DNF
This is really bad. Listening to this book has been literally painful. This is all stereotypes after stereotypes. After 75% of the book I couldn’t take any more, I had to stop.
The romance is cliché, too ridiculous to stand and over the top silly and cheese. But my biggest problem is that it is superficial. We have here not only instant-attraction, but instant-love too. There are no evidenced justifications for the characters to fell in love, their love is based on fantasy and preset destiny, there was no way I could connect to that.
The portrayal of the teenager girls here is incredibly disrespectful and annoying. Their behavior is a one-sided caricature of vapid girls whose only care in the world is obsessing about boys. Their conversations are all painfully trivial, and their personalities have no complexities or deepness. There is much more to teenage girls than being obsessed with boys, like for example the very basic need of getting more independence and control over their lives and figuring out who they are. Reducing all those possibilities to chasing boys is constricting, unrealistic and demeaning. I would have never being able to relate to these characters as a 17 year old girl, now, as a woman, I find them offensive, and vexing.
The portrayal of the teenage boy's mentality is very toxic. Fane, a 17 year old boy sees Jacque as his possession. He feels entitled to her, to her body and what she can show of it. This is not what love looks like. He is also, often and from the very beginning, jealous. I have a big problem with that because here that jealousy is glamorized as a form of love. When in reality, jealousy has nothing to do with love, it is actually emotional insecurity when we feel that something we consider ours is being threaten, is the feeling that someone might try to take what is yours. It is not love and it is not the show of someone's love for you. It is anti-productive in any relationship and I am passionately opposed to making it look as something desirable. It comes from possessiveness and insecurity, not love. The foundation of any healthy and happy relationship is trust and respect. A person struggling with jealousy is unable to trust the person they are with or show respect for them as an individual or their boundaries. It does not mean that some loves you, not even close.
Furthermore, Fane is said to be and Alpha and as such he is dominant and aggressive. Once again, here we have another writer that confuses aspects of the toxic-masculinity culture with being dominant. Well, the thing is that to be dominant does not mean you have to be aggressive. In fact, studies have shown that dominance sustained without aggressive behaviors is more stable than dominance formed on the basis of aggressive displays. One can establish dominance through many other methods like confidence, experienced, argumentation, respect, persuasion, age, etc., aggression is not necessary and this idea comes from the regressive idea of how a man should behave to be a real manly “man”. The funny thing is that despite Fane describing himself as aggressive, he never shows it (at least not on the part of the book I have read), it is all talk for the sake of this misguided toxic ideal.
Story-wise: Most of the conversations between the characters are absurd and everything that happens is cliché. Nevertheless, the biggest miss is that the conflict presented in the plot is driven by a weak and unreasonable motivation, which makes it not plausible enough to be relevant and sustainable.
The Audiobook: I have listen to several other audiobooks read by this narrator and generally, I like her. However, in this case, the voices that she makes for the teenager girls are very annoying, which only serves to make the girls even more aggravating that they already are. Jacque sounds like a brat most of the time, while Sally (Jacque’s friend) sounds like a 10 year old. But the worst is reserved for Jen (Jacque’s other friend) who sounds like a hag that smokes a thousand cigarettes a day, just HORRENDOUS.
To conclude I’ll just say that regarding romantic relationships between teenagers, I think this book is a terrible example, and could influence negatively and create unrealistic expectations on the minds of some impresionable teens that could lead to unhealthy relationships. Regarding everything else, this book is just plain bad, cheese and cliché.
It is not worth reading, there are many other books out there about werewolves for young adults that are, go read those and stay away from this.