This book was sent to me by the author in exchange for an honest review. All opinions remain my own.
The author reached out to me to try out the sequel after not enjoying the first book. This was very admirable and I agree with some other reviewers that Jordan clearly took on board what reviewers were saying to make improvements (e.g. the overly complex language that felt unnatural for a bunch of teens had been shortened at least, if not entirely simplified). Yet it didn't dispel the barbaric and unnecessary descriptions used, such as "Jackhammeeing the chair's hind leg, he shredded her labia".
I was warned the prison setting was going to unearth some hard scenes, but I was disgusted by the rascist language and the disgusting descriptions of the 15 year old main character's genitals and this was only 23 pages in. If it was just characters speaking like this then okay, but the actual narration could be really unnecessarily disgusting, for example "Julian shadowed her, his nose all but penetrating her harlequin thong-adorned vagina." .... What on earth?
This was a sentence to describe a situation and it did not need to be described like this. Unfortunately the line "you went from speaking like an unrealistic, poorly written protagonist to a believable 15 year old" still did not ring true for me and I'm very sorry to say that.
When looking at actual plot/story, despite looking over my previous review of the first book to refresh my mind, I struggled to get into the plot as I was lost. As the story originally was quite confusing in book one, I think it would have been good to have a prologue of sorts just recapping the first book as it did take me a while to remember characters and what went down.
The Prison plot was over rather quickly, but I'm kind of glad because it was pretty dark and brutal during those scenes. I was intrigued when mention of Atlantis came up as I'm fascinated by that lost civilisation myth and legend, however it wasn't what I expected and left a lot to be desired. I do admire the unique take on it though, but it just wasn't a take I could get on board with.
I don't know how or why a sex scene came about but although it was a fade to black sort of scenario, I just found the whole thing vulgar and out of place in the sense that I didn't see how it sprouted out of nowhere. This is when I noticed my face had been twisted in a mixture of disgust and confusion for a while, because it ached.
Bestiality scenes made me very uncomfortable. Just another point I wanted to note.
Once again the "inspiration" of Ransom Riggs' series is a bit too obvious.... "Library Of Solstice" (... "Library Of souls") ... "brave new world"... to name but a few. It definitely became more of its own thing in this sequel, but some things or concepts still felt a bit too close to imitation, which is odd to say because Jordan's books really is it's own thing and lore, which could be incredibly fascinating if approached in a more, perhaps, tasteful way. I don't mean tasteful as in the writing isn't intricate (yet overly so), but it just doesn't flow, it's unnecessarily obscene and there's too many confusing sentences, scenes, etc spliced together for me to really ever make any sense of what is going on.
One thing I really did enjoy was the discussions of religion and science through the conversations between Julien and Salvador. It didn't come across preachy at all but very passionate and engaging.
Honestly, I think Jordan should dip his toes into adult fiction, following adult characters because I just found the use of language in general inappropriate and uncomfortable for this set of characters and the writing still too complex and confusing, for what I believe to be his target audience (YA).
The author clearly cares about his storytelling and the craft, but I think perhaps a suggestion on my behalf would be to explore other avenues within the world of literature, to find a genre that really makes his work shine, once he wraps up this series.
Pick it up, give it a go and enjoy! >(^_^)<
Gén