What do you think?
Rate this book
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus
In 1928, Bonaventure Circus outcast Pippa Ripley must decide if uncovering her roots is worth putting herself directly in the path of a killer preying on the troupe. Decades later, while determining if an old circus train depot will be torn down or preserved, Chandler Faulk is pulled into a story far darker and more haunting than she imagined.
391 pages, Paperback
First published September 1, 2020
189 people are currently reading
4639 people want to read
About the author
Jaime Jo Wright
29 books2,396 followersDaphne du Maurier and Christy Award-Winning author, Jaime Jo Wright resides in the hills of Wisconsin writing suspenseful, mysteries stained with history's secrets. Jaime lives in dreamland, exists in reality, and invites you to join her adventures at jaimewrightbooks.com!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 715 reviews
December 19, 2025
4.5 Stars
I really enjoyed this one!
Mel 🖤🐶🐺🐾
I really enjoyed this one!
Mel 🖤🐶🐺🐾
July 22, 2020
If only I could give this book 100 stars rather than only five.
This book, this author, I am so in awe!
No one presents words in quite the way Jamie Jo Wright does.
If you were to give twenty authors the subject matter this book was composed of none would present it in the way this author does.
I read so many books per year that I can truly get burnt out on the sameness of the books, not so with this author's books.
She has just the presentation I am looking for, which is originality. Originality is very hard to find in today's writing world.
A time split novel, The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus is a novel of the past colliding with present on a collision course that's frightening yet fascinating . It keeps you reading late into the night as you try to grasp what you're reading and process it. The past is amazingly connected to the present in ways you can't even begin to imagine.
If you don't read this book you are really missing out. I highly recommend it!
Pub Date 01 Sep 2020 by Bethany House Publishers.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
This book, this author, I am so in awe!
No one presents words in quite the way Jamie Jo Wright does.
If you were to give twenty authors the subject matter this book was composed of none would present it in the way this author does.
I read so many books per year that I can truly get burnt out on the sameness of the books, not so with this author's books.
She has just the presentation I am looking for, which is originality. Originality is very hard to find in today's writing world.
A time split novel, The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus is a novel of the past colliding with present on a collision course that's frightening yet fascinating . It keeps you reading late into the night as you try to grasp what you're reading and process it. The past is amazingly connected to the present in ways you can't even begin to imagine.
If you don't read this book you are really missing out. I highly recommend it!
Pub Date 01 Sep 2020 by Bethany House Publishers.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
August 30, 2020
Jaime Jo Wright definitely knows a good way to mix historic and present-day mysteries. I love seeing how the stories of the two eras come together and how a mystery of the past continues until today. This one totally kept me up at night to see how it would turn out.
One thing that really stood out to me in this book is the extreme diversity of characters. I sometimes have a hard time remembering individual characters, but that totally was not the case here. Every single character was vivid in their unique characteristics and traits.
I could really identify with Chandler. Not her “stupid mistakes of the past,” but her daily energy and health struggles (though I don’t have Lyme). I’m very thankful for authors who include realistic health issues in their books.
There is no surprise that this story deals with ghost talk. Sometimes, in obsessive details. I’m okay with ghost-talk. However, I’m not quite okay with it being left unresolved and no finalized fact. Coupled with that, there was also a character who discussed “negative energy” and “had connections” that were slightly disturbing for a Christian book.
The spiritual message actually left me confused. In thinking back over it, I think it boils down to the fact that spiritual truths were delivered by human opinion rather than solidified by the foundation of God’s Word. Like, each character had to accept for themselves what was truth in their situation, with their understanding. In a way, each character was so very well developed in that their perspective of God was all different. But I think that is also a grave danger, because this is the message the readers are receiving. There has to be the foundation of God’s Word for truth, regardless our feelings, regardless our upbringing, and regardless our opinions. For instance, one character believed in God, however, “But I do have a mind. And, I do have . . . well, I have my ways to support myself, I do, and I know I ain’t perfect, and maybe I don’t do everything to make God smile, but I still believe in Him. And I try to make good choices, when I can.” And then later, she quoted her grandmother, saying, “If we were all good and flawless, then Jesus wasted His blood.” But it was used more as an excuse for continuing a sinful lifestyle rather than being redeemed and sanctified for God’s glory.
The romance was a fairly good balance. There were a few kisses mentioned, but I didn’t feel like there was extreme passion between the love interests. However, there were many references to women of questionable character and ways men handled women.
I wouldn’t advise teens to read this because of the confusing spiritual content and the story revolving around loose morals.
*I received this book from NetGalley and happily provided my honest review.*
One thing that really stood out to me in this book is the extreme diversity of characters. I sometimes have a hard time remembering individual characters, but that totally was not the case here. Every single character was vivid in their unique characteristics and traits.
I could really identify with Chandler. Not her “stupid mistakes of the past,” but her daily energy and health struggles (though I don’t have Lyme). I’m very thankful for authors who include realistic health issues in their books.
There is no surprise that this story deals with ghost talk. Sometimes, in obsessive details. I’m okay with ghost-talk. However, I’m not quite okay with it being left unresolved and no finalized fact. Coupled with that, there was also a character who discussed “negative energy” and “had connections” that were slightly disturbing for a Christian book.
The spiritual message actually left me confused. In thinking back over it, I think it boils down to the fact that spiritual truths were delivered by human opinion rather than solidified by the foundation of God’s Word. Like, each character had to accept for themselves what was truth in their situation, with their understanding. In a way, each character was so very well developed in that their perspective of God was all different. But I think that is also a grave danger, because this is the message the readers are receiving. There has to be the foundation of God’s Word for truth, regardless our feelings, regardless our upbringing, and regardless our opinions. For instance, one character believed in God, however, “But I do have a mind. And, I do have . . . well, I have my ways to support myself, I do, and I know I ain’t perfect, and maybe I don’t do everything to make God smile, but I still believe in Him. And I try to make good choices, when I can.” And then later, she quoted her grandmother, saying, “If we were all good and flawless, then Jesus wasted His blood.” But it was used more as an excuse for continuing a sinful lifestyle rather than being redeemed and sanctified for God’s glory.
The romance was a fairly good balance. There were a few kisses mentioned, but I didn’t feel like there was extreme passion between the love interests. However, there were many references to women of questionable character and ways men handled women.
I wouldn’t advise teens to read this because of the confusing spiritual content and the story revolving around loose morals.
*I received this book from NetGalley and happily provided my honest review.*
December 7, 2020
I thoroughly enjoyed The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus by Jaime Jo Wright! It was such a good read; gripping, mysterious, sincere, thought provoking, and of course, a little spooky!
This novel is gold! It tells two stories; one story is set in the present and one in the 1920s, but they are fused together by the history and a haunting of the circus depot. The protagonists, Chandler in the present and Pippa in the 1920s, are equally haunted by the mysteries and secrets of the crimes at The Watchman and the Bonaventure Circus. Some mysteries really do take a century to solve and most secrets hurt no matter when they are discovered.
The parallel stories are creatively twisted together with excellent writing and exceptional detail.
Interestingly enough, the stories are strikingly similar but it never feels repetitive. It’s intriguing. Chandler and Pippa are crippled by fear, loneliness and the never ending torture of feeling less than or never good enough for the people around them. They struggle with loss and physical health handicaps, they experience abandonment and a longing to belong. And they are both struggling with their faith.
While the characters and personal journeys are developing, a gripping mystery is simultaneously unfolding. The writing is skilled and so vivid that you can create the whole scene in your mind’s eye with little difficulty.
Thank you NetGalley, Bethany House Publishers, and Jaime Jo Wright for a copy of this book for review.
Possible triggers: domestic and societal mistreatment of women, mentions of God and faith, murder and some gore.
Thank you for reading my review on Goodreads! Follow me on Instagram (@journeyofthepages) for further bookish engagement! www.instragram.com/journeyofthepages I hope to meet you there!
This novel is gold! It tells two stories; one story is set in the present and one in the 1920s, but they are fused together by the history and a haunting of the circus depot. The protagonists, Chandler in the present and Pippa in the 1920s, are equally haunted by the mysteries and secrets of the crimes at The Watchman and the Bonaventure Circus. Some mysteries really do take a century to solve and most secrets hurt no matter when they are discovered.
The parallel stories are creatively twisted together with excellent writing and exceptional detail.
Interestingly enough, the stories are strikingly similar but it never feels repetitive. It’s intriguing. Chandler and Pippa are crippled by fear, loneliness and the never ending torture of feeling less than or never good enough for the people around them. They struggle with loss and physical health handicaps, they experience abandonment and a longing to belong. And they are both struggling with their faith.
While the characters and personal journeys are developing, a gripping mystery is simultaneously unfolding. The writing is skilled and so vivid that you can create the whole scene in your mind’s eye with little difficulty.
Thank you NetGalley, Bethany House Publishers, and Jaime Jo Wright for a copy of this book for review.
Possible triggers: domestic and societal mistreatment of women, mentions of God and faith, murder and some gore.
Thank you for reading my review on Goodreads! Follow me on Instagram (@journeyofthepages) for further bookish engagement! www.instragram.com/journeyofthepages I hope to meet you there!
July 12, 2020
This was a heart thumping time slip novel set in 1928 and current day. It evolves around a circus that has its headquarters in a small town. Strange noises, screams, ghosts and serial killers all play a part in this story, especially in the dark of night. The not so perfect characters won places in my heart. Pippa in the 1928 tale was born of circus parents and had a deformed leg. Given up at birth, she was raised by the owner of the Bonaventure Circus along with his wife. A very strict father kept Pippa under his thumb most of her young life. She found time to sneak off to the wonders and people in the circus world feeling a connection deep in her soul. Pippa was lost and felt so unloved, always searching for acceptance. Baby Lily also won me over. Her rejection by her mom left lots of hurt and scars that formed in big tears and whines from within. Pippa could relate so well to Lily and they formed a close bond beyond explanation.
Chandler in modern day was just trying to survive and raise her young son Peter alone. She was working on a renovation of the old circus buildings under her uncle who purchased the property. Strange sounds and moans and scraps across the floors that couldn’t be explained sent Chandler on a search into the past. Rumors of a serial killer, the Watchman, surfaced as she dug deeper and deeper. What was it going to cost her in the end?
And who couldn’t love an author that uses such fun words as “heebie-jeebies” and “flibbertigibbet”?
Look for them! And my favorite reference to my all time favorite TV show, Andy Griffith on Loc 1695.
My takeaway from this book, “the best families are made of broken people.”
I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the author through Netgalley but was not required to write a review.
Chandler in modern day was just trying to survive and raise her young son Peter alone. She was working on a renovation of the old circus buildings under her uncle who purchased the property. Strange sounds and moans and scraps across the floors that couldn’t be explained sent Chandler on a search into the past. Rumors of a serial killer, the Watchman, surfaced as she dug deeper and deeper. What was it going to cost her in the end?
And who couldn’t love an author that uses such fun words as “heebie-jeebies” and “flibbertigibbet”?
Look for them! And my favorite reference to my all time favorite TV show, Andy Griffith on Loc 1695.
My takeaway from this book, “the best families are made of broken people.”
I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the author through Netgalley but was not required to write a review.
December 13, 2020
I wanted to love this book & I almost did. Then there was the end & it completely screwed it up. So, that’s how a four star review turns to two stars. If you haven’t read it and want to, stop reading this now b/c I’m about to launch into an analysis of why this book makes no sense.
There are two MC. Pippa, who is from the past and is alive during the time of a serial killer, and Chandler who has purchased the old circus depot to refurbish as an investment. She is modern day.
Modern day Chandler meets the grandson of the person believed to be the serial killer in the past. His sister disappeared as a child & his family has been ostracized b/c people think he could have inherited the “serial killer” gene. It is later discovered that Pippa Ripley’s father (the man who owned the circus) was the serial killer. To keep this info from getting out, the descendent of Pippa’s cousin had killed the missing girl and kidnapped Chandler’s son. Which seems fine, right. Makes sense. Pippa didn’t have any siblings, so it couldn’t be a brother or sister of hers and Pippa was adopted, so the dependents would have to come from a first cousin. The problem with that is the first cousins are the mother’s side of the family, so they couldn’t have inherited the “serial killer” gene if that is even a thing. So, Chandler’s entire story falls apart. The author tries to explain it as “killing isn’t rational,” but that’s a cop out.
Then you go back to Pippa’s story & she is searching for love. Desperate to the point of recklessness. So reckless it is annoying. She keeps meeting this guy who wears a bag over his head and speaks in a frightening way. Her loneliness is due to the coldness of her parents. After her father is murdered (which is a whole separate rant of its own), her mother tells her she always loved her fiercely but kept her distance b/c she didn’t want the danger to hurt Pippa. Which also makes sense unless you remember that he left every summer with the circus and it was always her and her mother. There’s no reason why the mother would have to keep her separation then other than a plot hole.
Sooooo many plot holes. It ruins otherwise good characters & a decent book.
There are two MC. Pippa, who is from the past and is alive during the time of a serial killer, and Chandler who has purchased the old circus depot to refurbish as an investment. She is modern day.
Modern day Chandler meets the grandson of the person believed to be the serial killer in the past. His sister disappeared as a child & his family has been ostracized b/c people think he could have inherited the “serial killer” gene. It is later discovered that Pippa Ripley’s father (the man who owned the circus) was the serial killer. To keep this info from getting out, the descendent of Pippa’s cousin had killed the missing girl and kidnapped Chandler’s son. Which seems fine, right. Makes sense. Pippa didn’t have any siblings, so it couldn’t be a brother or sister of hers and Pippa was adopted, so the dependents would have to come from a first cousin. The problem with that is the first cousins are the mother’s side of the family, so they couldn’t have inherited the “serial killer” gene if that is even a thing. So, Chandler’s entire story falls apart. The author tries to explain it as “killing isn’t rational,” but that’s a cop out.
Then you go back to Pippa’s story & she is searching for love. Desperate to the point of recklessness. So reckless it is annoying. She keeps meeting this guy who wears a bag over his head and speaks in a frightening way. Her loneliness is due to the coldness of her parents. After her father is murdered (which is a whole separate rant of its own), her mother tells her she always loved her fiercely but kept her distance b/c she didn’t want the danger to hurt Pippa. Which also makes sense unless you remember that he left every summer with the circus and it was always her and her mother. There’s no reason why the mother would have to keep her separation then other than a plot hole.
Sooooo many plot holes. It ruins otherwise good characters & a decent book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 26, 2020
Jaime Jo Wright has delighted me again with her gripping and unique brand of fiction. I have coined a new phrase for her stories: CREEPY GOOD!
Dual time books have become a favorite genre for me. Ms. Wright pieces the timelines together with just the right touch. She gives spectacular cliffhangers to the end of some of the chapters to keep you turning pages and wanting more. This is not just entertainment; Ms. Wright weaves life lessons and spiritual truths into the story for good measure.
Regarding circus elephants: Quote “they were not loved so much as treasured. And there was a difference between the two. Love sacrificed, whereas a treasure was hoarded.” Pippa can relate to that.
Pippa on her connection with Forrest: Quote “It was a relationship that reminded her of her paper dolls. Stiff but pretty. Fake but full of imaginary potential.”
The dual time heroines have something in common. They are both insecure and trying to prove themselves worthy. Pippa in 1928 is searching for her true identity and it centers around the circus that her father owns. Chandler is trying to live down a life mistake she made ages ago and can be a bit prickly and untrusting, while trying to be independent and better than competent. Quote “ Maybe she was shutting people out, even while she ached to be seen. It was a wicked oxymoron. But wasn’t that what life was?”
The heroes are unlikely on the surface. Ms. Wright aptly shows that you should not judge by appearances. As one character says: Quote “ If we were all good and flawless, then Jesus wasted His blood.” Hank, in present time: Quote “We all need saving. It’s the idea that we don’t that makes us fools.”
Some highlights were the interaction between Pippa and the baby elephant and Pippa and her dog. The relationship that Chandler had with her son was precious. Peter’s superhero persona, Nitro Man, was a hoot.
With this book you can expect the unexpected!
This is definitely one of my top picks for 2020.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House on behalf of the author. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
Dual time books have become a favorite genre for me. Ms. Wright pieces the timelines together with just the right touch. She gives spectacular cliffhangers to the end of some of the chapters to keep you turning pages and wanting more. This is not just entertainment; Ms. Wright weaves life lessons and spiritual truths into the story for good measure.
Regarding circus elephants: Quote “they were not loved so much as treasured. And there was a difference between the two. Love sacrificed, whereas a treasure was hoarded.” Pippa can relate to that.
Pippa on her connection with Forrest: Quote “It was a relationship that reminded her of her paper dolls. Stiff but pretty. Fake but full of imaginary potential.”
The dual time heroines have something in common. They are both insecure and trying to prove themselves worthy. Pippa in 1928 is searching for her true identity and it centers around the circus that her father owns. Chandler is trying to live down a life mistake she made ages ago and can be a bit prickly and untrusting, while trying to be independent and better than competent. Quote “ Maybe she was shutting people out, even while she ached to be seen. It was a wicked oxymoron. But wasn’t that what life was?”
The heroes are unlikely on the surface. Ms. Wright aptly shows that you should not judge by appearances. As one character says: Quote “ If we were all good and flawless, then Jesus wasted His blood.” Hank, in present time: Quote “We all need saving. It’s the idea that we don’t that makes us fools.”
Some highlights were the interaction between Pippa and the baby elephant and Pippa and her dog. The relationship that Chandler had with her son was precious. Peter’s superhero persona, Nitro Man, was a hoot.
With this book you can expect the unexpected!
This is definitely one of my top picks for 2020.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House on behalf of the author. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
July 12, 2020
I knew that Jaime Jo Wright had written another triumph when I found myself fervently praying for a fictional elephant! This story immediately grabbed my attention and kept me guessing until the last possible moment. With lots of mystery, suspense, and just the right amount of spookish intrigue, this book has it all! Jaime’s writing creates such vivid images that you feel like you can actually see the characters and scenes unfolding. I have to say that the heroes in the story are definitely not your typical heroes and I was surprised at how much I admired them by the end of the story. This is one book that I will definitely read again and again!
November 4, 2020
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus was a great surprise. It takes place in the 1920's and today. I have to admit I don't like books written this way. I just like one side of the story told. It does takes about 6 chapter to get into the story but when it does the book becomes excellent. The story of Pippa and Chandler, Pippa living in the 1920's adopted to a famous circus family not feeling likes she belong and Chandler who is trying to make it on her own with a son. I loved both these women, both don't feel like they really can't make life work for them and feel weak and afraid. Pippa from her controlling family wanting to be in the circus world and Chandler showing her family that she can take care of her son and do her job to the best of their ability. There is a murder that effects both characters that took place inn the 1920's . Both Pippa and Chandler have to figure out who did it and how they can save their own family. When both start looking for who is murdering the circus employees until the finish you will be on the edge of your seat. How can a murder effect both women? Will they discover who done it before it effects both of the women love ones. Its a great murder mystery and a nice romance for both girls. I still not a huge fan of dual time period books but this one is a must read!! Highly recommend this wonderful novel!!
September 13, 2020
"...she wondered if the problem of trouble plus conflict plus heartache could be solved by dividing it with the acceptance of help. Trusting that people—that God—didn’t expect nearly as much of her as she did of herself." ~The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus
Another absolutely captivating read from Jaime Jo Wright. The two stories connect seamlessly, and the characters are all so real and robust (no cardboard cutouts from this author). Even apart from the mystery aspect of this story, I love that the protagonist has some a-ha moments when she realizes that what she thought she knew for sure about her own relationships was only a projection of her own fears. I love the emphasis on parent-child dynamics in this novel.
If you're looking for something different that will keep you turning the pages until you're finished, look no further. The prose is as beautiful as the story itself.
Another absolutely captivating read from Jaime Jo Wright. The two stories connect seamlessly, and the characters are all so real and robust (no cardboard cutouts from this author). Even apart from the mystery aspect of this story, I love that the protagonist has some a-ha moments when she realizes that what she thought she knew for sure about her own relationships was only a projection of her own fears. I love the emphasis on parent-child dynamics in this novel.
If you're looking for something different that will keep you turning the pages until you're finished, look no further. The prose is as beautiful as the story itself.
October 2, 2020
Another terrific read from Jaimie Jo Wright. She takes any kind of story and turns it into a lesson learning, deep thinking read. The story itself is fantastic, but the way each character and experience have an every day meaning and an eternal meaning is amazing.
I thoroughly enjoy split time stories, and I usually can easily pick the historical as my favorite. I can’t always do that with this author. Well written characters with depth, a gripping story from past and present, and a faith and hope theme woven throughout create another wonderful novel that has a place on my forever shelves. You don’t want to miss this one!
I received this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
September 22, 2024
“The best families are made of broken people.”
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus is a book I had never heard of, and I only picked it up because it was on a “suggested reads” shelf at the library. I have never been a fan of the circus, and I am terrified of clowns, so the haunting theme seemed to be the trifecta in what I thought would be a creepy book.
I looked up the author and realized that she had won a Christy Award. I had no idea what that was, so I looked that up too. It is an award for Christian authors, and I was thrown because I didn’t know that this is a Christian book. Sure, there are some mentions of God and praying, but it was just a part of the characters portrayed. Then I started wondering why it even mattered enough for me to waste some of my few remaining brain cells thinking about it.
I was about halfway in and realized that although the story had started a little slow, it was growing on me, and I was invested in the outcome. Yes, I still doubted my affection for Chandler and how much I vibed with her. I was a single mom for many years and had some scary health hurdles in the past, so Chandler should be my spirit animal. It took some time though. Pippa, on the other hand, my heart bled for immediately.
I can tell you that I loved this book, and I will add other works by Jaime Jo Wright to my list and hope that they are just as good as this one. I have seen this book critiqued on the merit of being a Christian work, and I can’t speak to that. What I can speak to is that this was a great story.
It was sometimes sad, frustrating, creepy, inspiring, and creative, and by the 75% read mark, I still didn’t know how it was going to end. I only knew that if Lily died I would riot.
Was the ending totally believable? No, on various levels. Were all side plots satisfactorily explained? Not really. But in terms of a solid story that successfully navigates the time jump style of writing, I enjoyed it despite some minor quibbles.
I am thankful for that Suggested Reads table at my local library because I would likely never have read this book otherwise. Thank you, local library, you know you're fire!
Side notes:
If water is spraying across your house, turn it off at the valve. There were two grown women in this book, who had been on their own for years, yet they did not know this. Either that was a little unrealistic, or I have had abysmal luck with plumbing throughout my life.
Also, waking up in the morning to find a person you barely know feeding your kid and making coffee in your kitchen, after using the key they were given to do some plumbing work (see above), is NOT romantic. It is creepy. Full stop.
Last but not least, I have never been a fan of imitating dialects in a way that is distracting. Denny in this book is a lifelong small-town Wisconsin man, yet he says things like, “Didn’t figure. You’re a cute-‘un but ain’t no biker chick.” I have spent quality time in Wisconsin in various regions and I have never heard anyone there speak like that. It is an odd choice of dialect for Denny.
4.5 rounded up.
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus is a book I had never heard of, and I only picked it up because it was on a “suggested reads” shelf at the library. I have never been a fan of the circus, and I am terrified of clowns, so the haunting theme seemed to be the trifecta in what I thought would be a creepy book.
I looked up the author and realized that she had won a Christy Award. I had no idea what that was, so I looked that up too. It is an award for Christian authors, and I was thrown because I didn’t know that this is a Christian book. Sure, there are some mentions of God and praying, but it was just a part of the characters portrayed. Then I started wondering why it even mattered enough for me to waste some of my few remaining brain cells thinking about it.
I was about halfway in and realized that although the story had started a little slow, it was growing on me, and I was invested in the outcome. Yes, I still doubted my affection for Chandler and how much I vibed with her. I was a single mom for many years and had some scary health hurdles in the past, so Chandler should be my spirit animal. It took some time though. Pippa, on the other hand, my heart bled for immediately.
I can tell you that I loved this book, and I will add other works by Jaime Jo Wright to my list and hope that they are just as good as this one. I have seen this book critiqued on the merit of being a Christian work, and I can’t speak to that. What I can speak to is that this was a great story.
It was sometimes sad, frustrating, creepy, inspiring, and creative, and by the 75% read mark, I still didn’t know how it was going to end. I only knew that if Lily died I would riot.
Was the ending totally believable? No, on various levels. Were all side plots satisfactorily explained? Not really. But in terms of a solid story that successfully navigates the time jump style of writing, I enjoyed it despite some minor quibbles.
I am thankful for that Suggested Reads table at my local library because I would likely never have read this book otherwise. Thank you, local library, you know you're fire!
Side notes:
If water is spraying across your house, turn it off at the valve. There were two grown women in this book, who had been on their own for years, yet they did not know this. Either that was a little unrealistic, or I have had abysmal luck with plumbing throughout my life.
Also, waking up in the morning to find a person you barely know feeding your kid and making coffee in your kitchen, after using the key they were given to do some plumbing work (see above), is NOT romantic. It is creepy. Full stop.
Last but not least, I have never been a fan of imitating dialects in a way that is distracting. Denny in this book is a lifelong small-town Wisconsin man, yet he says things like, “Didn’t figure. You’re a cute-‘un but ain’t no biker chick.” I have spent quality time in Wisconsin in various regions and I have never heard anyone there speak like that. It is an odd choice of dialect for Denny.
4.5 rounded up.
July 8, 2021
I've had this one on my shelf for awhile (sorry) but I am ever so glad I finally got to pick it up. It reminded me of a little trip I took with my parents and daughters to the Circus World Museum in Baraboo (found out why at the end). It was not a good day to go, it was cold, rainy, and my girls were 2 and 4, the youngest afraid of anything in costume. So where do we go - to the circus tent to see a clown demonstration - she screamed the entire time!! But the history of the circus was interesting to see and the pictures of animals helped soothe some.
This is the story of Pippa Ripley, the daughter of the owner of Ripley's Circus, who just got back from their summer tour and was settling down in Wisconsin for the winter. Having a deformity, and knowing she was the biological daughter of circus performers but adopted by the Ripley's, seemed to pull her in two different directions. But yet it seemed she held herself back from happiness. With the mystery of the Watchman who has watched over her for years, and the mysterious murders of girls along the train route, it brings Pippa's fears of belonging to the surface and where she really wants to be.
In present day, Chandler has just bought the old circus depot and costume workshop to revitalize. But it also comes with the history of the depot, the murders that happened, and the strange things still happening. Chandler is also suffering from a lasting immune disorder, raising a child on her own, and holding back from the help she desperately needs, but won't admit.
I truly enjoyed this book and cannot believe I waited so long to read it. As usual, highly recommended read. Always a delight to read one of Ms. Wright's books.
I received this ARC from the publisher for my honest review.
This is the story of Pippa Ripley, the daughter of the owner of Ripley's Circus, who just got back from their summer tour and was settling down in Wisconsin for the winter. Having a deformity, and knowing she was the biological daughter of circus performers but adopted by the Ripley's, seemed to pull her in two different directions. But yet it seemed she held herself back from happiness. With the mystery of the Watchman who has watched over her for years, and the mysterious murders of girls along the train route, it brings Pippa's fears of belonging to the surface and where she really wants to be.
In present day, Chandler has just bought the old circus depot and costume workshop to revitalize. But it also comes with the history of the depot, the murders that happened, and the strange things still happening. Chandler is also suffering from a lasting immune disorder, raising a child on her own, and holding back from the help she desperately needs, but won't admit.
I truly enjoyed this book and cannot believe I waited so long to read it. As usual, highly recommended read. Always a delight to read one of Ms. Wright's books.
I received this ARC from the publisher for my honest review.
September 23, 2020
“Welcome to the circus. A place where eccentrics came to hide and where, even here, they abandoned their own.”
“Maybe this was why the Watchman was so elusive? He was trying to guard her, to protect her from the troubled secret world of this place. This vibrant, glorious, dark place called Bonaventure Circus.”
“I am seen and loved by God. I was created for a purpose. I need no other truth.”
Welcome to the circus! Jaime Jo Wright, the master of dual timeline novels, once again has penned an amazing book. While The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus is probably my least favorite Wright book so far, that speaks volumes when it still gets a 5-star rating! I enjoyed the circus aspects of the 1920’s and the modern day plot that centered around a possible renovation of the buildings that belonged to the circus. The characters are beautifully broken people, either lost and searching or saved and seen by God. There is a lot of great faith aspects per usual and I found myself highlighting a lot of great passages. I also enjoyed how Jaime Jo Wright blended in real areas of her own life (a character battling the effect of Lyme disease and a son like her own who helped come up with the superheroes in the book). The gothic style writing is so distinct which makes Jaime Jo Wright stand out in the Christian fiction market. And the fact that she is so good with endings and surprises makes me a huge fan and one that will keep reading all of her future books!
I received this book free from Netgalley and publisher Bethany House in exchange for an honest review.
For more reviews, please check out my blog!
https://wadeurspider01.wixsite.com/we...
“Maybe this was why the Watchman was so elusive? He was trying to guard her, to protect her from the troubled secret world of this place. This vibrant, glorious, dark place called Bonaventure Circus.”
“I am seen and loved by God. I was created for a purpose. I need no other truth.”
Welcome to the circus! Jaime Jo Wright, the master of dual timeline novels, once again has penned an amazing book. While The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus is probably my least favorite Wright book so far, that speaks volumes when it still gets a 5-star rating! I enjoyed the circus aspects of the 1920’s and the modern day plot that centered around a possible renovation of the buildings that belonged to the circus. The characters are beautifully broken people, either lost and searching or saved and seen by God. There is a lot of great faith aspects per usual and I found myself highlighting a lot of great passages. I also enjoyed how Jaime Jo Wright blended in real areas of her own life (a character battling the effect of Lyme disease and a son like her own who helped come up with the superheroes in the book). The gothic style writing is so distinct which makes Jaime Jo Wright stand out in the Christian fiction market. And the fact that she is so good with endings and surprises makes me a huge fan and one that will keep reading all of her future books!
I received this book free from Netgalley and publisher Bethany House in exchange for an honest review.
For more reviews, please check out my blog!
https://wadeurspider01.wixsite.com/we...
December 12, 2023
Despite not being a circus fan myself, Jaime Jo Wright still kept me entranced in this dual-timeline mystery!
I loved Pippa and Chandler as MCs and could relate to both of them, particularly with their health limitations. Both of these physically weak women were strong amid harrowing circumstances—that’s the kind of strength that really counts. (I also really love Hank & wished we’d gotten to know Jake better.)
There was a lot of ghost talk, but the mystery itself is twisty and complex. I was surprised by the ending, which is always fun!
And the baby elephant… my heart! 🥰
The theme was what I loved best: learning what it means to live a life seen by God the One who created you even when unseen by the rest of the world. 💛
I loved Pippa and Chandler as MCs and could relate to both of them, particularly with their health limitations. Both of these physically weak women were strong amid harrowing circumstances—that’s the kind of strength that really counts. (I also really love Hank & wished we’d gotten to know Jake better.)
There was a lot of ghost talk, but the mystery itself is twisty and complex. I was surprised by the ending, which is always fun!
And the baby elephant… my heart! 🥰
The theme was what I loved best: learning what it means to live a life seen by God the One who created you even when unseen by the rest of the world. 💛
June 29, 2023
new favorite Jamie jo Wright book 👏👏
This book had me so captivated by the story and the characters, and the circus setting was amazing 👌
The ending was so intense and I was completely shocked by the reveal.
I just Absolutely loved it 😍
This book had me so captivated by the story and the characters, and the circus setting was amazing 👌
The ending was so intense and I was completely shocked by the reveal.
I just Absolutely loved it 😍
October 4, 2020
What a mysterious, spooky, and chilling dual timeline tale! I was captivated by both the present and past storylines.
The author did a great job, as always, at weaving two tales that were connected through the ages, yet telling them in such a way that the reader discovers the clues as the characters do.
The author really kept me guessing about who was behind the murders, what exactly happened, and who the heroines of both timelines could trust. This was a tale that definitely kept me turning the pages and nervously wondering what would happen.
Jaime Jo Wright always does a good job of penning tales that can be both spooky, yet not flounder from the truth of God’s word. Some characters may question God’s existence, wonder about the possibilities of ghosts and hauntings, and deal with strange situations, yet the truth will always prevail in this author’s novels, allowing growth and understanding for the main characters.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
The author did a great job, as always, at weaving two tales that were connected through the ages, yet telling them in such a way that the reader discovers the clues as the characters do.
The author really kept me guessing about who was behind the murders, what exactly happened, and who the heroines of both timelines could trust. This was a tale that definitely kept me turning the pages and nervously wondering what would happen.
Jaime Jo Wright always does a good job of penning tales that can be both spooky, yet not flounder from the truth of God’s word. Some characters may question God’s existence, wonder about the possibilities of ghosts and hauntings, and deal with strange situations, yet the truth will always prevail in this author’s novels, allowing growth and understanding for the main characters.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
March 15, 2025
Oh my goodness I could not put this book down. I knew it was going to be good but honestly this book was better than expected! The setting is fantastic and I learned a lot about the circus. The dual timeline was written flawlessly and I completely loved both stories. The characters were unique and I felt like I got to know each of them. I love how the author writes about real life tough stuff. The characters aren’t perfect in any way, they are all broken and searching. This is what makes the book all the better because she introduces the reader to hope. The suspense in both story lines was fantastic and the ending did take me by surprise. The romance side of things was interwoven perfectly.
Getting to read a Jaime Jo Wright novel is pure enjoyment. This story was also extra special as it includes a baby elephant!
Everything written by this author is my favorite.
Five Stars.
“I received the book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own and I was not required to write a positive review.”
Getting to read a Jaime Jo Wright novel is pure enjoyment. This story was also extra special as it includes a baby elephant!
Everything written by this author is my favorite.
Five Stars.
“I received the book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own and I was not required to write a positive review.”
September 1, 2020
“What was the circus really but a façade for them all? A pretend place of wonder when behind its beautiful and celebratory cover were hurting hearts, broken people and wanderers who had no where else to go.”
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus by Jaime Jo Wright takes readers on an epic journey. Set in two time periods with connecting mysteries, the story centers around a traveling circus in the late 1920’s. Pippa Ripley longs to connect to her real family. Abandoned by her parents, all she knows is that they once worked for the circus. A mysterious phantom of a man called The Watchman seems to hold the answers, if Pippa could find him. In the present time, Chandler Faulk tries to keep everything together. A single mother, she moves to Bluff River for work. She’s trying to renovate an old train depot but gets sucked into local lore that has the place pegged as haunted by the ghost of a murdered woman.
The novel enchants readers from the start. Jaime Jo Wright has an amazing way with words. The backdrop of the circus brings out incredible imagery – yet it’s almost a behind the scenes tour for the reader. The focus isn’t the glitz and glamour of the show with the big tents and epic acts. This is the story of the people who work in the shadows, the ones who live to entertain others but hide themselves behind a curtain. Jake Chambers is a brooding man that just wants justice for his sister’s murder. Clive is a dwarf dealing with being rejected because of his stature. Their stories come to light as they try to figure out the mystery behind the Watchman. No one knows who he is, but he appears around the circus in a burlap bag mask and is associated with a string of murders along the circus stops.
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus definitely gives off some creepy vibes. The author creates an ambiance of Gothic imagery that adds another layer to the imagery and plotline. It all works together to create this world full of magic and mystery, that spans decades and reaches into the broken hearts of the characters with offers of redemption and healing. Many of the character find refuge in the circus, yet the modern setting reflects the same hidden identities of the performers. Both Pippa and Chandler just want to be seen, they long for a place to call their own where they are known and loved. Their parallel stories seem to intersect seamlessly. Chandler tries so hard to overcome her past, that she self-destructs by thinking she can’t manage. Hank Titus brings warmth and depth into her life by seeing her for who she truly is and not expecting her to manage everything by herself.
As far as the suspense, the entire story is a complicated and twisted mystery. Chandler uncovers information about the 1920’s murder, and someone wants her to stop looking. The old train depot definitely makes a great setting for a haunted place. This novel kept me flipping pages to figure out the ending. I had to slow down to make sure I read every word because I just wanted to find out the identity of the Watchman.
I’m such a fan of Jaime Jo Wright! Between the mystery that spans decades, the incredible imagery, and the broken and beautiful characters, this story is one of my favorites!
Overall: 5 stars (I loved it, couldn’t put it down)
Suspense: 5 stars (Non-stop edge-of-your-seat suspense from start to finish)
I received an ebook review copy of this book through NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus by Jaime Jo Wright takes readers on an epic journey. Set in two time periods with connecting mysteries, the story centers around a traveling circus in the late 1920’s. Pippa Ripley longs to connect to her real family. Abandoned by her parents, all she knows is that they once worked for the circus. A mysterious phantom of a man called The Watchman seems to hold the answers, if Pippa could find him. In the present time, Chandler Faulk tries to keep everything together. A single mother, she moves to Bluff River for work. She’s trying to renovate an old train depot but gets sucked into local lore that has the place pegged as haunted by the ghost of a murdered woman.
The novel enchants readers from the start. Jaime Jo Wright has an amazing way with words. The backdrop of the circus brings out incredible imagery – yet it’s almost a behind the scenes tour for the reader. The focus isn’t the glitz and glamour of the show with the big tents and epic acts. This is the story of the people who work in the shadows, the ones who live to entertain others but hide themselves behind a curtain. Jake Chambers is a brooding man that just wants justice for his sister’s murder. Clive is a dwarf dealing with being rejected because of his stature. Their stories come to light as they try to figure out the mystery behind the Watchman. No one knows who he is, but he appears around the circus in a burlap bag mask and is associated with a string of murders along the circus stops.
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus definitely gives off some creepy vibes. The author creates an ambiance of Gothic imagery that adds another layer to the imagery and plotline. It all works together to create this world full of magic and mystery, that spans decades and reaches into the broken hearts of the characters with offers of redemption and healing. Many of the character find refuge in the circus, yet the modern setting reflects the same hidden identities of the performers. Both Pippa and Chandler just want to be seen, they long for a place to call their own where they are known and loved. Their parallel stories seem to intersect seamlessly. Chandler tries so hard to overcome her past, that she self-destructs by thinking she can’t manage. Hank Titus brings warmth and depth into her life by seeing her for who she truly is and not expecting her to manage everything by herself.
As far as the suspense, the entire story is a complicated and twisted mystery. Chandler uncovers information about the 1920’s murder, and someone wants her to stop looking. The old train depot definitely makes a great setting for a haunted place. This novel kept me flipping pages to figure out the ending. I had to slow down to make sure I read every word because I just wanted to find out the identity of the Watchman.
I’m such a fan of Jaime Jo Wright! Between the mystery that spans decades, the incredible imagery, and the broken and beautiful characters, this story is one of my favorites!
Overall: 5 stars (I loved it, couldn’t put it down)
Suspense: 5 stars (Non-stop edge-of-your-seat suspense from start to finish)
I received an ebook review copy of this book through NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
August 29, 2020
"He was her Watchman. But more than that, she belonged to him."
Pippa Ripley has craved a sense of belonging her entire life. Given every advantage and opportunity as the daughter of a wealthy circus owner, she has also been forced to sacrifice the freedom to be seen for who she really is. When odd correspondences from an unknown watcher begin to escalate, Pippa valiantly strives to locate the person standing guard over the secrets of her past. Could a bruised and battered baby elephant become the catalyst for prodding Pippa's painful heritage out of the darkness and into the light? . . . . . or were her ministrations going to prove that just like the elephants, she might be treasured but not loved; for "love sacrificed, whereas a treasure was hoarded".
Real estate developer Chandler Faulk sees the restoration of the grand old circus grounds in Bluff River, Wisconsin as a way to prove herself; to prove that she is not only capable of being a single mother, but proficient enough to handle a large construction project with skill and determination. However, "No one told (her) before she'd recommended the purchase that the abandoned train depot her uncle had invested in was likely the site of an old murder".
"Life was not unlike the wisp of fog that curled around the base of a grave marker" . . . begins the author, creating an enticing aura of uncertainty about things to come. Unlike the eerie call of a siren within the wind, this story bravely beckons its readers to proceed toward danger rather than away from it, ultimately revealing that "what to us seems like God's biggest errors, to Him they are His largest promises".
Once again, Jaime Jo Wright has proven herself to be one of the most brilliant story plotters among authors of romantic suspense. Don't discount the methodical beginning, it only serves to heighten the anticipation of a stunning ending.
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
Pippa Ripley has craved a sense of belonging her entire life. Given every advantage and opportunity as the daughter of a wealthy circus owner, she has also been forced to sacrifice the freedom to be seen for who she really is. When odd correspondences from an unknown watcher begin to escalate, Pippa valiantly strives to locate the person standing guard over the secrets of her past. Could a bruised and battered baby elephant become the catalyst for prodding Pippa's painful heritage out of the darkness and into the light? . . . . . or were her ministrations going to prove that just like the elephants, she might be treasured but not loved; for "love sacrificed, whereas a treasure was hoarded".
Real estate developer Chandler Faulk sees the restoration of the grand old circus grounds in Bluff River, Wisconsin as a way to prove herself; to prove that she is not only capable of being a single mother, but proficient enough to handle a large construction project with skill and determination. However, "No one told (her) before she'd recommended the purchase that the abandoned train depot her uncle had invested in was likely the site of an old murder".
"Life was not unlike the wisp of fog that curled around the base of a grave marker" . . . begins the author, creating an enticing aura of uncertainty about things to come. Unlike the eerie call of a siren within the wind, this story bravely beckons its readers to proceed toward danger rather than away from it, ultimately revealing that "what to us seems like God's biggest errors, to Him they are His largest promises".
Once again, Jaime Jo Wright has proven herself to be one of the most brilliant story plotters among authors of romantic suspense. Don't discount the methodical beginning, it only serves to heighten the anticipation of a stunning ending.
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
October 14, 2020
I know I'm deep in the minority, but I didn't like this book. At. All. Chandler's obsession with Peter in wanting no one's help in raising him, paranoid her parents are trying to take custody of him and ESPECIALLY them still sleeping together in the same bed at night was DISTURBING!!! Both romantic interests (Jake Chapman and Hank Titus) were basically the exact same - long hair, beard, social outcasts, brooding, etc. And couldn't believe either of them would be attracted to wallflower Pippa or bitter stubborn Chandler.
I wouldn't even say this was Christian fiction, since the paranormal seem to take more center stage than Christianity. And none of the characters even remotely acted as though they had a relationship with Christ, except for Clive, but even his actions were questionable. I don't have a problem with that, but since it's touted as Christian fiction I thought it would have more sway in the storyline.
Obviously, others really liked this book but I couldn't wait to finish it so I could move on.
I wouldn't even say this was Christian fiction, since the paranormal seem to take more center stage than Christianity. And none of the characters even remotely acted as though they had a relationship with Christ, except for Clive, but even his actions were questionable. I don't have a problem with that, but since it's touted as Christian fiction I thought it would have more sway in the storyline.
Obviously, others really liked this book but I couldn't wait to finish it so I could move on.
January 15, 2021
I'll be honest, I very nearly did not finish this one. I enjoy mysteries, and I enjoy suspense . . . but this book was downright *creepy* in parts, which I don't particularly enjoy anymore. But, because I knew that a trusted friend finished the book and enjoyed the end, I persevered, and am glad I did so.
There's a lot going on in the book, both with the present day Chandler, and also Pippa back in the late 1920s. I appreciated the sense of community and 'found family' that was portrayed, especially for Pippa.
As to the who and the *why* of the 'haunting', in both timelines, I had suspicions, which mostly did not pan out and left me gasping in surprise at 'whodunnit'.
The faith thread was there, but not quite as strongly as I would have preferred. (I think I would have liked to see a whole lot more Jesus to counteract the 'creepy' vibe.)
There's a lot going on in the book, both with the present day Chandler, and also Pippa back in the late 1920s. I appreciated the sense of community and 'found family' that was portrayed, especially for Pippa.
As to the who and the *why* of the 'haunting', in both timelines, I had suspicions, which mostly did not pan out and left me gasping in surprise at 'whodunnit'.
The faith thread was there, but not quite as strongly as I would have preferred. (I think I would have liked to see a whole lot more Jesus to counteract the 'creepy' vibe.)
September 1, 2020
No one pens a more eerie tale than Jaime Jo Wright. She has mastered the craft of writing suspenseful split time novels with haunting plots that are chilling and full of surprises. The Haunting At Bonaventure Circus kept me guessing until the conclusion! Prepare yourself for twists and turns as this story unfolds! This has such a suspenseful and shocking ending, like hold your breath and just keep turning the pages! I love it when I’m surprised by an ending or shocked by a reveal of facts and this one delivers! This isn’t your typical trip to the circus, but it will definitely grab your attention and intrigue you! I would recommend this book for anyone who enjoys a good chilling and suspenseful read!
September 9, 2020
While not matte like the previous books by this author, the cover for The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus certainly is gorgeous! I’ve been eagerly anticipating this novel since the author began letting out pieces of information about it. :)
I loved Pippa’s story. Her part of this split-time story is set in 1928, and I became enthralled immediately. Pippa was such a tender-hearted, dear character. Insecure, and struggling to find her worth, but also strong and growing in her strength. It might be needless to say that her portion of the story was definitely my favorite ;) I loved the elephant aspect of it as well.
The contemporary portion held its own great characters and I appreciated Chandler having health complications that were very real and shown with care. I don’t have Lyme, but I am familiar with energy-loss and health problems, so it was nice to see such things represented in fiction.
It’s hard for me to find the words for this review because I really liked the book, but there were a couple aspects that I had a bit of a hard time with.I feel like the topic of ghosts was a lot stronger in this book than the others, and was never really resolved in the end. I expect some talk of ghosts in these books, but in the past, it always resulted in being concrete evidence of the occurrences and not encouraged to be dealing with ghosts. This book wasn’t really that way. That was one of the reasons I didn’t like the contemporary thread quite as much, because it was very heavily influenced by “the other side” and there was a character who was connected to that realm, and while the character even said that ‘whether its ghosts or demons, they’re still not to be trifled with’, the characters definitely trifled with them. I know views on ghosts and all are very different but I believe that the spiritual realm does exist, in demonic ways, and by playing around with them, it is opening a door, so it’s a serious thing. The characters didn’t take it seriously, and if it was just that one character I could let it go because yes, in life there are all sorts of people and representation of them is realistic, but the whole message of “maybe it was a ghost for real” at the end was disconcerting to me. I’m only pointing this out for readers who share my same beliefs and would want to know this content as well. I’m in no way attacking the author or how it is written – just stating my opinion of it so others can be aware too.
The mystery of both stories was very well done, and kept you intrigued and curious till the very end. The Watchman was eerie and the deaths sad, but it was all tied together in such a compelling manner.
As I said, I really liked Pippa’s story, and I loved Jake. He and Pippa were my favorite characters for certain! And Lily the elephant <3 Pippa struggled to ever feel like she was enough, so while it was mainly just from a human perspective, I’m glad she was able to find some reassurance on that in the end! The message of God being our true worth was there as a sweet undertone. I think it could’ve been shown with more power, but it was still nicely done.
All in all, I did really enjoy this novel, and think it was written beautifully as usual.
*I received a copy of the book from the publishers.
I loved Pippa’s story. Her part of this split-time story is set in 1928, and I became enthralled immediately. Pippa was such a tender-hearted, dear character. Insecure, and struggling to find her worth, but also strong and growing in her strength. It might be needless to say that her portion of the story was definitely my favorite ;) I loved the elephant aspect of it as well.
The contemporary portion held its own great characters and I appreciated Chandler having health complications that were very real and shown with care. I don’t have Lyme, but I am familiar with energy-loss and health problems, so it was nice to see such things represented in fiction.
It’s hard for me to find the words for this review because I really liked the book, but there were a couple aspects that I had a bit of a hard time with.I feel like the topic of ghosts was a lot stronger in this book than the others, and was never really resolved in the end. I expect some talk of ghosts in these books, but in the past, it always resulted in being concrete evidence of the occurrences and not encouraged to be dealing with ghosts. This book wasn’t really that way. That was one of the reasons I didn’t like the contemporary thread quite as much, because it was very heavily influenced by “the other side” and there was a character who was connected to that realm, and while the character even said that ‘whether its ghosts or demons, they’re still not to be trifled with’, the characters definitely trifled with them. I know views on ghosts and all are very different but I believe that the spiritual realm does exist, in demonic ways, and by playing around with them, it is opening a door, so it’s a serious thing. The characters didn’t take it seriously, and if it was just that one character I could let it go because yes, in life there are all sorts of people and representation of them is realistic, but the whole message of “maybe it was a ghost for real” at the end was disconcerting to me. I’m only pointing this out for readers who share my same beliefs and would want to know this content as well. I’m in no way attacking the author or how it is written – just stating my opinion of it so others can be aware too.
The mystery of both stories was very well done, and kept you intrigued and curious till the very end. The Watchman was eerie and the deaths sad, but it was all tied together in such a compelling manner.
As I said, I really liked Pippa’s story, and I loved Jake. He and Pippa were my favorite characters for certain! And Lily the elephant <3 Pippa struggled to ever feel like she was enough, so while it was mainly just from a human perspective, I’m glad she was able to find some reassurance on that in the end! The message of God being our true worth was there as a sweet undertone. I think it could’ve been shown with more power, but it was still nicely done.
All in all, I did really enjoy this novel, and think it was written beautifully as usual.
*I received a copy of the book from the publishers.
July 23, 2020
'Sometimes God brought peace in the most unusual and outside-the-norm ways.'
Once again the past and future collide in Jaime Jo Wright's signature time slip novel. She captured my attention with her very first book in this vein and it hasn't dimmed since. Love her work.
1928. Pippa has been abandoned in the circus and taken in by the owner. Bonaventure Circus is quite popular and they settle in this Wisconsin town in the winter. Strange goings on are noticed by many and Pippa is captured by the attention of The Watchman, who she believes knows the secret of her parentage. But her interest is going to lead to disastrous results if she isn't careful.
Present Day. Chandler Faulk is heading the renovation of the old circus train depot to restore its historical significance. She's carrying a heavy load with a newly diagnosed autoimmune disorder, and single parenthood. She accidentally discovers clues to the unsolved murders involving the circus of decades earlier. Soon she's in a battle for her life if she herself isn't careful.
Wright again takes us on a riveting and fast paced journey into the past as it slams into the present day. I love how she combines the two and propels the reader into both worlds, while at the same time, building the momentum until it crashes around you and you've never guessed who and what was going on. I devoured this! Recommended.
*My thanks to Bethany House Publishers for a copy of this book via Net Galley.
Once again the past and future collide in Jaime Jo Wright's signature time slip novel. She captured my attention with her very first book in this vein and it hasn't dimmed since. Love her work.
1928. Pippa has been abandoned in the circus and taken in by the owner. Bonaventure Circus is quite popular and they settle in this Wisconsin town in the winter. Strange goings on are noticed by many and Pippa is captured by the attention of The Watchman, who she believes knows the secret of her parentage. But her interest is going to lead to disastrous results if she isn't careful.
Present Day. Chandler Faulk is heading the renovation of the old circus train depot to restore its historical significance. She's carrying a heavy load with a newly diagnosed autoimmune disorder, and single parenthood. She accidentally discovers clues to the unsolved murders involving the circus of decades earlier. Soon she's in a battle for her life if she herself isn't careful.
Wright again takes us on a riveting and fast paced journey into the past as it slams into the present day. I love how she combines the two and propels the reader into both worlds, while at the same time, building the momentum until it crashes around you and you've never guessed who and what was going on. I devoured this! Recommended.
*My thanks to Bethany House Publishers for a copy of this book via Net Galley.
July 29, 2023
I didn’t think I would be reading another Jaime Jo Wright novel so soon. I had forgotten that this was in the pile of books that I gave my husband to pick out for me. He has two days left of picking my books for me.
Like the book I read previously by Wright, this has dual plotlines. One in 1928 and one in the present day. I will say this book had more of a ghost story feel.
I loved the 1920s plotline more than I did the present-day plotline. I would have loved the whole book in 1928. But at the same time, there were things found out in the present day that shed more light on what had happened in 1928 because of the evidence that was found surrounding who the “Watchman” was and what were his crimes.
I loved the romance more in the past plotline because it grew and was more believable than the present-day plotline. There were a few things I really didn’t like about the hero of the present day. I liked the 1928 hero. I just wished I could like them both but I didn’t.
I was stuck between giving this a 3-star and a 4-star. So I had to settle for a 3.5 star.
I will say Wright has beautiful writing. While I didn’t like this book as much as Echoes Among the Stones, I still loved the writing. I especially, loved how this book started. That first paragraph is still sticking out to me. I loved the first chapter. I really wished this book focused more on Pippa and the Watchman instead of having the present day.
~~~~~~~~
Rtc
Like the book I read previously by Wright, this has dual plotlines. One in 1928 and one in the present day. I will say this book had more of a ghost story feel.
I loved the 1920s plotline more than I did the present-day plotline. I would have loved the whole book in 1928. But at the same time, there were things found out in the present day that shed more light on what had happened in 1928 because of the evidence that was found surrounding who the “Watchman” was and what were his crimes.
I loved the romance more in the past plotline because it grew and was more believable than the present-day plotline. There were a few things I really didn’t like about the hero of the present day. I liked the 1928 hero. I just wished I could like them both but I didn’t.
I was stuck between giving this a 3-star and a 4-star. So I had to settle for a 3.5 star.
I will say Wright has beautiful writing. While I didn’t like this book as much as Echoes Among the Stones, I still loved the writing. I especially, loved how this book started. That first paragraph is still sticking out to me. I loved the first chapter. I really wished this book focused more on Pippa and the Watchman instead of having the present day.
~~~~~~~~
Rtc
October 13, 2020
Haunting. Chilling. Suspenseful. Meaningful. Author, Jaime Jo Wright, delivers a time-split historical mystery that left me on the edge of my seat with every page. There's not a lot of books that surprise me but this one had me biting my nails in anxious anticipation of what was coming next. I appreciated how the author wrote a story with a strong heroine who suffers from an auto-immune disease that's not often talked about. The authenticity it brought to the character had a level of depth not seen in many stories these days. Really, really enjoyed this story and would recommend it as a Top Ten Read of 2020!
October 22, 2020
The Haunting at Bonaventure Circus by Jaime Jo Wright is a fascinating and truly gripping mystery with deep themes of grace and light shining through darkness. With equally riveting time periods and compelling characters, this story draws the reader into the world of the circus, its people, and a unique look at how history has far-reaching threads into the present.
I really appreciate how both timelines and the heroines mirror each other in many ways. Pippa is learning to champion her independence while Chandler is fiercely fighting to maintain hers. Both heroes play crucial yet subtle roles, too, complimentary to each heroine. Both heroes are strong and protective, yet actively letting the heroines prove their capability. The colorful and unexpected cast of characters imparts both wisdom and insight into the web of mystery.
Wright’s style, a balance of creepy and lyrical, highlights the contrasts of human nature and grace, the evil lurking in the shadows and bright light of hope. I appreciate the way the realities of redemption, flaws of humanity, and the gift of being seen by those we care about the most was interwoven in a thrilling way.
I had my mind made up about 60% through of just WHO the culprit(s) were in the shadows. I was completely wrong! I love how Wright surprises me with every. single. one of her mysteries. Bravo!
Thank you to Bethany House Publishers for the review copy. This is my honest review.
I really appreciate how both timelines and the heroines mirror each other in many ways. Pippa is learning to champion her independence while Chandler is fiercely fighting to maintain hers. Both heroes play crucial yet subtle roles, too, complimentary to each heroine. Both heroes are strong and protective, yet actively letting the heroines prove their capability. The colorful and unexpected cast of characters imparts both wisdom and insight into the web of mystery.
Wright’s style, a balance of creepy and lyrical, highlights the contrasts of human nature and grace, the evil lurking in the shadows and bright light of hope. I appreciate the way the realities of redemption, flaws of humanity, and the gift of being seen by those we care about the most was interwoven in a thrilling way.
I had my mind made up about 60% through of just WHO the culprit(s) were in the shadows. I was completely wrong! I love how Wright surprises me with every. single. one of her mysteries. Bravo!
Thank you to Bethany House Publishers for the review copy. This is my honest review.
October 6, 2020
Review coming soon
Displaying 1 - 30 of 715 reviews