I need to preface this with the statement that:
1) I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review,
2) The entire CHRONOS Files saga is fairly nostalgic for me. I binged the first trilogy and I have very fond memories of the entire experience,
And 3) I also need to say that this series would probably be fairly confusing to people who haven't read the first series.
I loved the characters and the concept and the world so incredibly much. Even still, when I reread the first book earlier this year to remind myself of some things that happened in the original trilogy, it wasn't QUITE as good as I remembered. But this isnt a review of the first trilogy.
All of that was to say, the first book in this spin-off series, Now, Then, and Every When, hit me with the same feelings as the first time I read that trilogy. Though I had a slower time getting into that book, it quickly picked up and I sped through the remaining 75%. I was into the time period and new characters and the aspects of history that were being explored.
That wasn't exactly the case in this second book. While I still enjoyed it, I feel as though the entire plot of this one centered too strongly on a game that doesn't exist in our world and so was conceptually difficult (for me, anyway) to understand. I found myself wanting the rule book the characters were given so I could maybe follow along a bit easier. Time Chess, aka The Game, aka Temporal Dilemma, was so complex that I kept struggling to understand why the characters were doing what they were doing while also trying to keep up with a period of American history I'm not well versed in.
While I did enjoy reading this and getting to see some returning old faces again, I definitely enjoyed the 1st book better. For one, I feel as though the events of the second book drastically change the timeline with regards to the events of the first trilogy, and I kept getting distracted going down a "timeline" hole of attempting to figure out how the actions of these characters would affect the timeline of the previous books. This might not have bothered me so much if the entire plot of this series, and this book in particular, didn't revolve specifically around changing the timeline and reversing said changes to the timeline in order to return to the "original", ie the timeline from the previous trilogy.
*****SPOILERS FOR THE FIRST TRILOGY, DO NOT READ ANY FURTHER IF YOU HAVEN'T READ IT YET*****
I also dislike how certain characters are portrayed in this series. Katherine was such a strong individual in the first trilogy, and while I can understand that the events of her life led her to be that way and it was not necessarily how she was in her youth, Katherine is portrayed as annoyingly naive and ignorant in this series.
Saul obviously walks all over her, insults her to her face, demeans her constantly, and all is constantly forgiven, in my opinion, in an unrealistic manner. The author attempts to explain this in the plot in a couple of different ways, and I can't tell if the reason was more that she was genetically tampered with to be more submissive as a side effect of the time period she chose to research, or if we were supposed to believe that she reasoned it all away as "relationship compromise" in which he got everything he wanted and she didn't. She reasons away the awful things he does constantly, to the point where I actually disliked her character.
All of this is to say that, while I clearly had issues with this story, I still love the concept and the characters (Madi and Tyson and Jack in particular!) and will definitely be continuing with the third book. I just had to give this 3 stars because of my issues outline above, but its entirely possible that the confusion I experienced was entirely my fault regarding the timeline issues and the game being played. Also, the politics-heavy time period of history that was chosen was just not my thing, while I know for a fact that others will be more interested in it than I was.
All in all, I do love the CHRONOS Files and CHRONOS Origins, and I'm interested to see where the third book will take all of these characters. This book was not my favorite, but I still enjoyed myself reading it for the most part!