIS FOR AUTHOR FLEMING
On July 25, 1980, Mary Fleming was killed. It took her brother, Dennis Fleming, many wrong turns in life and a quarter of a century to tell the story of her brutal murder in his memoir, “She Had No Enemies.”
The facts are, as often, deceptively simple. On a warm summer day, Mary, the youngest of the Fleming children, affectionately nicknamed “Mickey,” is followed home from a walk to the corner market where she had purchased lunch items. The man who followed her was Anthony J. LaRette, a serial killer, who slashed her throat and stabbed her in the heart while the lettuce for her luncheon salad sat on the kitchen counter.
When I look at Mickey’s picture, a beautiful girl at age 18 with the full promise of life ahead of her, I can imagine how difficult it must have been for the author to tell a story so close to the bone. But when you read his book you’ll know that he had to find a way to talk about this most personal tragedy, or let it destroy him. And destroy him it almost did by way of drugs, alcohol, depression, attempted suicide, and failed relationships.
“She Had No Enemies” is more than a crime story of how LaRette was caught, tried, and eventually executed. The blue-collar Flemings, like Frank McCourt‘s family in “Angela’s Ashes,“ have tragedy written all over them right from the get-go. Fleming’s mother and brother were abandoned by their parents, raised by a grandma “who’d smack your hands with her sausage fingers.” No wonder the mom ran as fast as she could from “Big Grandma” right into the arms of an alcoholic who beat her and the children, which the two somehow managed to produce between the fighting and the beatings. She had eight of them before she found the strength to leave him. “Whenever I think back on my childhood, I recall those ugly images,” Fleming writes.
The father was a bully and a conman who couldn‘t hold down a job. Fleming nails him, reads him like a book. He does it so well you must wonder if he sees something of himself in the old man. But unlike the dad, when Fleming blunders he catches himself, like the time with Christopher McQuarrie at a writer‘s conference, or when he says he‘s rarely passed an opportunity to make a fool of himself. You have to ask why did he move back home and why is he disappointed that the family hasn’t changed? Did he believe time and distance would transform them into a model family? But isn't that what most of us do? Time and distance puts a rosy sheen on our childhood. Your heart will break when he writes, “seeing Mickey again was my homecoming.”
Fleming says, “Although most of us were broken in some way growing up in the chaos of our family, Mickey emerged intact.” When he thinks of Mickey’s death one hopes that this is a comfort to him, just like Mickey’s innocent drawings he used to tuck into his footlocker as a Marine. In the end, for Dennis Fleming to emerge intact he needed to write “She had to Enemies.“