Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Mad Cook of Pymatuning

Rate this book
While working as a camp counselor, teenager Jerry Muller finds himself attracted to an unavailable girl, learns a shocking truth about his friend's sexuality, and becomes involved in the dangerous games of a psychopathic peer. Reprint.

320 pages, Mass Market Paperback

First published February 6, 2005

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Christopher Lehmann-Haupt

8 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (8%)
4 stars
13 (15%)
3 stars
29 (35%)
2 stars
26 (31%)
1 star
7 (8%)
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
Profile Image for Jon Recluse.
381 reviews318 followers
January 3, 2015
A coming of age thriller that tries very hard, yet fails to deliver.

Disappointing.
Profile Image for Bob O'G.
359 reviews
November 20, 2024
TMCOP was a good fast read. It's branded as a horror novel, but the horror elements are actually quite few. It's more about trying to recapture something precious from youth that seems unattainable as one ages. Lehmann-Haupt's prose was accessible and fast paced and he has a real feel for the campfire genre. One of the only issues I had was when the novel purposely goes off the rails at the climax, it becomes batsh*t, but not not batsh*t enough and not for long. SPOILER: The moment when Redclaw tells Jerry that they're going to kill the younger brother because they need to eat him comes out of nowhere and it leads the reader to believe they are descending into a crazy hell. It just doesn't happen. I wish the author had leaped much further into the deep end. Additionally, the main character Jerry, functions as the sane man in a world that's losing sanity. However, he just seemed like a stick in the mud. A killer of fun. I know that's a bizarre criticism because he was spot on with his concerns, but every time he asked the other counselors if something was safe, I kind of wanted to slap him. Good book in general, and certainly not a waste of time. I doubt it will end occupying much space though in my memory bank.
Profile Image for Bill Riggs.
1,067 reviews19 followers
December 22, 2019
I bought this book because it is set close to where I grew up in Western PA and the description sounded interesting. Set at a Summer camp in the 1950’s the main character believes something is off, something is wrong - and for most of the book he spends his time whining and trying to convince everyone that he is right. It would probably be a much better read if the main character wasn’t so annoying - as it is you almost want to see something bad happen to him. Other than that there are quite a few creepy, suspenseful and even horrifying parts. Oh, and how can you have a book take place on Pymatuning Lake and not talk about the carp?? Unacceptable.
Profile Image for Bob Box.
3,212 reviews25 followers
August 6, 2022
Read in 2006. A chilling novel of a 1950's boys summer camp gone awry.
Profile Image for Dawn Wallhausen.
46 reviews1 follower
December 10, 2015
I picked up this book because I spend a fair amount of time at Pymatuning, so the title piqued my interest. Overall, I'm sort-of ambivalent about it, but it was worth a read. Parts were entertaining and the story line was decent, but I had trouble with suspension of disbelief. There are any number of things I struggled to find believable as I read the book.

Other reviewers seem to feel that the book suffered from too much exposition: I think that applies in some cases, but there are other spots where I'd have liked to know more. The book brings up some questions that it never completely answers. This can be a way to build and continue suspense or to make a reader think, but in the instances I have in mind, I think the questions deserved an answer, and to that end, the book ended almost too abruptly.

What did I like about it, apart from what I mentioned briefly in the first paragraph? The setting--not only the place, but also the time period--evoked a sense of nostalgia that I think must be what the author was going for. The exposition that is effective is really pretty good; it's not difficult to become engaged in the book despite its problems. In short, this was not one of my favorite reads, but enjoyable enough.
353 reviews
December 14, 2015
Again, I wish I had a "0" for a Rating as this was abysmal. I only took the book since I grew up going to Pymatuning (PA) and Linesville, PA. My cousins used to camp up there and we'd go to feed the carp, disgusting.

The book started out OK, but then it took different paths, and the ending was just plain ridiculous. It is on par with most James Patterson books. And after all the "hijinks" at the end, the campers are still allowed to stay there? And way too many areas where it seemed it was going down a path that was going to develop the story line, but to me, it was a big fat dead end.

I only hate to rate it so poorly since I will not be able to commiserate with anyone else on it since no one will read it!
Profile Image for Kristy McRae.
1,370 reviews23 followers
March 31, 2012
A very interesting book....not your typical horror novel. I picked it up because of a recommendation on the cover from Stephen King. It wasn't in-your-face horror...definitely more visceral. Not what I expected, but nonetheless, I enjoyed it.
Profile Image for Joe.
552 reviews3 followers
January 15, 2009
A dark spin off of a Lord of Flies theme. An easy fast read with some confusing plot turns and some unsatisfying loose ends at the end.
Profile Image for Debra.
1,910 reviews128 followers
Want to Read
March 24, 2011
Stephen King says: "Warm '50s nostalgia gives way to cold chills in this tale of a summer camp gone bad. Very bad. Think Lake Lord-of-the-Flies."
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews