My very first read from Margaret Oliphant and I have somewhat mixed feelings. The story was quite sensationalist in its plot with copious secrets involving mothers and children and this certainly kept the pages turning. There are some great characters such as Miss Bethune, a Scottish lady of fortune and Doctor Rowland, a man ahead of his time in his surmises that a person’s mental and emotional state can affect their physical health. The concept of the whole story taking place almost exclusively in one boarding house also works well with lots of coming and goings from one floor to another and put upon servants. Oliphant makes commentary on the position of women at the time and the different expectations society has of them and writes some quite affecting passages about her characters emotions, managing to portray Dora, the teenage daughter of Mr. Mannering very realistically for example.
What lets it down ultimately is the writing itself and even then, it is primarily in the first part of the book. In the opening chapters there is some rather clunky sentences and a lot of repetition of the same idea. It is almost as though these parts were not edited properly as when the novel gets going, this is far less noticeable. This is not one of Oliphant’s most well-known novels and as she wrote over a hundred, I am still likely to pick up something else because it was an easy and mostly enjoyable read.