This book was really quite good despite it having me tear up a few times. Honestly I wouldn't call it horror. It's rather depressing, more than horrifying. Tim's death story is pretty disturbing. I found it difficult to not feel a pang of sadness each time his family was brought up. This book certainly won't elevate your fear of death. Mr. Groan does have his gross, creepy, and downright dark moments (but was honestly mostly meh for this horror snob). However, the general meloncholic setting feels way more sad than it does terrifying (which was probably augmented by my audiobook reader). Jesenta may be my new favorite character next to Wen from The Cabin at the End of the World. Is it just me, or is she a perfect description of Agnes from Despicable Me?
I think if there is anything horrifying about the book, it's Groan's gaslighting. You come to feel truly bad for Timothy and (this is not a spoiler because it's obvious from page one) Groan is a bully. While he certainly is an illiterate, dumb bully, he is also smart enough to convince Tim that he is incapable of thinking. The way you start to see his tactics unravel through the novel, and how you eventually see them for what they really are is pure art in my opinion. Groan moves from being just a bully like the ones you'd see on a playground to an actual manipulative narcissist. Personally, I find that to be the most scary part- way more than descriptions of gunk and gore. As a True Crime enthusiest, it's also not hard for me to see that this could be a reality even amung the living. To continue to be haunted by abuse even after you pass from life to death is.. well.. that IS terrifying.