Back in the early 2000s I spent hundreds, if not thousands of dollars on eBay buying up every piece of Dawsons Creek merchandise I could find from rare promo posters to the novels based on the show, to signed scripts and a series of 4 tv guide covers depicting the characters. I even had a replica of the necklace Dawson wore early on. I watched the show all the time on VHS (and later DVD when all the seasons were finally released) and was obsessed. When I randomly found out a book had recently been written about the show I was stoked!
This book, while being about the show, doesn’t really have any cogent points. It provides examples of dialogue and then “analysis” which sometimes is just summarizing what was said in the dialogue. At one point they share a quote and the only insight offered is this: #soulmates.
It is also very selective about what dialogue it includes to classify characters dichotomously as either awful or amazing. Sure, Dawson was probably the most annoying character, but it only focuses on those times he was wrong. It doesn’t mention how he helped pay for Joey’s college or saved Pacey and Jen’s lives or sacrificed his relationship with Joey by informing her of her dad’s criminal activity. It just harps on how terrible he is. On the other side of the coin, it puts Pacey on a pedestal and neglects to mention how he lost all of his friends money, slept with a married woman, cheated on Audrey, and treated Joey like garbage at their prom.
The collector in me had to have this book, but the avid reader and Dawson’s Creek fan was extremely disappointed. Before I read it I was excited to learn the authors have a Dawson’s Creek podcast, but after finishing it, I have no desire to listen to said podcast.