I was looking for a quick, spooky read. What I got was poor characterization, less than stellar writing conventions, and a rushed and unrealistic story.
First off, I need to like characters. Or hate them. I just need to feel something extreme to want to keep reading. Clarissa was just downright confusing. It was like the author kept forgetting how she was supposed to act or think. Ed is glanced over so quickly. Even the ghosts are poorly constructed and barely in the story...and it’s a freakin ghost story!!!
As a creative writing teacher, I can be hard to please. I get that. But could someone teach these authors how to write dialogue, internal monologue and narration? Use italics and quotation marks correctly, people! There were times that the narration sounded like a documentary or a history book - no ambiance whatsoever for a ghost story. Sometimes the dialogue should have been narration or narration should have been dialogue or the dialogue repeated what the narration had just said. I felt like pulling out my hair but I don’t want to be bald so I just read through the story faster to end my pain.
The plot itself was lackluster. While this is the length of a long short story, an author could use time wisely and make sure that the imagery and world building makes sense. Character names changed as did the mystery. Earlier information about the 1919 characters changed but in a way that made it seem like Riley Amitrani forgot what the details were. The flood, which was described as a wall of water, didn’t knock down the mansion or any other house, didn’t break windows, flooded the mansion but didn’t move furniture. How is that possible? People in the area want to forget about the flood, even though everyone survived it besides the family in the mansion. Really? Why? Their ancestors survived. Why would you forget the one family who died? No one has investigated the town underwater. Not even divers? A whole town submerged and no one has put on scuba gear to check it out? They do that in the ocean all the time with shipwrecks. No one has thought to do that in a lake and a whole submerged village? Not realistic at all. The story dragged for most of the time and then when it mattered, everything moved too quickly. The whole climax was rushed and I couldn’t have cared less. It felt like the author also couldn’t have cared less.
Sadly, this is one I would not recommend to anyone.