SPITTING DEVIL [2012] By Brian Freeman
My Review Four Stars****
This short story was written by the author about a year after he had published his fifth Jonathan Stride novel THE BURYING PLACE [2010]. The genesis of the tale is quite interesting. Freeman’s Spanish publisher was compiling a crime anthology with the theme designated as “the perfect crime”. Freeman was asked to contribute a short story for the project. The author decided to put his own spin on things and in SPITTING DEVIL it is someone’s “perfect life” that is stolen. The protagonist in this story is Alison Malville, a woman who has it all, but it is also a Jonathan Stride story. In Freeman’s own words “…this story gave me a chance to catch up on Stride’s life”. In fact, it is considered to be “5.5” in the Jonathan Stride book series. This designation is due to the liminal glimpse it provides into what is happening in the time frame following the conclusion of THE BURYING PLACE.
The police in Duluth, Minnesota are in pursuit of a serial killer dubbed “Dead Read”, and the detectives in the tale are only peripheral characters. SPITTING DEVIL works as a short story independent of the fact that the plot line has Jonathan Stride and his partner Maggie Bei at the helm of the hunt. However, fans of the author’s Stride books are treated to a look at what is happening with the relationship between Stride and Bei.
This short story was a quick read and I thoroughly enjoyed it but for one criticism. The author opined that (SPITTING DEVIL) “brings a lot of depth to the format” and Freeman was quite pleased by a reader who wrote “Couldn't believe how well you developed those characters in such a short story.” This provided an insightful look into the mindset of the author and what he hoped to accomplish with this short story. This is the first short story I have read by Brian Freeman. I purchased it (along with TURN TO STONE, a Novella designated as Jonathan Stride “5.6” in the series and also as a “Prelude” to #6 THE COLD NOWHERE) because I wanted to enjoy the events that bridged the distance between the finale of THE BURYING PLACE [2010] and the first page of THE COLD NOWHERE [2013]. I don’t read many short stories per se, but the formats couldn’t be more different if they tried. It follows that an author who excels at full-length novels may not be equally adept at penning short stories that are limited both in scope and page length. I feel satisfied after reading a well written short story. In the case of SPITTING DEVIL, it was figuratively a half-full glass of fine champagne as opposed to a full glass of cold beer in a frosted mug on a hot day. The author DID bring a lot of depth to the format, which is my only complaint. The short story felt like a fully developed novel unfolding, and I found myself mentally logging clues that were insidiously included in the narrative (the killer left evidence of hemoptysis at the murder scenes and the heroine of the story is a heavy smoker of instance). In a short story there are no holds barred. The author can misdirect the readers and good can be bad and vice versa. The hook is to snag their interest at the outset, lead them down a path, and then turn it all upside down with the big reveal. Frankly SPITTING DEVIL gave the reader more than that. There was deeper character development, the expected misdirection, and then double the plot twists.
In my opinion the author did not demonstrate an innate knack for the short story format. It left many readers wanting more I would expect. In my case, I got to learn what happened with the Jonny and Maggie experiment and I really enjoyed the couple’s endeavors to unmask the serial murderer nicknamed by the media as “Dead Red”. I will also acknowledge that despite the clearly planted clues to the identity of the villain, I was effectively misdirected and was surprised by the ending. This story of a woman with a fairy tale marriage, a beautiful home, good kid, and a handsome hard-working husband is rife with psychological suspense and really knocks it out of the ball park as a complex well-conceived whodunit. A short story wouldn’t typically lend itself to a discussion about marital relationships, but this one easily could qualify. Would (could?) a couple survive the horror that was unleashed to steal their perfect life.
A DEVILISH SHORT STORY TO ENJOY BETWEEN THE AUTHOR’S JONATHAN STRIDE BOOKS #5 AND #6