Lucy Lancaster is working on a family history project for hotel heiress Pippa Sutton and her family. Pipp's mother, Roselyn, is a thorn in Lucy's side for not wanting her family tree done. Working hard is a good distraction for Lucy's broken heart. Special Agent Ben Turner has been MIA for ages even though he swore he didn't go undercover. Lucy believes he's "ghosted" her. When a clearly ill man stumbles onto the hotel property and into Lucy, he hands her a Montblac pen and begs her to keep them safe. Who are them and why does Lucy need to keep them safe? The man unfortunately dies and the pen disappears in the chaos. Pipp's dog, Boomer, finds the pen and delivers it to Lucy in return for treats. Lucy is curious about the pen as her beloved grandfather collects antique Mont Blanc fountain pens. When she shows him the pen, her grandfather becomes mysterious. He shows up at the Hotel Sutton unexpectedly, just as Lucy is about to show the pen to the assorted Sutton descendants. She notices something odd about the pen. Lucy then gets swept up in a mystery involving her grandfather, old secrets from WWII and a top-secret spying mission to save the world from the Nazis. It looks like the man's death was connected and Grandpa suspects others may be in danger as well. Lucy must use all her research skills to figure out who will be targeted next. As she gets closer, more people are killed and her own life, Grandpa's and Pippa's lives may also be in danger. Can Lucy figure out who the crafty killer is in time?
This mystery was not as engaging as the first book in the series. World War II is not my thing and I don't read spy thrillers for a reason. This is not a geneaological mystery in the true sense. Lucy needs her Grandpa's spy knowledge and to call in favors from friends and she still can't figure it out. The identity of the murderer was SOOOOO obvious from the beginning! As soon as the murder method was revealed, Lucy should have known. If she were a real historian and not just a geneaologist with an interest in history, she'd have figured it out. It was just too obvious. While there are a few red herrings along the way, they're not strong enough to lead away from the true killer. There's not enough geneaological research in this book to please me and it needs the chart from the first book to explain the cousin relationship so readers know how Pippa is related to each of her relatives. I liked the first chapter in the cemetary the best but it has NOTHING to do with the rest of the book. There's a secondary mystery that bogs down the novel and one minor mystery from the past that doesn't really add anything to the story. There's a little too much going on here.
I like Lucy well enough but I am still bothered by her lack of background in history and library studies. She loves history and discussing history but she doesn't seem to have formally studied history. She also doesn't know when to shut up. I can relate to that! She's more open and personable than most researchers I know. Something about her just doesn't feel authentic to me for some reason. I don't like her self-pity party over Ben. Even though he said he doesn't go undercover, I believe he said rarely, not never. He does work for the FBI so it stands to reason he may be up to something he can't tell her. However, he should have had a colleague contact Lucy to say he was alive and would contact her when he could, if that's allowed, or told her up front he's too busy for a relationship right now. That subplot was way predictable and too rushed.
What I do really like about Lucy is her relationship with her grandpa. They're fun together and their relationship is sweet. It's obvious how much she loves and cares about him. Grandpa Lancaster is a hoot. George has some pretty big secrets and now is the time he has to share them. I would think that information would still be classified for 75 years or 75 years + until all parties involved are dead. George can not possibly have been as old as 19 in 1944 or he shaved many years off his age. My grandmother was a 20 year old war bride in 1944 and is currently 96 years old. There are very few WWII veterans still alive, let alone veterans with amazing memories like George's. I found that just a little bit implausible but maybe I'm jealous and wishing my grandfather was still alive and my grandmother's memory was not affected by Alzheimers. George is kind, caring and extremely brave. He's a real hero. George is also cheeky and mischievous at times. I wonder if the author chose the musical Oklamahoma as the theater ticket because it was the hottest show on Broadway in 1944? George could have gotten tickets because he was a serviceman but regular people had to wait and wait and wait. My grandpa took his war bride to see it in March that year on their honeymoon. They went back to NY for their 60th anniversary and it was a massive sticker shock experience just to sleep at the same hotel, let alone go see a show!
George's story is thrilling and kept me turning the pages to see how Lucy would decode the message. She took too long. I recognized the pigpen cypher from the Revolutionary War. As George said, it's not hard to crack. The book cipher is another old one but it's supposed to use a book EVERYONE had on their bookshelf like the Bible or Shakespeare, not some random early 20th-century novel that's been reprinted a million times. That part of the story made me roll my eyes and I was frustrated at Lucy's delay.
I really like Pippa Sutton. I was expecting a Paris Hilton type spoiled brat but Pippa is a smart businesswoman who cares a lot about her family heritage passed down from her great-grandparents. She's excited to learn what Lucy has to tell her about her family heritage and share it with her relatives. Pippa also cares a lot about the hotel staff and moves them around from her other properties to make sure she has staff she can trust to do the job well. I love how welcoming and kind she is to Lucy. Not every hotelier would invite Lucy to STAY on site, let alone allow her to invite her besties over for New Year's Eve! I also love Pippa's relationship with her Yellow Lab, Boomer. Boomer is goofy, sweet and lovable. He adores Pippa as much as she loves him.
Pippa also loves her mom. Roselyn can be flighty and rude at times but Pippa never judges. She worries about her mom and wants to help. Roselyn is not very likable at first but I grew to like her and was envious of the close mother-daughter relationship.
Mrs. Pollingham, the front desk manager, is a motherly sort but she's also very strict about keeping the hotel clean and about the rules. She can be tough when she wants to be. Mrs. P has to run the hotel, deal with angry guests and worry about the dead bodies associated with the hotel. I feel sorry for her. She's been a good friend to Pippa's mom and I think the two may have a closer connection than they realize or tell anyone about. I don't understand her catchphrase "Och" if she's supposed to be American of English parentage? "Och" is Scottish. I've never met anyone who actually says "och" in real life. Maybe it's supposed to sound old-fashioned?
Chef Rocky is not of LATIN heritage if he's Italian. Italians are not Latin as much as a certain person I know claims they are. Lucy must not know many Italians or do Italian geneology because for some reason she doesn't know Rocky is the Anglicized version of Rocco, a common Italian first name. I rolled my eyes at her lack of knowledge. A true geneaologist would know the common names of immigrants and the American equivalents. Chef Rocky is a bit tempermental. He's certainly arrogant thinking he's God's gift to women. He's rude to flirt with all the women and make them think they're special when it doesn't mean anything to him. I don't like him but I want to try his chocolate mint gelato! He doesn't deserve what happens to him at all.
Lucy's friends add some lightness and humor to the novel. There isn't enough of them or of Flaco's Tacos. I don't like tacos or Mexican food but I'm up for some break-up churros and chocolate! I like how protective Flaco is of Lucy. He's almost like an uncle to her.
Hugo Markham was a nutty government conspiracy theorist. Hmm he may have actually been on to something now. He was known to the CIA as a harmless threat but he can't have been that harmless to have someone murder him! He didn't deserve to die. The killer is truly evil and remorseless. The killer's motive is vastly scary and unbelievable but sadly, probably plausible.
David S. Eason, Pippa's "Uncle Dave" has a special subplot of his own. He's kind of boorish and whiny. He can't move past an incident that ended his career. He does sound "used carsalesman"ish as Pippa describes his manner. I find him crude and not worth speaking to even if he is enthusiastic about the family history.
Officer Carr is the man in charge of the investigation. He's tough but I think he's fair. At first I thought he suspected Lucy of murder but he just wanted to get the facts while they were fresh in her mind. Detective Dupart is kind of a jerk and doesn't know how to handle nosy geneaologists yet. He knows how to do his job and does it well but this mystery is beyond his scope. He needs Lucy's help and she needs him. I hope they can work together again.
Even though I didn't enjoy this story as much as the first in the series, I hope the author writes more about the Ancestry Detective.