What do you think?
Rate this book


226 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2008
Long Version: The short version above represents more accurate summarization than snarky criticism. ”A Downhill Lie grows out of a golf journal Hiaasen keeps during a roughly 18 month return to the activity of golf in which he details his deteriorating play, efforts to remedy it and the emotional toll it takes on him. The book lacks true literary merit – it isn’t particularly funny or dramatic or moving or interesting or entertaining in any real sense. He makes some small effort at participatory journalism by partaking in a few clearly dubious stroke cutting pills, drills and products offered for sale to golfers who tend to have far more money than skepticism when it comes to improving their game. However, Hiaasen clearly brings the perspective of the believer (until the magical bracelet, pill, training club, etc. proves to be ineffective) and not the objective journalist or winking, Michael Moore-esque critic. He tries to weave in golfing memories of his deceased father but and burgeoning memories of playing with his wife and small children but these are too straightforward and perfunctory to offer much juice. He does offer some reflected celebrity glory but these are either on the level of celebrity of sportswriter Mike Lupica or stories about how he saw someone say something to Tiger Woods.
In the end Hiaasen simply spends a lot of time talking about the horrendous round of golf that day and how it made him question his fundamental worth as a human being. It seems he doesn’t so much feel bad about himself because of his course performance but sees his course performance as an outward reflection of his fundamental unworthiness. Unfortunately, this self-loathing isn’t severe enough to qualify as worthy of note (at one point he drowns his sorrows in Coca-cola yawn). In short, one wonders why the accomplished writer of fiction didn’t embellish his anecdotes a bit – this is memoir after all and no one would have done a reconciliation between his private golf journal and finished book. Try reading one of his novels, maybe they are entertaining.